Ratings today...
#1
After getting to a live game for the first time in a while..


Palmer - 8 - Started off giving him a 7 but then thought he made a few very good saves. Arguably harder worked than O'Leary in their goal despite us really bossing much of the game.

Townsend - 7 - Steady return to the side. Looked really effective in the 10-15 mins either side of the break where he was pushed further up, and an excellent assist for the goal.
Pieters - 4 - One to forget for Erik! Defensively he was OK, positioning was fine but none of his passes came off. Looked really out of sorts and rightly hooked.
Kipre - 8 - Another man-mountain performance at the back - loved that late challenge he got a booking for!!
Furlong - 9 - MOTM - Thought he was outstanding today - will be interested to see Lurkers' statsbomb on him - defensively he didn't put a foot wrong IMO, and he became a crucial player carrying the ball forward and coming inside to outnumber them in the middle. 

Yokuslu - 7 - Thought he kept things ticking over but wasn't at his absolute best - but again we noticeably became more fragile the second he went off.
Mowatt - 7.5 - Excellent during out more dominant spell, but first half felt he was very quiet and well marshalled by Bristol. 

Johnston - 7.5 - Constant threat, really good ball for Townsend to start that move, maybe my expectations are too high of him!
Grady - 7 - Quiet first half but looked a lot more comfortable when Bristol opened up a little at 1-0. Really wish he'd buried that chance just before being hooked.
Fellows - 7.5 - Improving every week, you can see the senior pros now consider him a first team player, and Carlos is trusting him more and more. Great to see him using his other foot for the goal - a constant menace.

Wallace - 7.5 - Fella behind me was giving him dogs abuse all first half and looking for anyone who would listen to him to tell them how BTA should be starting as Wallace just isn't  a striker so was delighted when he grabbed the goal. Ran himself into the ground and was surprised to see him go off ahead of Fellows.

Bartley - 7 - Solid, as usual.
Swift - 5 - Seems to be really struggling and instead of just getting his head down and doing the basics, he seems to be reverting to trying more tricks and Hollywood passes - was absolutely seething when he tried to switch the play instead of feeding Johnston with the simple side pass.
BTA - 6 - Good to see him back... Looked fast and really up for it. 
M'Vila - Couple tidy blocks - seemed to want to put himself around a bit - certainly plenty of him!
Reach - Not sure he touched it!

Corberan - thought he outwitted Manning today - City played very well for the first 30 minutes and frustrated us, but you could see the tweaks CC made worked. Townsend went further up, Furlong came inside, Grady went up alongside Wallace and we gradually wrestled control of the game. Combining his nous with the quality we now have on the bench and I think we really could do something special in the playoffs!
Reply
#2
Not much to argue on the scores but Pieters should be high at 5 not 4, this is just me being pedantic.

Grady is making me think as when he starts the game it is tight, second half he starts to find space and he is brought off. Not sure what the best alternative is.
Reply
#3
Good write up SW.  Agree with most of that.  Don’t think ÇC outwitted Manning. Felt they were the better side first 35 and last 25 (admittedly it was CCs usual tactic of sitting in with something to hold). They passed it well but can’t hit a barn door.  We really should have got a third when we were dominant on hour mark. They had late chances and we weren’t all that comfortable. Marks. 

AP 7.5. Great save first half and routine saves 2nd half. Went longer today but we invited trouble with some short stuff

Furlong. 8. Poor passing first half but very good defensively and won plenty of headers. Probably MOTM 

CT 7.5.  Great assist and supported attack well today. Good defending late on considering his yellow. Cornick a handful 

Pieters. 5.5. Targeted as a weak link and some poor passing undermined him today.  Creaks when he starts. 

Kipre. 7.5 not his most convincing game and some loose passing but solid again. Won key late headers late on from their corners. 

Okay. 6.5. Some poor passing and should have bagged that chance.  Ran out of gas and wise to hook him 

Mowatt 7. Quiet first half but plenty of linkplay 2nd and key clearances when we needed them.  Absolute bonus since September 

Grady. 6.5. Didn’t show much for 45 min but committed them much better 2nd half. Held ball in key areas. Poor effort with big chance 

Fellows. 7. Good goal and key cog.  Struggled early on as they got tight but much better after break. Got his shots and crosses off

MJ. 7. Not enough of an outlet first 30 but drew in 2 players and his control in tight areas and passes were key to both goals. Real threat. 

