Jimmy ...
#11
(05-10-2024, 09:55 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(05-10-2024, 06:18 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(05-10-2024, 06:05 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I don't share the haste for a Jimmy exit. One look at Ollie Robinson trudging in clearly unfit and painfully slow in the field and I'm hoping Jimmy is fine for a while yet. I'd like another look at Tongue and haven't seen enough of Atkinson but other than Wood's undoubted pace,  I don't see a plethora of potential. We had enough trouble replacing Strauss and Cook so I'm not looking forward to seeing the era of no Broad and Anderson.
Ollie Robinson should not be representing his country full stop.
Not totally his failings however.

Ollie Robinson plays for England because his step-dad is Paul Farbrace. His fitness, life-style and attitude issues are enough to have stalled anyone's career regardless of his undoubted talent, but cricket looks after its own.

The tour of India was a massive opportunity missed to have a better look at Potts and Tongue. Atkinson should have played a bigger part. If you're keen to keep the old guard going, why wasn't Woakes on the bus? Robinson let himself and England down again. But it's all OK 'cos Jimmy got his 700th wicket. Now it's time for a change.
Tongue is very injury prone, I do not think he has played this year.

Archer is unlikely to play much in the future, Wood and Woakes are also ageing and becoming increasingly injury prone so there are a lot of opportunities for young bowlers

For the first Test of the summer would think the pace bowlers will come from Anderson, Cook, Potts and then possibly C. Overton, Robinson, Coad, Atkinson, Lawes, Pennington
Reply
#12
(05-10-2024, 10:59 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Ollie Robinsons test bowling average is one of the best in the world.

He absolutely should be playing for England.

You beat me to it.  His record is extremely good.  His downfall is that when he’s not fully fit he looks very poor, but in terms of ability his record shows that he’s right up there. 

The likes of Potts, Tongue, Atkinson and Cook should all be forcing their way through.  I doubt it will happen but if Archer’s injuries stand up to the workload then we might see him bowling with a red ball again.   Jimmy has been outstanding but all good things must come to an end.  He should become England’s pace bowling coach - he has so much knowledge to pass on. 

As far as his retirement is concerned, I would have preferred it to have been done along the lines of “I’m retiring from Test cricket at the end of the summer and remain available for selection until then”.
Reply
#13
(05-10-2024, 10:59 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Ollie Robinsons test bowling average is one of the best in the world.

He absolutely should be playing for England.

Did you see him lumbering around in the 5th |ndia test? Miss-fielding, out of shape and generally looking like someone's dad that had been forced into a club game. I rated Ollie but he has a fitness and reflexes mountain to climb to get to proper Test standard.
Reply
#14
I think he still has something to offer. He's still taking wickets and keeps the run rate down. So I'd select him. But that's on the basis of the skill he brings to the team NOW, not to do with mis-placed sentiment.

If the coaches have seen something in the nets that he's lost ability and his body is now failing him, then that should be what he's judged on. Not what he's done in the past and certainly not on the sentiment to give him one last Test. Sentimental bollocks, that's not needed.

The team always should come first. Individual sentiment, or any sentiment for that matter, has no place in sport.
Reply
#15
Retiring in the summer.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: