Posts: 10,863
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(04-22-2024, 07:19 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: If they insist on continuing with offside calls being done on VAR a better and easier rule would be for a player to be onside if both players have any part of their body in the same section of lines drawn. It would also uphold the original point of what the rule was for and not punish the attacking team for minor margins
Spot on. Absolutely. And so easy to enforce to.
Posts: 527
Threads: 0
Joined: Dec 2020
Reputation:
4
Whether anybody likes it or not, Haji Wright was offside. If United had scored that it would have been disallowed as well. Nobody here would be arguing that a great FA Cup moment had been ruined then would they?
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(04-22-2024, 08:08 AM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: Whether anybody likes it or not, Haji Wright was offside. If United had scored that it would have been disallowed as well. Nobody here would be arguing that a great FA Cup moment had been ruined then would they?
Hands up who actually believes this?
Posts: 527
Threads: 0
Joined: Dec 2020
Reputation:
4
(04-22-2024, 08:18 AM)Duffers Wrote: (04-22-2024, 08:08 AM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: Whether anybody likes it or not, Haji Wright was offside. If United had scored that it would have been disallowed as well. Nobody here would be arguing that a great FA Cup moment had been ruined then would they?
Hands up who actually believes this?
The Big 6 have had plenty of goals like that disallowed. Coventry also had a penalty for handball that wouldn’t usually be given, especially as late in the game as it was. If VAR was biased towards United they’d have overturned that.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(04-22-2024, 08:30 AM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: (04-22-2024, 08:18 AM)Duffers Wrote: (04-22-2024, 08:08 AM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: Whether anybody likes it or not, Haji Wright was offside. If United had scored that it would have been disallowed as well. Nobody here would be arguing that a great FA Cup moment had been ruined then would they?
Hands up who actually believes this?
The Big 6 have had plenty of goals like that disallowed. Coventry also had a penalty for handball that wouldn’t usually be given, especially as late in the game as it was. If VAR was biased towards United they’d have overturned that.
Agree.
Posts: 3,032
Threads: 78
Joined: Jun 2019
Reputation:
22
04-22-2024, 08:44 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-22-2024, 08:46 AM by Ossian.)
(04-22-2024, 07:19 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: If they insist on continuing with offside calls being done on VAR a better and easier rule would be for a player to be onside if both players have any part of their body in the same section of lines drawn. It would also uphold the original point of what the rule was for and not punish the attacking team for minor margins
Perhaps the solution is a version of the 'torso' rule, as used in athletics finishes. It would at least rid us of these 'was the kneecap played on by the defender's toe?' debates.
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(04-22-2024, 08:44 AM)Ossian Wrote: (04-22-2024, 07:19 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: If they insist on continuing with offside calls being done on VAR a better and easier rule would be for a player to be onside if both players have any part of their body in the same section of lines drawn. It would also uphold the original point of what the rule was for and not punish the attacking team for minor margins
Perhaps the solution is a version of the 'torso' rule, as used in athletics finishes. It would at least rid us of these 'was the kneecap played on by the defenders toe' debates.
Fuck it, I'd go for daylight between players.
If any body part of an attacker overlaps with any defender's then it's onside.
Posts: 3,884
Threads: 161
Joined: Mar 2022
(04-22-2024, 08:47 AM)Duffers Wrote: (04-22-2024, 08:44 AM)Ossian Wrote: (04-22-2024, 07:19 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: If they insist on continuing with offside calls being done on VAR a better and easier rule would be for a player to be onside if both players have any part of their body in the same section of lines drawn. It would also uphold the original point of what the rule was for and not punish the attacking team for minor margins
Perhaps the solution is a version of the 'torso' rule, as used in athletics finishes. It would at least rid us of these 'was the kneecap played on by the defenders toe' debates.
Fuck it, I'd go for daylight between players.
If any body part of an attacker overlaps with any defender's then it's onside.
I was trying to work out how to say it 100% duffers it's getting ridiculous now ....they don't have the technology to work out when it actually left the boot to when the player made the run
Posts: 2,465
Threads: 34
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(04-22-2024, 08:30 AM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: (04-22-2024, 08:18 AM)Duffers Wrote: (04-22-2024, 08:08 AM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: Whether anybody likes it or not, Haji Wright was offside. If United had scored that it would have been disallowed as well. Nobody here would be arguing that a great FA Cup moment had been ruined then would they?
Hands up who actually believes this?
The Big 6 have had plenty of goals like that disallowed. Coventry also had a penalty for handball that wouldn’t usually be given, especially as late in the game as it was. If VAR was biased towards United they’d have overturned that.
Agree it was a harsh penalty but don't think VAR would have overruled either way because handball is very much a referee's interpretation at the time. If the ref gives it VAR can only say it wasn't handball if it actually didn't hit the player's hand/arm. There have been plenty of penalties given when the ball has ricocheted off the defenders leg onto their hand which, again, is a very harsh call.
Posts: 8,000
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
Coventry are the true winners of this season's FA Cup anyway, let's face it. I would rather stick wasps in my eyes than watch a City Utd final, so the competition is now over in my eyes.
Cov flew the flag for real football, came out with their heads held high and landed a blow for the greater football community. I'm glad it ended the way it did, with them going toe to toe with the bully and holding their own, despite it never being a fair fight. If they'd gone through and got trounced by the next bully off the rank, this game, and it's impact, would have been too easily forgotten.
It's also a great advert for why the semis at Wembley can be a good thing. That was Cov's cup final and, in terms of dignity and humility, they won it by a million miles.
|