Here we go again
(04-21-2024, 03:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 02:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 01:24 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 10:19 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
  • Any party political campaign is bound legally to telling the truth.
Also morally politicians should be held to a much higher standard than others because they have decided they want to make the rules we all have to adhere to. Sanctions if they fail to live up to those standards should be a zero tolerance rule book and mean a by-election and expulsion from political life.

Who on Earth would be a politician in an era where people like you, particularly exceptionally sanctimonious people like you, can't handle the truth?

Hit a nerve with this I see. If you seek public office then the standards you should adhere to should be above those of others who know they haven’t or couldn’t live up to them. Btw you aren’t Jack Nicholson dear.

You might like them to tell you the truth, but you couldn't handle the truth they'd be compelled tell you. You'd never vote for them. Nor would anyone else.

The truth of the matter is that both main parties have already committed to either exceptionally deep cuts in public expenditure after the next election, or even more borrowing or even more taxation (most likely a combination of all three). Neither of them are telling you this. Instead we're having pointless arguments about VAT on school fees, putting non-doms off staying here, tax "cuts" which are nothing of the sort and employing a few more folks at the HMRC to chase down evasion. 

None of this touches the sides of problem actually measured in the high tens of £billions each year.

Neither party will tell you the truth about the unwinding of QE. Neither will tell you that inflation target is likely to be increased to 3% to help inflate away debt (and so your money halves in value every 20 years or so). Neither will tell you that we're back in an era where long term interest rates have reverted to the historic mean rather than the zero interest rates prevalent during the most destructive monetary experiment in history over the last 16 years.

Jeremy Hunt is lying to you. Rachel Reeves is lying to you. They both know they're doing it and you're queueing on the left.

[Image: EVigSd1X0AIW4BD.jpg]

I’m as cynical as you will ever be politically, the difference is your ‘truth’ always seems to punch down never up. It’s never ‘unpleasant truth’s’ for the rich and privileged. That is a political choice not a truth. I’m as exasperated with Labour trying to park on traditional Tory territory as I am with this awful government but under our archaic first past the post democracy that’s where we are. The idea I can’t handle the truth and I need to be lied to is nonsense I don’t like the lies or ‘truths’ they are both peddling.
Reply
You have never provided a single solution to any of the problems you constantly carp about.

You'll have to explain, please, how removing distortions from the tax system that the wealthy take advantage of is "punching down". You have to explain, please, how replacing SDLT (partially avoidable), Business Rates (partially avoidable by all means of contortions), Council Tax (based on 1990 valuations) and Inheritance Tax (wholly avoidable) with a Land Value Tax (wholly unavoidable) is "punching down".

The richest and most privileged already subsidise the rest of us with the huge amount of tax they pay. "Punching Up" would / does inevitably lead to behavioural change and capital flight. Feel free to shoot the golden goose if it makes you feel less bitter for 5 minutes, but it won't take long for you to discover there'll be no more omelettes. I'm not really for punching in any direction, least of all in my own face - which is generally what people like you want. That's why you queue to the left - you can't face the hard choices.
Reply
(04-21-2024, 10:34 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 10:25 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 10:19 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
  • Simplify tax, close all loopholes and diddums to the industry that has been built around circumventing it.
  • Any party political campaign is bound legally to telling the truth. Those who do not adhere to this face criminal prosecution not fines. The industrial scale misdirection shall we say by the Tories at the last election has set the tone for the parties behaviour in government. Which let’s face it has been has been appalling.
  • Pay a larger salary for MPs but no outside jobs allowed, expenses cut to the bare bone, no donations allowed and if found to have received one instant by-election
  • Election campaign funds restricted and paid for from public money not by donors, lobbying, business, media companies.
  • Less holidays as they have silly amounts of time off.
  • Privatise public transport or insist that routes are chosen on need not just profitability
  • Privatise water there is no excuse for failing monopolies creaming millions of pounds off the general public in profit.
  • Energy companies profits capped and any excess is taxed or subsidises the most vulnerable.
  • Legislate that local companies are prioritised as suppliers to local government and NHS rather than contracts given to Serco and other large dubiously connected businesses who have a history of poor service but continue to procure large contracts.

