Here we go again
Inheritance Tax is pretty much a voluntary tax, paid by the legally ignorant or terminally useless. You'd make enough revenue from a Land Value Tax to more than make up IHT, Business Rates and Council Tax combined. You'd have the additional benefit of encouraging speculators to sell land for more productive uses - like housing or the big sheds we need. There's very little downside risk to LVT.

Osborne was moving towards simpler taxation - particularly Corporate Taxation - by removing all the distorting allowances and just reducing the rate. It worked perfectly for Corporation Tax where the take went up. Sunak has dismantled that route to 13%, massively increased the rate and added back in all sorts of distorting allowances. The tax take will go down. You literally can't make this shit up.

Similarly with personal taxation, the system is beset with pitfalls and cliff edges which act to disincentivise. There's a member of this Board who got a better paid job and was then presented with a £7,000 bill for overpaid Child Benefit. What a fucking reward for wanting to better yourself?

As it is the complex tax system rewards only those off PAYE like me. We can alter our behaviour by the day; For instance if Starmer puts up Corporation Tax I will simply pay myself more in Pension Contributions and less in salary and dividends to bring my Corporation Tax bill down. I can also put other benefits through my directors loan account so they don't attract BIK - employees can't do that.

Ending these distortions incrementally and moving away from the ridiculous contortions so many of us go through to maximise the benefit to our families v HMRC ought to be the aim of every government. Yet every one over the last 40 years has merely made the situation worse.
Reply
(04-19-2024, 04:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Inheritance Tax is pretty much a voluntary tax, paid by the legally ignorant or terminally useless. You'd make enough revenue from a Land Value Tax to more than make up IHT, Business Rates and Council Tax combined. You'd have the additional benefit of encouraging speculators to sell land for more productive uses - like housing or the big sheds we need. There's very little downside risk to LVT.

Osborne was moving towards simpler taxation - particularly Corporate Taxation - by removing all the distorting allowances and just reducing the rate. It worked perfectly for Corporation Tax where the take went up. Sunak has dismantled that route to 13%, massively increased the rate and added back in all sorts of distorting allowances. The tax take will go down. You literally can't make this shit up.

Similarly with personal taxation, the system is beset with pitfalls and cliff edges which act to disincentivise. There's a member of this Board who got a better paid job and was then presented with a £7,000 bill for overpaid Child Benefit. What a fucking reward for wanting to better yourself?

As it is the complex tax system rewards only those off PAYE like me. We can alter our behaviour by the day; For instance if Starmer puts up Corporation Tax I will simply pay myself more in Pension Contributions and less in salary and dividends to bring my Corporation Tax bill down. I can also put other benefits through my directors loan account so they don't attract BIK - employees can't do that.

Ending these distortions incrementally and moving away from the ridiculous contortions so many of us go through to maximise the benefit to our families v HMRC ought to be the aim of every government. Yet every one over the last 40 years has merely made the situation worse.

What about scrapping Corporation Tax and having a sales tax, Nigel Lawson was in favour of this

As regards inheritance tax, I think there are a few ethical issues here. In particular it gives a great advantage to those who have rich families and are from families where there are few children so they inherit from aunts and uncles. There is also the issue  about the origin of wealth, is the MP most in favour of this the grandson of the finance minister of a dicttorship.
Reply
You want a sales tax on top of 20% VAT? Hmm. I’m not sure that’ll fly. Particularly in inflationary times when firms are using every trick to shore up and enhance margins.

IHT is a voluntary tax. Any decent private client solicitor will be able to help the vast majority of people avoid it entirely. As such, it’s pointless.
Reply
Iam sure a few of us here have parents/ relatives with £20 million estates, can you please advise us how we can avoid inheritance tax
Reply
(04-20-2024, 06:30 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Iam sure a few of us here have parents/ relatives with £20 million estates, can you please advise us how we can avoid inheritance tax

Trusts.

The Duke of Westminster's £9bn Grosvenor Estate for instance, has never been subject to IHT.

The only people who's estates are subject to IHT are those who're stupid enough to fail to plan. It's no surprise therefore that the size of estates that attract most IHT are those of £2-3 million rather than the super rich whose forefathers didn't become super rich by failing to adequately plan.

Anyone who pays IHT ought to be cursing the person who left them them the bequest for being such a dick.
Reply
Am I right to assume that any government with the Milliband boys in is unlikely to change the Trust legislation!
Reply
(04-20-2024, 08:43 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Am I right to assume that any government with the Milliband boys in is unlikely to change the Trust legislation!

