England v Brazil
#51
(03-24-2024, 01:52 PM)Sliced Wrote: Has a manager ever got so much shit for doing, at worst, a decent job?

I think history might be kinder to him than we are right now.

The guy took a team containing Ashley Young, Jesse Lingard, Danny Rose and Eric Dier to a World Cup semi final!
Reply
#52
(03-24-2024, 02:16 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(03-24-2024, 01:52 PM)Sliced Wrote: Has a manager ever got so much shit for doing, at worst, a decent job?

I think history might be kinder to him than we are right now.

The guy took a team containing Ashley Young, Jesse Lingard, Danny Rose and Eric Dier to a World Cup semi final!

If we win the euros it's already been decided that it's "in spite" of Southgate rather than because of Southgate. The idea that we'd dominate world football with someone else in charge is ridiculous IMO.

And no, I wouldn't take Southgate over Corberan, but the skills required for international football management are very different to club management.

That's why the bloke who won consecutive AFCON's with Zambia (who had only qualified twice before) and Ivory Coast, then took Morocco to their first world cup in 20 years and managed Saudi Arabia to a victory against Argentina in the last World cup was absolutely crap in every club job he has had.
Reply
#53
Southgate is too woke for me…
Reply
#54
One of Southgate's pitfalls as a manager is that he hasn't managed in big games before this, so he's basically been learning on the job. Countries usually go for more experienced coaches for this reason.
Reply
#55
There are huge differences between club and international management. The obvious point is no need to have input into transfers etc. You've got what you’ve got by accident at birth.

I think almost all of us would pick 20 or so of the same players, so identifying talent is hardly a prerequisite either.

He doesn’t really need to be a good coach of the players. Internationally you don’t get long enough to work with the players on strengths and weaknesses, player development is pretty much all done at club level.

So it’s all about tactics, in game management and managing the egos of the players. As has already been raised it’s rare that Southgate makes an in game change that makes us better. This is why he’s not regarded that highly. There’s been nothing to suggest he’d do well at club level. And yet Dan Ashworth seems to rate him and I would respect his view over mine!
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#56
(03-23-2024, 11:54 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(03-23-2024, 10:00 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I’m also finding Southgate-apologists tiresome now.

He’s worked wonders off the pitch, but cannot in-game manage for shit. He’s earned his free-hits at glory, that can’t be denied; but if we carry on with him we will keep missing. Repetition vis-a-vis experiments etc.

It is time for him to move on. I just hope they don’t give it to a twat like Eddie Howe.

Bollix.  It's a friendly. Be careful what you wish for. I've had a lifetime of England managers picking players from the top few.  They  have all ignored talent in favour of the tried and failed. 
Bellingham  Saka and co would not have been selected under the others. 
Agree on Eddie Howe. Like I say, be careful what you wish for. Southgate has given chances to those that the Premier league wouldn't look twice at

How is it bollix? I get that it’s a friendly, against a (historical at least) very decent technical side. 

I don’t think Southgate has it as a manager. As a DoF he’d probably be very good. But we had two chances in recent years that suggest differently. He only took the handbrake off when the readership of media forced him to.

(03-24-2024, 05:05 PM)Slowpoke Gonzalez Wrote: One of Southgate's pitfalls as a manager is that he hasn't managed in big games before this, so he's basically been learning on the job. Countries usually go for more experienced coaches for this reason.

This. See also ‘Mark Hughes’. A career that is arse-about face doesn’t help sometimes.

It isn’t the crime of the century to be grateful to Southgate for taking us as far as he has and allowing someone else to finish it, opposed to sticking with an outcome that probably won’t happen. Just please not Eddie Howe.
Reply
#57
(03-24-2024, 02:16 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(03-24-2024, 01:52 PM)Sliced Wrote: Has a manager ever got so much shit for doing, at worst, a decent job?

I think history might be kinder to him than we are right now.

The guy took a team containing Ashley Young, Jesse Lingard, Danny Rose and Eric Dier to a World Cup semi final!

Agreed considering how low expectations were of him at the beginning. He did become a victim of his own success, because then people started to expect and he hasn't kept up this end of the bargain. I do see Southgate as a net positive overall though.
Reply
#58
2018 the route to the final was kind to him, Columbia & Sweden are teams we should beat, just unfortunate he could not get it done against Croatia, lessons learned you would think...., however even though we went one better in 2021 we came up short and the circumstances very similar - leading at half time - however this time, with home advantage and playing against a good Italian team(but aged back line) we could not get over the line.

Southgates' strength has been to unite the players from within, which he he fostered during his tenure developing the U21. However I feel he will always come up short against canny managers - like he did in 2021 against Mancini.

When it matters, can he change the shape of the game and come up with a plan b, or his approach too scripted and cautious.

He did not convince at club level with Boro, relegation to the championship followed, then sacked during their first season back in the champ.

Even though he's been very successful compared to what's gone before a lot of fans I speak to, just don't like him. 

I think it's now or never for him.
Reply
#59
To be fair to him last year’s World Cup we played very well for the most part, we were far more expansive and less cautious and scored goals for fun as a result.

He certainly couldn’t be blamed for a narrow defeat to a very good France side where we went toe to toe with them and were only a fluffed penalty away from extra time at the very least.

Hopefully we see that England again this summer.
Reply
#60
Southgate has a 20% win rate against teams in the top 10 of the FIFA rankings. In well over 20 matches. Baffling that anyone thinks he's a good enough tactician to still be in this role.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)