Hi Maggie

Well spotted  Big Grin

Especially like the bit about mps having less holiday time! We trust that most if not all teachers work hard during their long holidays but doubt we have the same trust in our politicians! Maybe law should state they have to be working in their local office during all holidays bar 6 weeks of the year as annual leave entitlement or the standard 28 days most of us get!

(04-21-2024, 09:34 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(04-20-2024, 02:24 PM)FenlandBoing Wrote:
(04-19-2024, 04:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Inheritance Tax is pretty much a voluntary tax, paid by the legally ignorant or terminally useless. You'd make enough revenue from a Land Value Tax to more than make up IHT, Business Rates and Council Tax combined. You'd have the additional benefit of encouraging speculators to sell land for more productive uses - like housing or the big sheds we need. There's very little downside risk to LVT.

Osborne was moving towards simpler taxation - particularly Corporate Taxation - by removing all the distorting allowances and just reducing the rate. It worked perfectly for Corporation Tax where the take went up. Sunak has dismantled that route to 13%, massively increased the rate and added back in all sorts of distorting allowances. The tax take will go down. You literally can't make this shit up.

Similarly with personal taxation, the system is beset with pitfalls and cliff edges which act to disincentivise. There's a member of this Board who got a better paid job and was then presented with a £7,000 bill for overpaid Child Benefit. What a fucking reward for wanting to better yourself?

As it is the complex tax system rewards only those off PAYE like me. We can alter our behaviour by the day; For instance if Starmer puts up Corporation Tax I will simply pay myself more in Pension Contributions and less in salary and dividends to bring my Corporation Tax bill down. I can also put other benefits through my directors loan account so they don't attract BIK - employees can't do that.

Ending these distortions incrementally and moving away from the ridiculous contortions so many of us go through to maximise the benefit to our families v HMRC ought to be the aim of every government. Yet every one over the last 40 years has merely made the situation worse.

Why is the tax system so complicated in the first place? Why isn't it 10 simple rules/laws so it is transparent enough for everyone who has a D at GCSE maths to understand it? First rule could be every business whether making loss or profit pays 1-2% tax every month direct to govt. I'm sure with your knowledge you could fill in the other 9 rules/laws? (that's a serious point not sarcasm btw).
This exactly. And every tweak costs more to implement than it can hope to bring in.

My business is in a sector where the govt are crying out for extra placements for clients they have and I could easily expand (double) my business to meet that need, but it just isn't worth the effort with the taxation system this govt have expanded nor do I want to give more money to them for my hard work. They've taken away the desire of people to do better and create wealth because of the govts greed, corruption and overall failings.
Reply
(04-19-2024, 04:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Inheritance Tax is pretty much a voluntary tax, paid by the legally ignorant or terminally useless. You'd make enough revenue from a Land Value Tax to more than make up IHT, Business Rates and Council Tax combined. You'd have the additional benefit of encouraging speculators to sell land for more productive uses - like housing or the big sheds we need. There's very little downside risk to LVT.

Osborne was moving towards simpler taxation - particularly Corporate Taxation - by removing all the distorting allowances and just reducing the rate. It worked perfectly for Corporation Tax where the take went up. Sunak has dismantled that route to 13%, massively increased the rate and added back in all sorts of distorting allowances. The tax take will go down. You literally can't make this shit up.

Similarly with personal taxation, the system is beset with pitfalls and cliff edges which act to disincentivise. There's a member of this Board who got a better paid job and was then presented with a £7,000 bill for overpaid Child Benefit. What a fucking reward for wanting to better yourself?

