Match Fred - Albion vs Brizzle City
#71
Palmer occasionally misplaces a pass so it’s a clear weakness because no Premier league keeper ever does that. Meanwhile all of our outfield players misplace passes but that’s ok.
Reply
#72
(03-17-2024, 09:35 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Maybe the fan merely asked him if he could keep his kick on the field of play instead of putting it out for a throw-in?

This is Palmer’s biggest weakness and what will hold him back from being any more than what he already is, a top end Champo keeper.  Think the PL may be a step too far.

In terms of the altercation - Palmer should just ignore him unless it’s particularly personal.  Arguing with your won fans is never a good look, even if you have right on your side.

Palmer's passing is quite good. I'm not sure we should condemn him in his first season at this level as having poor distribution when he clearly improves every game. As for the (supposed) fan, what a colossal twat! Further proof that although everyone is entitled to an opinion, not everyone needs to listen.
Reply
#73
I'm not sure we should be placing so much weight on a GK's distribution. Sure, I understand that's where the game is heading, especially at the top level, and that GK's need to be good with their feet and act like an extra ball playing centre half, as such. However, first and foremost, I want my GK's to command their area and be reliable with their hands, as well as consistently making important saves. Palmer certainly has these attributes.

I'm more than happy with his game, and his quality. I hope he's our GK for many a year. He's more than good enough to develop as we (hopefully) progress as a football club.

I am aware I've been slightly critical of his recent mistakes, but he's human and entitled to make mistakes. That doesn't mean you can't criticise, but overall he's a great keeper. He makes many more saves than mistakes. Even in an individual game he makes up for them. See QPR and Huddersfield. Two mistakes which cost us goals, however, he made big saves at important times to play a big part in us earning points.
Reply
#74
Distribution should be a “nice to have” when it comes to keepers. People rave about keepers being able to spray 50 yard passes but it means little if they can’t keep the ball out of their net. Onana at United is a good example of a good passer but mediocre at the task of actually stopping shots.
Reply
#75
His short passing is fine, he does though consistently find touch when going long.

It’s such fine margins for the top players that ultimately it will hold him back from reaching the top.

I’ve hardly called him Button ffs, merely pointed out it’s a weakness in his game. He may improve, he may not.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#76
I'd sooner see Palmer kick the ball out of play than give it away from trying to be a prime Xavi, FFS!
Reply
#77
(03-18-2024, 08:26 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: I'd sooner see Palmer kick the ball out of play than give it away from trying to be a prime Xavi, FFS!

Is that all we do these days, straight to an extreme? 

He’s a good keeper, pointing out something he needs to work on, that will hold him back, is what I would hope our coaches are doing with everyone of our players.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#78
(03-18-2024, 08:13 AM)Duffers Wrote: Distribution should be a “nice to have” when it comes to keepers. People rave about keepers being able to spray 50 yard passes but it means little if they can’t keep the ball out of their net. Onana at United is a good example of a good passer but mediocre at the task of actually stopping shots.

(03-18-2024, 08:33 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(03-18-2024, 08:26 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: I'd sooner see Palmer kick the ball out of play than give it away from trying to be a prime Xavi, FFS!

Is that all we do these days, straight to an extreme? 

He’s a good keeper, pointing out something he needs to work on, that will hold him back, is what I would hope our coaches are doing with everyone of our players.

Sorry, that wasn't meant to come across as having a go at you. It's a general thought. I feel the same about defenders. It's OK seeing City's back line ping the ball about Infront of XI men, they have both the time and skill to do so, but Kipre and Bartley don't. They're also more likely to be pressed and forced into an error. Was it Huddersfield away where Kipre played a ball directly across our 18 yard box? That's just needless.

As you say, it's not about extremes, I'm not calling for us to go all out route one, and playing out from the back is a good tactic for the most part, but play the situation. If a team is pressing and you have no options, go long and play percentages.
Reply
#79
You’ve made my point. The PL defenders can pass it around, whereas Bartley would be a disaster doing it. It’s one of the reasons Bartley is a Champ defender.

Palmer quite regularly slices into touch, he needs to improve on this. No more, no less.

My post was slightly tongue in cheek about whatever it was someone shouted to Palmer. I’ve said elsewhere he should rise above it, unless it’s personal.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#80
(03-17-2024, 08:53 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(03-17-2024, 04:27 PM)Mr Nimbus Wrote:
(03-17-2024, 11:33 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The fans do have the right to make a fair comment though, as long as it isn't racist or abusive.

I didn't hear what was said, and whatever it was I guess was unnecessary at the end of a 2-0 win. I don't want to watch football in a sanitised environment though.

I'm not sure how fans do have the right to be a cock end? Is it because they bought a ticket?  I've sat next to a number of fans who seemed to have either been lobotomised and/or had very unhappy lives.  Think if I was 6ft 4 and built like a brick house I might have been inclined to have a word back.

Just because Palmer disagreed what the fan said he is automatically a cock .

I'm just making an educated guess that this fella, was indeed, being an utter cock end.  I'm sure CCTV would probably back up my presumption. I can't say if he is always a cock end, it may have been a one off moment although again.....
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)