Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
04-22-2024, 11:06 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-22-2024, 11:07 AM by AnelkasBeard.)
(04-22-2024, 09:48 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (04-22-2024, 05:21 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (04-21-2024, 08:28 PM)Duffers Wrote: (04-21-2024, 07:51 PM)wbamitch Wrote: (04-21-2024, 05:39 PM)Duffers Wrote: No but if you have to draw lines and measure to the milimetre then the decision to award or not is neither clear nor obvious. Ergo VAR should not, by its own definition, intervene.
Said before that VAR should only ever be used in exceptional circumstances. You should only be seeing one or two VAR decisions a week across all fixtures. Not three or four per game.
I agree with you that it shouldn’t be used as frequently as it is, but what would you suggest defines clear and obvious for offsides? They have to work with something, and no matter what you introduce there will be times where somebody is a millimetre offside
My view is that if an offside can’t be spotted by the naked eye in real time then give the attacking team the benefit of the doubt. Anything that involves drawing lines on the field and measuring to the milimetre does not fit the definition of clear and obvious.
There’s an element of common sense that needs to be involved. It’s usually pretty obvious which decisions are tight 50/50 calls and which are obviously wrong.
The “clear and obvious” requirement doesn’t apply to offsides, which is binary
Offsides are binary but VAR's determination of them is extremely subjective much as a linesman's determination of them is.
Yesterday's VAR line wasn't drawn properly as it overlapped with Wan Bissaka's toe and if you choose the next frame to draw the lines then Wright is onside. That's two subjective decisions there that have have favoured Man United owing to the margin of error, another day with a different set of officials and you could very easily produce a different outcome for an identical scenario.
I came here to say exactly this. The line is obviously over Wan-Bissaka's foot. If it's drawn properly, Wright is onside. So there's one fuck up.
Second potential fuck up, are we sure that the still image they used is when the ball precisely left the Cov players foot for the pass? I don't know either way, but with such a close decision, it seems wild to specify.
Even ignoring those two subjective, human decisions, I'm amazed I've only seen one comment on this thread about the margin for error of the cameras/line tech. This was a millimetre decision, and margin for error hasn't been accounted for at all? In terms of the ball leaving the foot, and the drawn line. Both could be out by millimetres, thus putting Wright onside or offside, depending on how the officials wanted it.
Not a sausage would have complained about that goal being given if VAR hadn't thrust itself in to the picture. It completely and utterly ruins the enjoyment of the sport we love. One of the best moments potentially ever in the history of the FA Cup and we're arguing over millimetres instead.
Football is finally dead.
Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(04-22-2024, 09:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (04-22-2024, 09:48 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (04-22-2024, 05:21 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (04-21-2024, 08:28 PM)Duffers Wrote: (04-21-2024, 07:51 PM)wbamitch Wrote: I agree with you that it shouldn’t be used as frequently as it is, but what would you suggest defines clear and obvious for offsides? They have to work with something, and no matter what you introduce there will be times where somebody is a millimetre offside
My view is that if an offside can’t be spotted by the naked eye in real time then give the attacking team the benefit of the doubt. Anything that involves drawing lines on the field and measuring to the milimetre does not fit the definition of clear and obvious.
There’s an element of common sense that needs to be involved. It’s usually pretty obvious which decisions are tight 50/50 calls and which are obviously wrong.
The “clear and obvious” requirement doesn’t apply to offsides, which is binary
Offsides are binary but VAR's determination of them is extremely subjective much as a linesman's determination of them is.
Yesterday's VAR line wasn't drawn properly as it overlapped with Wan Bissaka's toe and if you choose the next frame to draw the lines then Wright is onside. That's two subjective decisions there that have have favoured Man United owing to the margin of error, another day with a different set of officials and you could very easily produce a different outcome for an identical scenario.
I have to agree with the above. Duffers point about the line not helping spot the actual instant the ball leaves the player's foot and BBs point about where the line is drawn frame-wise. Probably the easiest example of why the Clear and Obvious Error rule SHOULD be implemented.
Yes I agree totally with that
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(04-22-2024, 11:06 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (04-22-2024, 09:48 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (04-22-2024, 05:21 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (04-21-2024, 08:28 PM)Duffers Wrote: (04-21-2024, 07:51 PM)wbamitch Wrote: I agree with you that it shouldn’t be used as frequently as it is, but what would you suggest defines clear and obvious for offsides? They have to work with something, and no matter what you introduce there will be times where somebody is a millimetre offside
My view is that if an offside can’t be spotted by the naked eye in real time then give the attacking team the benefit of the doubt. Anything that involves drawing lines on the field and measuring to the milimetre does not fit the definition of clear and obvious.
There’s an element of common sense that needs to be involved. It’s usually pretty obvious which decisions are tight 50/50 calls and which are obviously wrong.
The “clear and obvious” requirement doesn’t apply to offsides, which is binary
Offsides are binary but VAR's determination of them is extremely subjective much as a linesman's determination of them is.
Yesterday's VAR line wasn't drawn properly as it overlapped with Wan Bissaka's toe and if you choose the next frame to draw the lines then Wright is onside. That's two subjective decisions there that have have favoured Man United owing to the margin of error, another day with a different set of officials and you could very easily produce a different outcome for an identical scenario.
I came here to say exactly this. The line is obviously over Wan-Bissaka's foot. If it's drawn properly, Wright is onside. So there's one fuck up.
Second potential fuck up, are we sure that the still image they used is when the ball precisely left the Cov players foot for the pass? I don't know either way, but with such a close decision, it seems wild to specify.
Even ignoring those two subjective, human decisions, I'm amazed I've only seen one comment on this thread about the margin for error of the cameras/line tech. This was a millimetre decision, and margin for error hasn't been accounted for at all? In terms of the ball leaving the foot, and the drawn line. Both could be out by millimetres, thus putting Wright onside or offside, depending on how the officials wanted it.
Not a sausage would have complained about that goal being given if VAR hadn't thrust itself in to the picture. It completely and utterly ruins the enjoyment of the sport we love. One of the best moments potentially ever in the history of the FA Cup and we're arguing over millimetres instead.
Football is finally dead.
Totally agree. To use VAR with a mm to flag someone offside, when the margin for error of frame rates on when the camera is stopped is comparatively massive, and way more than the amount the bloke was “offside”, is utterly ludicrous.
Posts: 7,371
Threads: 181
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
27
Can't argue with that. I've been saying this for ages that very tight offsides cannot be determined by VAR as it is currently. The equipment isn't that accurate.
Posts: 27,981
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
We should move to vibes based refereeing. What decision provides the funniest outcome?
Posts: 4,668
Threads: 183
Joined: Nov 2022
Reputation:
14
Get rid of offside and bring back goal hanging.
(04-22-2024, 01:45 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: Get rid of offside and bring back goal hanging.
Bring back hanging
Posts: 4,322
Threads: 139
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(04-22-2024, 12:07 PM)Duffers Wrote: We should move to vibes based refereeing. What decision provides the funniest outcome?
|