Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
(04-09-2024, 07:46 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (04-08-2024, 08:44 PM)foreveralbion Wrote: Every time there is a story of a CHILD being murdered by another CHILD I hope it's the one that makes everyone sit up and say enough is enough.
No one likes a nanny state but there are some serious flaws in how kids are being taught morals.
I personally would flood the education/youth system with whatever it needs to help guide kids from as early an age as possible. I agree with this, the education system needs an overhaul IMO. It's all about academia these days and very little to do with social skills, practical skills or common sense.
I have a 15yr old and her school is like a Victorian workhouse where kids should be seen and not heard. Social interaction is frowned upon to the point where she doesn't get to decide who she sits by in the canteen, which sounds like an idea to encourage broader friend groups, but it doesn't it just increases isolation. The kids have no voice at all and are often punished for speaking up or offering opinions.
The outcome is very good in terms of academic results and Ofsted ratings, but the kids are are anxious and frustrated and struggle in social situations. We need to teach kids how to interact and care for each other and encourage them to speak up and be involved in decisions. This would serve them far better, in later life, than knowing who was King in 1383 or pulling their hair out over engineer level maths, which only a tiny percentage will ever need in real life.
One of the best and most accurate contributions yet BF.
I’d add to that that the loss of a lot of extra curricular activities has furthered the deficits you rightly identify. We’ve basically got a system that appears to be going well because all we are doing is measuring all the stuff that doesn’t actually matter.
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 10,525
Threads: 487
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
28
(04-09-2024, 07:46 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (04-08-2024, 08:44 PM)foreveralbion Wrote: Every time there is a story of a CHILD being murdered by another CHILD I hope it's the one that makes everyone sit up and say enough is enough.
No one likes a nanny state but there are some serious flaws in how kids are being taught morals.
I personally would flood the education/youth system with whatever it needs to help guide kids from as early an age as possible. I agree with this, the education system needs an overhaul IMO. It's all about academia these days and very little to do with social skills, practical skills or common sense.
I have a 15yr old and her school is like a Victorian workhouse where kids should be seen and not heard. Social interaction is frowned upon to the point where she doesn't get to decide who she sits by in the canteen, which sounds like an idea to encourage broader friend groups, but it doesn't it just increases isolation. The kids have no voice at all and are often punished for speaking up or offering opinions.
The outcome is very good in terms of academic results and Ofsted ratings, but the kids are are anxious and frustrated and struggle in social situations. We need to teach kids how to interact and care for each other and encourage them to speak up and be involved in decisions. This would serve them far better, in later life, than knowing who was King in 1383 or pulling their hair out over engineer level maths, which only a tiny percentage will ever need in real life.
Apologies, but that school sounds dreadful. Why do you keep your daughter there, if you don’t mind me asking?
Posts: 7,997
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(04-09-2024, 07:54 AM)Dumbo Wrote: (04-09-2024, 07:46 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (04-08-2024, 08:44 PM)foreveralbion Wrote: Every time there is a story of a CHILD being murdered by another CHILD I hope it's the one that makes everyone sit up and say enough is enough.
No one likes a nanny state but there are some serious flaws in how kids are being taught morals.
I personally would flood the education/youth system with whatever it needs to help guide kids from as early an age as possible. I agree with this, the education system needs an overhaul IMO. It's all about academia these days and very little to do with social skills, practical skills or common sense.
I have a 15yr old and her school is like a Victorian workhouse where kids should be seen and not heard. Social interaction is frowned upon to the point where she doesn't get to decide who she sits by in the canteen, which sounds like an idea to encourage broader friend groups, but it doesn't it just increases isolation. The kids have no voice at all and are often punished for speaking up or offering opinions.
The outcome is very good in terms of academic results and Ofsted ratings, but the kids are are anxious and frustrated and struggle in social situations. We need to teach kids how to interact and care for each other and encourage them to speak up and be involved in decisions. This would serve them far better, in later life, than knowing who was King in 1383 or pulling their hair out over engineer level maths, which only a tiny percentage will ever need in real life.
Apologies, but that school sounds dreadful. Why do you keep your daughter there, if you don’t mind me asking? Because we fell into the trap of the definition of a "good school" to be honest. And, to be fair, she is incredibly stoic and level headed, with a good support network, so she takes it in her stride and wouldn't want to leave friends etc., but, even if she did, I have mates with kids at the alternatives and they fair no better. A lot of her friends, however, have the archetypical "pushy" parents, who focus purely on exam results and some of them struggle horrifically in terms of mental health.
Posts: 4,768
Threads: 3
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
27
(04-08-2024, 08:19 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: (04-08-2024, 08:17 PM)Dumbo Wrote: I’ve heard the young lad that was stabbed may have been gay. Begs the question if this was a homophobic attack.
Fucking disgusting either way and I’ve said it on here 100 times but I’d urge any new parent to get their child in to martial arts.
Think self defence is a good addition to the range of stuff that can help. There’s a local Krav Maga class for kids near me and that certainly teaches lots of very useful skills
If someone pulls a blade the best form of self defence is to run like fuck and hope the cunt with the blade isn't as fast as you. That's what I told my lad before showing him a few things which may come in handy if a cunt with a knife caught up with him.
The last thing I wanted him doing was getting all Chuck Norris on the back of a few months of self defence classes. He was quite small for his age and very nippy on his feet with a strong sense of self preservation so there was no point in or need for overcomplication.
