Posts: 27,982
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(04-18-2024, 10:42 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (04-18-2024, 10:37 AM)Duffers Wrote: A better solution would have been to give all teams the option to agree before the tie is played to skip any replays. If both sides agree then fine, goes to ET and pens. If one or neither side agrees then it goes to a replay in the event of a draw.
Impractical and impossible to manage.
How is it? Replay dates are always agreed ahead of the tie being played anyway. Give sides a deadline of a week before the tie is due to be played to confirm whether they've agreed to scrap them or not and Bob's your uncle. Really not that difficult to administer, it's a simple yes/no to opt out of replays.
I don't buy the sporting integrity argument either, it's not as case of separate rules as all sides will have the same choice presented to them.
As for backhanders, would that happen? Maybe, but it is any different to the windfall that would come for Colchester from actually playing the replay?
Posts: 12,682
Threads: 1,158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
15
(04-18-2024, 10:43 AM)MrBater Wrote: I miss the years where replays were replayed and so on. It's part of what made the cup special.
It still won't limit how many games the big teams play.
Just add the top six in from round 4 and keep replays...
In fairness, that's not a bad shout really, on date of round 3 draw, top 10 of EPL & or active included in UEFA competition are excluded till round 4 draw. Bottom 10 EPL are included - unless they are in UEFA comp.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(04-18-2024, 10:37 AM)Duffers Wrote: A better solution would have been to give all teams the option to agree before the tie is played to skip any replays. If both sides agree then fine, goes to ET and pens. If one or neither side agrees then it goes to a replay in the event of a draw.
I think up to and including the third round, a club that is non-league, or league 1 & 2 has the right to forfeit home advantage. So if Walsall draw Man Utd at home, they can have the tie played at Old Trafford.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(04-18-2024, 10:56 AM)Duffers Wrote: (04-18-2024, 10:42 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (04-18-2024, 10:37 AM)Duffers Wrote: A better solution would have been to give all teams the option to agree before the tie is played to skip any replays. If both sides agree then fine, goes to ET and pens. If one or neither side agrees then it goes to a replay in the event of a draw.
Impractical and impossible to manage.
How is it? Replay dates are always agreed ahead of the tie being played anyway. Give sides a deadline of a week before the tie is due to be played to confirm whether they've agreed to scrap them or not and Bob's your uncle. Really not that difficult to administer, it's a simple yes/no to opt out of replays.
I don't buy the sporting integrity argument either, it's not as case of separate rules as all sides will have the same choice presented to them.
As for backhanders, would that happen? Maybe, but it is any different to the windfall that would come for Colchester from actually playing the replay?
Same rules can lead to differing outcomes. Man City could argue that Liverpool didn't have to play extra games in the forms of replays. It's luck of the draw who you're drawn against and whether they agree to it, doesn't solve the argument about too many fixtures for the top teams.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(04-18-2024, 10:56 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: (04-18-2024, 10:43 AM)MrBater Wrote: I miss the years where replays were replayed and so on. It's part of what made the cup special.
It still won't limit how many games the big teams play.
Just add the top six in from round 4 and keep replays...
In fairness, that's not a bad shout really, on date of round 3 draw, top 10 of EPL & or active included in UEFA competition are excluded till round 4 draw. Bottom 10 EPL are included - unless they are in UEFA comp.
Disagree. United joining in the 4th round due to the World Club thingie was part of downfall. It’s fast becoming a pointless competition and used to be the most converted in the world.
Posts: 3,808
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(04-18-2024, 10:55 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (04-18-2024, 10:32 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Can't wait to see how the FA spin this as a positive for the lower leagues and "grassroots" football.
They aren't trying to - they've said that scrapping replays is "in light of changes to the calendar driven by the expanded UEFA competitions". It sounds like replays will continue in the qualifying rounds though.
It's basically a further continuation of football being run in the best interests of the chosen few, rather than the game as a whole. If the clubs who are playing in European competitions are concerned about the number of games they play, well maybe they could stop regularly expanding the number of European matches, as well as ending the ridiculousness of clubs that fail in one European competition having the safety net of then playing in another one instead.
And moaning about fixture congestion, `Too Many Matches` player welfare etc, then a week after the end of the season they fly to Singapore or wherever for a couple of lucrative friendlies.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
(04-18-2024, 10:32 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Can't wait to see how the FA spin this as a positive for the lower leagues and "grassroots" football.
They aren't trying to - they've said that scrapping replays is "in light of changes to the calendar driven by the expanded UEFA competitions". It sounds like replays will continue in the qualifying rounds though.
It's basically a continuation of football being run in the best interests of the chosen few, rather than for the game as a whole. If the clubs who are playing in European competitions are concerned about the number of games they play, well maybe they could stop regularly expanding the number of European matches which take place, as well as ending the ridiculousness of clubs that fail in one European competition having the safety net of then playing in another one instead.
