Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
04-10-2024, 01:38 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-10-2024, 01:38 PM by AnelkasBeard.)
(04-10-2024, 01:34 PM)wba13 Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:21 PM)Sliced Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:09 PM)wba13 Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:02 PM)Sliced Wrote: I think that there are referees who fold under the pressure of refereeing at the bigger stadiums, and also there's a fear of being criticised more publically if you give a poor decision against one of the top teams in the Premier League in a league game; so in the Prem the bigger teams have an advantage. Outside of that every team seems to think referees are against them and it's just not true, although it's a separate point from the OP.
IMO the referee absolutely did the right thing yesterday on both counts. Saka's shouldn't have been a penalty.
With respect to the handball, the IFAB board official laws of the game number 5 states: "Decisions will be made to the best of the referee's ability according to the Laws of the Game and the 'spirit of the game' and will be based on the opinion of the referee who has the discretion to take appropriate action within the framework of the Laws of the Game."
Giving a penalty against Gabriel picking up the ball when he didn't realise that a free kick had been taken, when there was zero benefit for Arsenal doing so, doesn't fall into the "spirit of the game" IMO. By the rules of football without taking into account law 5 above it's a penalty, but I'm glad the ref applied some common sense.
It’s a penalty, both Raya and Gabriel should have been switched on, So it’s not ok for a defender to handle a ball accidentally for a penalty to be given but it’s ok for a defender to deliberately handle a ball but no penalty is given. Spirit of the game should apply both ways or not at all.
When a team is attacking and there's a handball because the hand is in an unnatural position, the attacking team loses an advantage. No advantage was gained or lost by Gabriel not realising that the ball was in play and picking it up to take the free kick. We will have agree to disagree, it’s Handball all day long my mind won’t change.
What is the point of starting a thread to invite discussion if your mind won't change? The fact you're wrong as well makes it all the funnier.
Posts: 27,981
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
Worth noting that VAR didn’t see fit to intervene either.
Posts: 4,668
Threads: 183
Joined: Nov 2022
Reputation:
14
(04-10-2024, 01:46 PM)Duffers Wrote: Worth noting that VAR didn’t see fit to intervene either.
That's not worth noting, such is the uselessness of VAR.
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(04-10-2024, 01:38 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:34 PM)wba13 Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:21 PM)Sliced Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:09 PM)wba13 Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:02 PM)Sliced Wrote: I think that there are referees who fold under the pressure of refereeing at the bigger stadiums, and also there's a fear of being criticised more publically if you give a poor decision against one of the top teams in the Premier League in a league game; so in the Prem the bigger teams have an advantage. Outside of that every team seems to think referees are against them and it's just not true, although it's a separate point from the OP.
IMO the referee absolutely did the right thing yesterday on both counts. Saka's shouldn't have been a penalty.
With respect to the handball, the IFAB board official laws of the game number 5 states: "Decisions will be made to the best of the referee's ability according to the Laws of the Game and the 'spirit of the game' and will be based on the opinion of the referee who has the discretion to take appropriate action within the framework of the Laws of the Game."
Giving a penalty against Gabriel picking up the ball when he didn't realise that a free kick had been taken, when there was zero benefit for Arsenal doing so, doesn't fall into the "spirit of the game" IMO. By the rules of football without taking into account law 5 above it's a penalty, but I'm glad the ref applied some common sense.
It’s a penalty, both Raya and Gabriel should have been switched on, So it’s not ok for a defender to handle a ball accidentally for a penalty to be given but it’s ok for a defender to deliberately handle a ball but no penalty is given. Spirit of the game should apply both ways or not at all.
When a team is attacking and there's a handball because the hand is in an unnatural position, the attacking team loses an advantage. No advantage was gained or lost by Gabriel not realising that the ball was in play and picking it up to take the free kick. We will have agree to disagree, it’s Handball all day long my mind won’t change.
What is the point of starting a thread to invite discussion if your mind won't change? The fact you're wrong as well makes it all the funnier.
I never started the thread to ask anyone to try and change my mind I know in my own mind it was a penalty. As for it being funny well as they say sarcasm is the lowest form of wit. So if you find it funny is your choice. As for you saying I’m wrong that’s your opinion not mine. To be honest couldn’t care less what you think.
Posts: 831
Threads: 43
Joined: Dec 2023
Reputation:
3
(04-10-2024, 01:33 PM)Duffers Wrote: Reminds me of that Aussie Wickett n the Ashes last year.
Yes you could argue that when Raya passed the ball to Gabriel the ball technically was in play and therefore it was handball, but it’s not really in the spirit of the game is it?
Be interesting to see a Venn diagram of those who condemned the Aussies yet are fuming about this non-award.
I think it's different to a batsman leaving the crease believing the ball was dead and the opposition using it to get a dismissal and a wholly self-inflicted howler, Duffers. All the more reason to give the penalty. The stupid boy. Keep paying attention - that also ought to be a basic requirement of a pro footballer.
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
04-10-2024, 02:13 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-10-2024, 02:14 PM by AnelkasBeard.)
(04-10-2024, 01:58 PM)wba13 Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:38 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:34 PM)wba13 Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:21 PM)Sliced Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:09 PM)wba13 Wrote: It’s a penalty, both Raya and Gabriel should have been switched on, So it’s not ok for a defender to handle a ball accidentally for a penalty to be given but it’s ok for a defender to deliberately handle a ball but no penalty is given. Spirit of the game should apply both ways or not at all.
