What the UK could learn from Ireland
#1
A 12.5% corporate rate since 1997 has resulted in a lot of companies going to Ireland. When they have 'windfall' years it puts a lot of money in the hands of the State. The last two years have had significant surpluses.

The secret is not to spend it all at once. Ireland is aiming to establish a £86bn sovereign wealth fund by the 2030's.

The UK last had a Budget surplus in 2000/2001. That's a generation ago.


https://www.ft.com/content/6e923f7a-cef0...c2e8910442

Oh, and 1000 Higher Rate taxpayers have left high tax Scotland since 2022, costing the Scottish economy £61m in revenue.

I'm sure there are some lessons to be learned here.
Reply
#2
I think you're wrong here. Taxing everyone more, especially those on higher and median incomes, is obviously the only way to go.
Reply
#3
Yeah 5M population against 65M is a great comparison. We should look at the Seychelles for their tax schemes, that’s bound to work as well

You’ve also got to ask yourself why so many companies have relocated to Ireland since 2016.

You know what I was saying about your binary thought processes.
Reply
#4
Singapore-on-Thames, Goddammit!

<shakes fist>
Reply
#5
The only part of the UK that this would work is Northern Ireland, given it's small population and it being in the single market and the customs union. The Treasury would never relinquish control to the Northern Irish government though, the Northern Irish government could collapse for any stupid reason and it would result in revenues from GB going down. Gibraltar would also technically work for the same reasons but that's already a tax haven.

The UK is also a signatory to the OECD agreement on Corporation Tax, I'm seriously questioning how much thought you've put into the externalities on this one.
Reply
#6
It's entirely consistent with corporate tax simplification, reducing reliefs and lowering the rate to say, 15% which is the floor in the OECD agreement.

(04-26-2024, 09:49 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You’ve also got to ask yourself why so many companies have relocated to Ireland since 2016.

I've answered that in the original post. Financial Services firms moved largely for tax incentives, and not just corporation tax.
Reply
#7
Without wanting to come over all ‘more qualified than yow’ on the subject but I work in FS and we have an operation in Ireland. I look after the regulation part of the entity and trust me, it’s become much more difficult to operate there without a footprint in the last couple of years.
Reply
#8
(04-26-2024, 10:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Without wanting to come over all ‘more qualified than yow’ on the subject but I work in FS and we have an operation in Ireland. I look after the regulation part of the entity and trust me, it’s become much more difficult to operate there without a footprint in the last couple of years.

Kept that quiet whilst it was getting competitive on here didn't you? Coward. 

Big Grin
Reply
#9
(04-26-2024, 11:24 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(04-26-2024, 10:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Without wanting to come over all ‘more qualified than yow’ on the subject but I work in FS and we have an operation in Ireland. I look after the regulation part of the entity and trust me, it’s become much more difficult to operate there without a footprint in the last couple of years.

Kept that quiet whilst it was getting competitive on here didn't you? Coward. 

Big Grin

I watched with much amusement Ted  Big Grin

Anyway what would be the fun in letting Proth tell me what an FS firm in Ireland does
Reply
#10
(04-26-2024, 10:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Without wanting to come over all ‘more qualified than yow’ on the subject but I work in FS and we have an operation in Ireland. I look after the regulation part of the entity and trust me, it’s become much more difficult to operate there without a footprint in the last couple of years.

There's a world of difference between a "footprint" and a "domicile". I'd have thought someone more qualified than me would know that.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)