Jed 7. Static and no threat for 30, when he makes runs we are a different team. Nice tuck and would have kept him on longer

BTA. 6.5 Energy and decent touch. Put himself about a bit and occupied their centre halves

Swift 5.5. Some control but doing nowhere near enough. Needs to lose timber and impose himself on games 

Bartley 7. Made a difference and swept up a few times against quick forwards.  Shows leadership 

Mvila 6.5. Slightly rusty but dug in and spread the ball. Much more similar to okay that Chalobah 

Reach 6.  Sat in as another LB and filled the space/ covered runners. Decent option when you are winning
Reply
#4
Bang on pretty much I’d have gone higher on MJ
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#5
(03-16-2024, 08:37 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Good write up SW.  Agree with most of that.  Don’t think ÇC outwitted Manning. Felt they were the better side first 35 and last 25 (admittedly it was CCs usual tactic of sitting in with something to hold). They passed it well but can’t hit a barn door.  We really should have got a third when we were dominant on hour mark. They had late chances and we weren’t all that comfortable. Marks. 

AP 7.5. Great save first half and routine saves 2nd half. Went longer today but we invited trouble with some short stuff

Furlong. 8. Poor passing first half but very good defensively and won plenty of headers. Probably MOTM 

CT 7.5.  Great assist and supported attack well today. Good defending late on considering his yellow. Cornick a handful 

Pieters. 5.5. Targeted as a weak link and some poor passing undermined him today.  Creaks when he starts. 

Kipre. 7.5 not his most convincing game and some loose passing but solid again. Won key late headers late on from their corners. 

Okay. 6.5. Some poor passing and should have bagged that chance.  Ran out of gas and wise to hook him 

Mowatt 7. Quiet first half but plenty of linkplay 2nd and key clearances when we needed them.  Absolute bonus since September 

Grady. 6.5. Didn’t show much for 45 min but committed them much better 2nd half. Held ball in key areas. Poor effort with big chance 

Fellows. 7. Good goal and key cog.  Struggled early on as they got tight but much better after break. Got his shots and crosses off

MJ. 7. Not enough of an outlet first 30 but drew in 2 players and his control in tight areas and passes were key to both goals. Real threat. 

Jed 7. Static and no threat for 30, when he makes runs we are a different team. Nice tuck and would have kept him on longer

BTA. 6.5 Energy and decent touch. Put himself about a bit and occupied their centre halves

Swift 5.5. Some control but doing nowhere near enough. Needs to lose timber and impose himself on games 

Bartley 7. Made a difference and swept up a few times against quick forwards.  Shows leadership 

Mvila 6.5. Slightly rusty but dug in and spread the ball. Much more similar to okay that Chalobah 

Reach 6.  Sat in as another LB and filled the space/ covered runners. Decent option when you are winning

Not a lot between the ratings Manc, I agree with your comments.

I thought Manning’s tactics were spot on in terms of how to set up against us, and for 30 minutes they nullified us, but as the first half wore on you could see the tweaks CC was making and we wrestled control of the game. Would say Manning tried to react but we were well in control.

Had they had better forwards they may have punished some of our sloppiness but I felt that had they got one back we could have easily raised the tempo and gone up a gear or two.
Reply
#6
(03-16-2024, 09:35 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-16-2024, 08:37 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Good write up SW.  Agree with most of that.  Don’t think ÇC outwitted Manning. Felt they were the better side first 35 and last 25 (admittedly it was CCs usual tactic of sitting in with something to hold). They passed it well but can’t hit a barn door.  We really should have got a third when we were dominant on hour mark. They had late chances and we weren’t all that comfortable. Marks. 

AP 7.5. Great save first half and routine saves 2nd half. Went longer today but we invited trouble with some short stuff

Furlong. 8. Poor passing first half but very good defensively and won plenty of headers. Probably MOTM 

CT 7.5.  Great assist and supported attack well today. Good defending late on considering his yellow. Cornick a handful 

Pieters. 5.5. Targeted as a weak link and some poor passing undermined him today.  Creaks when he starts. 

Kipre. 7.5 not his most convincing game and some loose passing but solid again. Won key late headers late on from their corners. 

Okay. 6.5. Some poor passing and should have bagged that chance.  Ran out of gas and wise to hook him 

Mowatt 7. Quiet first half but plenty of linkplay 2nd and key clearances when we needed them.  Absolute bonus since September 

Grady. 6.5. Didn’t show much for 45 min but committed them much better 2nd half. Held ball in key areas. Poor effort with big chance 

Fellows. 7. Good goal and key cog.  Struggled early on as they got tight but much better after break. Got his shots and crosses off

MJ. 7. Not enough of an outlet first 30 but drew in 2 players and his control in tight areas and passes were key to both goals. Real threat. 