When a team is attacking and there's a handball because the hand is in an unnatural position, the attacking team loses an advantage. No advantage was gained or lost by Gabriel not realising that the ball was in play and picking it up to take the free kick. We will have agree to disagree, it’s Handball all day long my mind won’t change.
What is the point of starting a thread to invite discussion if your mind won't change? The fact you're wrong as well makes it all the funnier.
I never started the thread to ask anyone to try and change my mind I know in my own mind it was a penalty. As for it being funny well as they say sarcasm is the lowest form of wit. So if you find it funny is your choice. As for you saying I’m wrong that’s your opinion not mine. To be honest couldn’t care less what you think.
So you've misidentified something as sarcasm, well done that's really added to the thread (hint: that was sarcasm, take notes).
And you've now stated you don't care about people's opinions if they're different to yours. So I must ask again, why did you start a thread? What is the point of discussing something if you aren't going to take on board anything that doesn't fit in to your mind's view? I guess the space in there must be pretty small, to be fair.
(Just to help out, before you claim you didn't want to discuss something, that's all we do on this board, specifically when people start threads about topics. So starting a thread on something, and discussing it are tantamout to the same thing. If you didn't want to talk about it, I think you might be in the wrong place.)
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(04-10-2024, 02:04 PM)Hudds1 Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:33 PM)Duffers Wrote: Reminds me of that Aussie Wickett n the Ashes last year.
Yes you could argue that when Raya passed the ball to Gabriel the ball technically was in play and therefore it was handball, but it’s not really in the spirit of the game is it?
Be interesting to see a Venn diagram of those who condemned the Aussies yet are fuming about this non-award.
I think it's different to a batsman leaving the crease believing the ball was dead and the opposition using it to get a dismissal and a wholly self-inflicted howler, Duffers. All the more reason to give the penalty. The stupid boy. Keep paying attention - that also ought to be a basic requirement of a pro footballer.
Of course it's different. The one incident was debatable, the other involved Australians, the biggest cheating crybabbies in world sport.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
On the spirit of the game theme I’m sure there was an incident whereby a defender effectively went down on hands and knees to head a ball back to the keeper. As this was deemed not in the spirit of the game he was penalised with a free kick against him. I’m sure I didn’t dream this but can’t find anything on it!
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(04-10-2024, 02:13 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:58 PM)wba13 Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:38 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:34 PM)wba13 Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:21 PM)Sliced Wrote: When a team is attacking and there's a handball because the hand is in an unnatural position, the attacking team loses an advantage. No advantage was gained or lost by Gabriel not realising that the ball was in play and picking it up to take the free kick. We will have agree to disagree, it’s Handball all day long my mind won’t change.
What is the point of starting a thread to invite discussion if your mind won't change? The fact you're wrong as well makes it all the funnier.
I never started the thread to ask anyone to try and change my mind I know in my own mind it was a penalty. As for it being funny well as they say sarcasm is the lowest form of wit. So if you find it funny is your choice. As for you saying I’m wrong that’s your opinion not mine. To be honest couldn’t care less what you think.
So you've misidentified something as sarcasm, well done that's really added to the thread (hint: that was sarcasm, take notes).
And you've now stated you don't care about people's opinions if they're different to yours. So I must ask again, why did you start a thread? What is the point of discussing something if you aren't going to take on board anything that doesn't fit in to your mind's view? I guess the space in there must be pretty small, to be fair.
(Just to help out, before you claim you didn't want to discuss something, that's all we do on this board, specifically when people start threads about topics. So starting a thread on something, and discussing it are tantamout to the same thing. If you didn't want to talk about it, I think you might be in the wrong place.)
If you can find out anywhere where I’ve said I don’t care about posters opinions all I’ve said is you won’t change my opinion and that your opinion won’t change it. Seems to me all you want to do is have a go at me well, if you think you’re right fair enough , but as I said before your opinion is different too mine . Bye bye.
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(04-10-2024, 03:05 PM)wba13 Wrote: (04-10-2024, 02:13 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:58 PM)wba13 Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:38 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (04-10-2024, 01:34 PM)wba13 Wrote: We will have agree to disagree, it’s Handball all day long my mind won’t change.
What is the point of starting a thread to invite discussion if your mind won't change? The fact you're wrong as well makes it all the funnier.
I never started the thread to ask anyone to try and change my mind I know in my own mind it was a penalty. As for it being funny well as they say sarcasm is the lowest form of wit. So if you find it funny is your choice. As for you saying I’m wrong that’s your opinion not mine. To be honest couldn’t care less what you think.
So you've misidentified something as sarcasm, well done that's really added to the thread (hint: that was sarcasm, take notes).
And you've now stated you don't care about people's opinions if they're different to yours. So I must ask again, why did you start a thread? What is the point of discussing something if you aren't going to take on board anything that doesn't fit in to your mind's view? I guess the space in there must be pretty small, to be fair.
(Just to help out, before you claim you didn't want to discuss something, that's all we do on this board, specifically when people start threads about topics. So starting a thread on something, and discussing it are tantamout to the same thing. If you didn't want to talk about it, I think you might be in the wrong place.)
If you can find out anywhere where I’ve said I don’t care about posters opinions all I’ve said is you won’t change my opinion and that your opinion won’t change it. Seems to me all you want to do is have a go at me well, if you think you’re right fair enough , but as I said before your opinion is different too mine . Bye bye.
Highlighted for you, just to help out. Also "all I’ve said is you won’t change my opinion and that your opinion won’t change it" is saying exactly the same thing.
Love to the family.
|