He's 24 soon and off to Germany with his mates in the summer. I'm just hoping he remembers those basics after a few beers if he comes face to face with some Serbian Ultras. Standing your ground with your mates is one thing. Ending up like a colander is another.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
I pretty much completely agree GoN. I’d say having the widest range of skills and options depending on the situation is the best of all worlds. Of course you are spot on that the most helpful element at any time is decision making - see all the other points about the opportunities you offer kids in their formative years, whether in the family, education or youth services
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(04-09-2024, 08:08 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote: If someone pulls a blade the best form of self defence is to run like fuck and hope the cunt with the blade isn't as fast as you. That's what I told my lad before showing him a few things which may come in handy if a cunt with a knife caught up with him.
The last thing I wanted him doing was getting all Chuck Norris on the back of a few months of self defence classes. He was quite small for his age and very nippy on his feet with a strong sense of self preservation so there was no point in or need for overcomplication.
He's 24 soon and off to Germany with his mates in the summer. I'm just hoping he remembers those basics after a few beers if he comes face to face with some Serbian Ultras. Standing your ground with your mates is one thing. Ending up like a colander is another.
Self preservation is always the best way to go. If someone pulls a knife and asks for your phone or wallet, you bloody hand them over asap and then get out of there. There's no heroism in dying over the latest iPhone. In light of more recent cases like the Cody Fisher one, how on earth do you avoid that? He bumped someone in a nightclub who then spent two days stalking him until he got a chance to stab him.
I'd do just about anything to avoid even having to throw a punch in all honesty, around the time I started going out regularly there seemed to be a spate of one-punch killings and even if it was in self defence I'm not sure I'd want that on my conscience for the rest of my life.
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
(04-09-2024, 07:46 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (04-08-2024, 08:44 PM)foreveralbion Wrote: Every time there is a story of a CHILD being murdered by another CHILD I hope it's the one that makes everyone sit up and say enough is enough.
No one likes a nanny state but there are some serious flaws in how kids are being taught morals.
I personally would flood the education/youth system with whatever it needs to help guide kids from as early an age as possible. I agree with this, the education system needs an overhaul IMO. It's all about academia these days and very little to do with social skills, practical skills or common sense.
I have a 15yr old and her school is like a Victorian workhouse where kids should be seen and not heard. Social interaction is frowned upon to the point where she doesn't get to decide who she sits by in the canteen, which sounds like an idea to encourage broader friend groups, but it doesn't it just increases isolation. The kids have no voice at all and are often punished for speaking up or offering opinions.
The outcome is very good in terms of academic results and Ofsted ratings, but the kids are are anxious and frustrated and struggle in social situations. We need to teach kids how to interact and care for each other and encourage them to speak up and be involved in decisions. This would serve them far better, in later life, than knowing who was King in 1383 or pulling their hair out over engineer level maths, which only a tiny percentage will ever need in real life.
Loads of kids at more conventional schools are anxious. I think their anxiety comes from an over reliance on phones and messaging, and 'social media'.
Teaching kids not to kill each other is everyone's responsibility not just schools. It starts at home. Then again loads of parents take no responsibility for themselves let alone their kids.
Posts: 7,997
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(04-09-2024, 08:20 AM)MrBater Wrote: (04-09-2024, 07:46 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (04-08-2024, 08:44 PM)foreveralbion Wrote: Every time there is a story of a CHILD being murdered by another CHILD I hope it's the one that makes everyone sit up and say enough is enough.
No one likes a nanny state but there are some serious flaws in how kids are being taught morals.
I personally would flood the education/youth system with whatever it needs to help guide kids from as early an age as possible. I agree with this, the education system needs an overhaul IMO. It's all about academia these days and very little to do with social skills, practical skills or common sense.
I have a 15yr old and her school is like a Victorian workhouse where kids should be seen and not heard. Social interaction is frowned upon to the point where she doesn't get to decide who she sits by in the canteen, which sounds like an idea to encourage broader friend groups, but it doesn't it just increases isolation. The kids have no voice at all and are often punished for speaking up or offering opinions.
The outcome is very good in terms of academic results and Ofsted ratings, but the kids are are anxious and frustrated and struggle in social situations. We need to teach kids how to interact and care for each other and encourage them to speak up and be involved in decisions. This would serve them far better, in later life, than knowing who was King in 1383 or pulling their hair out over engineer level maths, which only a tiny percentage will ever need in real life.
Loads of kids at more conventional schools are anxious. I think their anxiety comes from an over reliance on phones and messaging, and 'social media'.
Teaching kids not to kill each other is everyone's responsibility not just schools. It starts at home. Then again loads of parents take no responsibility for themselves let alone their kids. That's why "It starts at home" is, sadly, not an answer.
Kids spend 7/8 hours a day, 5 days a week at school, so it needs to be more than just academia that they are learning. Phones, messaging and social media are a fact of life that are not going away, and have a part to play in modern society, that's why their usage (as in how to use them safely and productively) should be part of the curriculum.
Posts: 99
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2024
Reputation:
0
My wife has worked in mental health for 35 years. She was a big advocate of Sure Start.
One of the first things The coalition government did when they got into power was to run down the Sure Start program that had been set up by Blair.
This provided support for lots of disadvantaged and single parent families in the early years. There's a report out today how exam results from people who took part in Sure Start are a few grades higher.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
I see there are calls to reintroduce Sure Start when Labour win the election. Of all the things destroyed since 2010, this was probably the biggest loss of the lot
Someone could have been killed
|