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
04-18-2024, 11:18 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-18-2024, 11:19 AM by MrBater.)
(04-18-2024, 11:02 AM)Fido Wrote: (04-18-2024, 10:56 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: (04-18-2024, 10:43 AM)MrBater Wrote: I miss the years where replays were replayed and so on. It's part of what made the cup special.
It still won't limit how many games the big teams play.
Just add the top six in from round 4 and keep replays...
In fairness, that's not a bad shout really, on date of round 3 draw, top 10 of EPL & or active included in UEFA competition are excluded till round 4 draw. Bottom 10 EPL are included - unless they are in UEFA comp.
Disagree. United joining in the 4th round due to the World Club thingie was part of downfall. It’s fast becoming a pointless competition and used to be the most converted in the world.
I don't disagree, but they're gonna change it anyway, they don't care about the competition at all. At least by doing this, with SEBs better enhancement they get less games and the rest of us get a better competition.
One of the top 6 is likely to win it anyway, so this gives them more chance too, but at least we can pretend it's the competition it once was for a bit longer.
I like the allowing the lower placed team the option of switching venue too.
At the end of the day the FA will bend to the will of the 6 anyway, they just want more euro games and shit all over the domestic stuff, unless they get knocked out and then all of a sudden they care.
Personally I want it back to how it used to be, but that's got chance of happening. Manc or someone can probably tell us what the record amount of replays was.
Alternatively drop the league cup and leave the FA cup alone. That's probably a better idea.
Posts: 7,971
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(04-18-2024, 11:18 AM)MrBater Wrote: (04-18-2024, 11:02 AM)Fido Wrote: (04-18-2024, 10:56 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: (04-18-2024, 10:43 AM)MrBater Wrote: I miss the years where replays were replayed and so on. It's part of what made the cup special.
It still won't limit how many games the big teams play.
Just add the top six in from round 4 and keep replays...
In fairness, that's not a bad shout really, on date of round 3 draw, top 10 of EPL & or active included in UEFA competition are excluded till round 4 draw. Bottom 10 EPL are included - unless they are in UEFA comp.
Disagree. United joining in the 4th round due to the World Club thingie was part of downfall. It’s fast becoming a pointless competition and used to be the most converted in the world.
I don't disagree, but they're gonna change it anyway, they don't care about the competition at all. At least by doing this, with SEBs better enhancement they get less games and the rest of us get a better competition.
One of the top 6 is likely to win it anyway, so this gives them more chance too, but at least we can pretend it's the competition it once was for a bit longer.
I like the allowing the lower placed team the option of switching venue too.
At the end of the day the FA will bend to the will of the 6 anyway, they just want more euro games and shit all over the domestic stuff, unless they get knocked out and then all of a sudden they care.
Personally I want it back to how it used to be, but that's got chance of happening. Manc or someone can probably tell us what the record amount of replays was.
Alternatively drop the league cup and leave the FA cup alone. That's probably a better idea.
For one tie - it’s 6 replays
Posts: 12,682
Threads: 1,158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
15
(04-18-2024, 11:18 AM)MrBater Wrote: (04-18-2024, 11:02 AM)Fido Wrote: (04-18-2024, 10:56 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: (04-18-2024, 10:43 AM)MrBater Wrote: I miss the years where replays were replayed and so on. It's part of what made the cup special.
It still won't limit how many games the big teams play.
Just add the top six in from round 4 and keep replays...
In fairness, that's not a bad shout really, on date of round 3 draw, top 10 of EPL & or active included in UEFA competition are excluded till round 4 draw. Bottom 10 EPL are included - unless they are in UEFA comp.
Disagree. United joining in the 4th round due to the World Club thingie was part of downfall. It’s fast becoming a pointless competition and used to be the most converted in the world.
I don't disagree, but they're gonna change it anyway, they don't care about the competition at all. At least by doing this, with SEBs better enhancement they get less games and the rest of us get a better competition.
One of the top 6 is likely to win it anyway, so this gives them more chance too, but at least we can pretend it's the competition it once was for a bit longer.
I like the allowing the lower placed team the option of switching venue too.
At the end of the day the FA will bend to the will of the 6 anyway, they just want more euro games and shit all over the domestic stuff, unless they get knocked out and then all of a sudden they care.
Personally I want it back to how it used to be, but that's got chance of happening. Manc or someone can probably tell us what the record amount of replays was.
Alternatively drop the league cup and leave the FA cup alone. That's probably a better idea.
That's a good idea of having say League One, Two or lower state where they want the tie at - from a revenue perspective. I would imagine a league two club would pick the larger ground for share of gate.
It probably is about time they sort out the league cup. Not sure what the implications would be on the Trophy - but something like remove EPL and Champ from it entirely. Then again if they do that, who's going to sponsor it missing the big clubs from the competition.
|