(04-26-2024, 05:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Sorry? IS there a difference between "footprint" and "domicile"?Eh? Didn't you ask and imply there was a world of difference?
I presume the law is of the same kidney - I dug out some advice I gave a client a year ago or so (in Irish company "working out" of a London business address):
The law on AWRS states, inter alia that a “ ‘UK person” means a person who is UK-established for the purposes of value added tax (see paragraph 1(10) of Schedule 1 to the Value Added Tax Act 1994).” (ALDA s88A(9))
Paragraph 1(10) of Schedule 1 to the Value Added Tax Act 1994 states: “A person is “UK-established” if the person has a business establishment, or some other fixed establishment, in the United Kingdom in relation to a business carried on by the person.” So, for the Alcohol Wholesale Scheme (AWRS) (years 2015-16), the excise law borrows from VAT law. This is not used in the far looser and often imprecise WOWGR provisions of 1999 – no definitions are given which is what leads to vague terms like “footprints” of businesses not otherwise established in the UK (but may also trespass into the AWRS interpretations of Notice 2002)).
I am next quoting HMRC’s Notice 2002, which, so far as I can make out reflects the law and probably the VAT case law but still does not give a wholly complete picture:
“3.1 Who is liable to be approved under the AWRS
Part 6A of ALDA 1979 sets out the scope of AWRS. Businesses will need to consider if they:
are established in the UK (see paragraphs 3.2 to 3.4)
carry on a controlled activity (see paragraphs 3.5 to 3.11)
You need to read all of these sections to decide whether you need to be approved.”
3.2 What is meant by ‘UK established’
A person or business is considered to be UK established if they have a business establishment, or some other fixed establishment in the UK in relation to a business carried on by them (ie reflecting the VAT law/definition)
3.3 What is meant by a ‘business establishment’
The business establishment is the place where the main functions of the business’s central administration are carried out. This will usually be the head office, headquarters or ‘seat’ from which the business is run. This is where essential day to day decisions concerning the general management of the business are taken.
3.4 What is meant by a ‘fixed establishment’
A fixed establishment is an establishment other than the business establishment, which has the human and technical resources necessary for providing or receiving services permanently present. A business may have several fixed establishments, which may include a branch or agency. If you have a temporary presence of human and technical resources, this does not create a fixed establishment in the UK.
Examples of a fixed establishment include:
an overseas business sets up a branch comprising staff and offices in the UK to arrange wholesale sales of alcohol imported from outside the UK, the UK branch is a fixed establishment
an overseas business sets up a UK subsidiary to act in its name to arrange wholesale sales in the UK, the overseas business has a fixed establishment in the UK created by the agency of the subsidiary
Examples where there’s not a fixed establishment include:
an overseas company that registers or is incorporated at their accountant’s address but has no other offices or staff in that country
the presence of computer servers alone within a country
the existence of a UK VAT registration without any supporting resources in the UK
5.5 Imports from overseas wholesalers
AWRS will not extend beyond the boundaries of the UK, so wholesalers with no establishment in the UK do not have to be approved.” (This takes us round in circles somewhat).
I am unclear whether X would fall within a category that requires AWRS approval. And probably HMRC led to look at the situation as I referred to the other cases I am dealing with for WOWGR where HMRC stated: “Payments have been made by X Ltd (UK) to Y Co to cover the payment of staff salaries, for those employed by the company (non-UK)”
I have, in fact, referred matters of ambiguity to Officer B at HMRC Policy responsible for AWRS who to told me that if there was any doubt, the trader should make the application and HMRC would look at the individual circumstances and decide whether registration is appropriate. The danger again is not doing this, considering AWRS does not apply to the non-UK businesses but HMRC decides there is a footprint and then one is way behind the game and facing sanctions and (at best) temporary inability to trade in duty-paid alcohol.
I hope this is helpful.