Jed 7. Static and no threat for 30, when he makes runs we are a different team. Nice tuck and would have kept him on longer

BTA. 6.5 Energy and decent touch. Put himself about a bit and occupied their centre halves

Swift 5.5. Some control but doing nowhere near enough. Needs to lose timber and impose himself on games 

Bartley 7. Made a difference and swept up a few times against quick forwards.  Shows leadership 

Mvila 6.5. Slightly rusty but dug in and spread the ball. Much more similar to okay that Chalobah 

Reach 6.  Sat in as another LB and filled the space/ covered runners. Decent option when you are winning

Not a lot between the ratings Manc, I agree with your comments.

I thought Manning’s tactics were spot on in terms of how to set up against us, and for 30 minutes they nullified us, but as the first half wore on you could see the tweaks CC was making and we wrestled control of the game. Would say Manning tried to react but we were well in control.

Had they had better forwards they may have punished some of our sloppiness but I felt that had they got one back we could have easily raised the tempo and gone up a gear or two.

Agreed. Nothing in them pal. 

Can’t argue.  The trouble is that after his subs to shore it up - it would have been hard to go again
Reply
#7
(03-16-2024, 09:41 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(03-16-2024, 09:35 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-16-2024, 08:37 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Good write up SW.  Agree with most of that.  Don’t think ÇC outwitted Manning. Felt they were the better side first 35 and last 25 (admittedly it was CCs usual tactic of sitting in with something to hold). They passed it well but can’t hit a barn door.  We really should have got a third when we were dominant on hour mark. They had late chances and we weren’t all that comfortable. Marks. 

AP 7.5. Great save first half and routine saves 2nd half. Went longer today but we invited trouble with some short stuff

Furlong. 8. Poor passing first half but very good defensively and won plenty of headers. Probably MOTM 

CT 7.5.  Great assist and supported attack well today. Good defending late on considering his yellow. Cornick a handful 

Pieters. 5.5. Targeted as a weak link and some poor passing undermined him today.  Creaks when he starts. 

Kipre. 7.5 not his most convincing game and some loose passing but solid again. Won key late headers late on from their corners. 

Okay. 6.5. Some poor passing and should have bagged that chance.  Ran out of gas and wise to hook him 

Mowatt 7. Quiet first half but plenty of linkplay 2nd and key clearances when we needed them.  Absolute bonus since September 

Grady. 6.5. Didn’t show much for 45 min but committed them much better 2nd half. Held ball in key areas. Poor effort with big chance 

Fellows. 7. Good goal and key cog.  Struggled early on as they got tight but much better after break. Got his shots and crosses off

MJ. 7. Not enough of an outlet first 30 but drew in 2 players and his control in tight areas and passes were key to both goals. Real threat. 

Jed 7. Static and no threat for 30, when he makes runs we are a different team. Nice tuck and would have kept him on longer

BTA. 6.5 Energy and decent touch. Put himself about a bit and occupied their centre halves

Swift 5.5. Some control but doing nowhere near enough. Needs to lose timber and impose himself on games 

Bartley 7. Made a difference and swept up a few times against quick forwards.  Shows leadership 

Mvila 6.5. Slightly rusty but dug in and spread the ball. Much more similar to okay that Chalobah 

Reach 6.  Sat in as another LB and filled the space/ covered runners. Decent option when you are winning

Not a lot between the ratings Manc, I agree with your comments.

I thought Manning’s tactics were spot on in terms of how to set up against us, and for 30 minutes they nullified us, but as the first half wore on you could see the tweaks CC was making and we wrestled control of the game. Would say Manning tried to react but we were well in control.

Had they had better forwards they may have punished some of our sloppiness but I felt that had they got one back we could have easily raised the tempo and gone up a gear or two.

Agreed. Nothing in them pal. 

Can’t argue.  The trouble is that after his subs to shore it up - it would have been hard to go again

Just a shame they didn’t shore us up Big Grin
Reply
#8
Decent markings in OP. I'd have Townsend not far behind Furlong though. I thought both full backs were excellent yesterday. Probably CTs best game this season.
Reply
#9
Agree with Townsend especially as he got an early booking very professional performance.
When you think there was a player on the opposition side kicking anything in stripes that moved, as well as deliberately handling the ball and he got away with everything hmmmm I wonder who that was.
Reply
#10
(03-17-2024, 09:08 AM)wba13 Wrote: Agree with Townsend especially as he got an early booking very professional performance.
When you think there was a player on the opposition side kicking anything in stripes that moved, as well as deliberately handling the ball and he got away with everything hmmmm I wonder who that was.

Think there was an angry young man in the 22 shirt.
All yesterday proved was that we were right to let him go. Never rated him as highly as some .. was given an elevated status due to being "one of our own". Something he has proven is not mutually respected.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)