I've met plenty of Trustafarians campaigning for Labour over the years. They're the only people who can afford to be socialists.

I doubt Labour would rock that particular boat and it would be legal nightmare that would only lead to capital flight by the wealthy (again) and the crushing (again) of the middle classes.
Reply
(04-20-2024, 08:43 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Am I right to assume that any government with the Milliband boys in is unlikely to change the Trust legislation!

It's a hypothetical, but you're probably wrong.

Their parents weren't that  wealthy...refugee academics I believe.
Reply
(04-19-2024, 04:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Inheritance Tax is pretty much a voluntary tax, paid by the legally ignorant or terminally useless. You'd make enough revenue from a Land Value Tax to more than make up IHT, Business Rates and Council Tax combined. You'd have the additional benefit of encouraging speculators to sell land for more productive uses - like housing or the big sheds we need. There's very little downside risk to LVT.

Osborne was moving towards simpler taxation - particularly Corporate Taxation - by removing all the distorting allowances and just reducing the rate. It worked perfectly for Corporation Tax where the take went up. Sunak has dismantled that route to 13%, massively increased the rate and added back in all sorts of distorting allowances. The tax take will go down. You literally can't make this shit up.

Similarly with personal taxation, the system is beset with pitfalls and cliff edges which act to disincentivise. There's a member of this Board who got a better paid job and was then presented with a £7,000 bill for overpaid Child Benefit. What a fucking reward for wanting to better yourself?

As it is the complex tax system rewards only those off PAYE like me. We can alter our behaviour by the day; For instance if Starmer puts up Corporation Tax I will simply pay myself more in Pension Contributions and less in salary and dividends to bring my Corporation Tax bill down. I can also put other benefits through my directors loan account so they don't attract BIK - employees can't do that.

Ending these distortions incrementally and moving away from the ridiculous contortions so many of us go through to maximise the benefit to our families v HMRC ought to be the aim of every government. Yet every one over the last 40 years has merely made the situation worse.

Why is the tax system so complicated in the first place? Why isn't it 10 simple rules/laws so it is transparent enough for everyone who has a D at GCSE maths to understand it? First rule could be every business whether making loss or profit pays 1-2% tax every month direct to govt. I'm sure with your knowledge you could fill in the other 9 rules/laws? (that's a serious point not sarcasm btw).
Reply
(04-20-2024, 02:24 PM)FenlandBoing Wrote:
(04-19-2024, 04:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Inheritance Tax is pretty much a voluntary tax, paid by the legally ignorant or terminally useless. You'd make enough revenue from a Land Value Tax to more than make up IHT, Business Rates and Council Tax combined. You'd have the additional benefit of encouraging speculators to sell land for more productive uses - like housing or the big sheds we need. There's very little downside risk to LVT.

Osborne was moving towards simpler taxation - particularly Corporate Taxation - by removing all the distorting allowances and just reducing the rate. It worked perfectly for Corporation Tax where the take went up. Sunak has dismantled that route to 13%, massively increased the rate and added back in all sorts of distorting allowances. The tax take will go down. You literally can't make this shit up.

Similarly with personal taxation, the system is beset with pitfalls and cliff edges which act to disincentivise. There's a member of this Board who got a better paid job and was then presented with a £7,000 bill for overpaid Child Benefit. What a fucking reward for wanting to better yourself?

As it is the complex tax system rewards only those off PAYE like me. We can alter our behaviour by the day; For instance if Starmer puts up Corporation Tax I will simply pay myself more in Pension Contributions and less in salary and dividends to bring my Corporation Tax bill down. I can also put other benefits through my directors loan account so they don't attract BIK - employees can't do that.

Ending these distortions incrementally and moving away from the ridiculous contortions so many of us go through to maximise the benefit to our families v HMRC ought to be the aim of every government. Yet every one over the last 40 years has merely made the situation worse.

Why is the tax system so complicated in the first place? Why isn't it 10 simple rules/laws so it is transparent enough for everyone who has a D at GCSE maths to understand it? First rule could be every business whether making loss or profit pays 1-2% tax every month direct to govt. I'm sure with your knowledge you could fill in the other 9 rules/laws? (that's a serious point not sarcasm btw).
This exactly. And every tweak costs more to implement than it can hope to bring in.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)