As it is the complex tax system rewards only those off PAYE like me. We can alter our behaviour by the day; For instance if Starmer puts up Corporation Tax I will simply pay myself more in Pension Contributions and less in salary and dividends to bring my Corporation Tax bill down. I can also put other benefits through my directors loan account so they don't attract BIK - employees can't do that.

Ending these distortions incrementally and moving away from the ridiculous contortions so many of us go through to maximise the benefit to our families v HMRC ought to be the aim of every government. Yet every one over the last 40 years has merely made the situation worse.

That bit about pension contributions is mostly untrue mon. Most employers will allow you to salary sacrifice as much as you like into your pension. They should also be topping it up with their employer’s NIC savings.

Everyone should be loading their pension up to the absolute max possibly every year - it’s the best investment you can make.
Reply
(04-24-2024, 06:50 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(04-19-2024, 04:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Inheritance Tax is pretty much a voluntary tax, paid by the legally ignorant or terminally useless. You'd make enough revenue from a Land Value Tax to more than make up IHT, Business Rates and Council Tax combined. You'd have the additional benefit of encouraging speculators to sell land for more productive uses - like housing or the big sheds we need. There's very little downside risk to LVT.

Osborne was moving towards simpler taxation - particularly Corporate Taxation - by removing all the distorting allowances and just reducing the rate. It worked perfectly for Corporation Tax where the take went up. Sunak has dismantled that route to 13%, massively increased the rate and added back in all sorts of distorting allowances. The tax take will go down. You literally can't make this shit up.

Similarly with personal taxation, the system is beset with pitfalls and cliff edges which act to disincentivise. There's a member of this Board who got a better paid job and was then presented with a £7,000 bill for overpaid Child Benefit. What a fucking reward for wanting to better yourself?

As it is the complex tax system rewards only those off PAYE like me. We can alter our behaviour by the day; For instance if Starmer puts up Corporation Tax I will simply pay myself more in Pension Contributions and less in salary and dividends to bring my Corporation Tax bill down. I can also put other benefits through my directors loan account so they don't attract BIK - employees can't do that.

Ending these distortions incrementally and moving away from the ridiculous contortions so many of us go through to maximise the benefit to our families v HMRC ought to be the aim of every government. Yet every one over the last 40 years has merely made the situation worse.

That bit about pension contributions is mostly untrue mon. Most employers will allow you to salary sacrifice as much as you like into your pension. They should also be topping it up with their employer’s NIC savings.

Everyone should be loading their pension up to the absolute max possibly every year - it’s the best investment you can make.

May need to re-word that as I don't think that £60k per annum put into your pension is a fair expectation  Big Grin

Half your age as a percentage (including employer contribution) is fair. I'd also recommend getting a SIPP and annually transferring over from a workplace pension so you can better define the risk levels (no point being on a low-risk pension plan if you are younger than 50 in my opinion).
Reply
(04-24-2024, 06:56 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: May need to re-word that as I don't think that £60k per annum put into your pension is a fair expectation  Big Grin

Exactly.
Reply
(04-24-2024, 08:30 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-24-2024, 06:56 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: May need to re-word that as I don't think that £60k per annum put into your pension is a fair expectation  Big Grin

Exactly.

Your point seemed to be that you are powerless as an employee to make tax-efficient extra contributions to your pension? 

The £60k max per year is neither here nor there. You can only put it what you can afford whether you’re employed or self-employed. Kind of goes without saying really…
Reply
My point is that it's far easier to optimise the amount of tax you pay if you are in complete control of your own payroll and benefits. Most employees are not.
Reply
(04-25-2024, 07:48 AM)Protheroe Wrote: My point is that it's far easier to optimise the amount of tax you pay if you are in complete control of your own payroll and benefits. Most employees are not.

I’ve just pointed out exactly how most are, though?

The big advantage of being SE - as I’m sure you’re well aware - is the dodgy expenses going through the books Wink
Reply
I wouldn't know about that.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)