Posts: 8,846
Threads: 270
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(03-16-2024, 07:32 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: Prag
Note 4 states the carrying value had been reduced to nil, hence the loan was no longer included as a debtor in the balance sheet. The note also states the carrying value is nil and makes no mention of a provision.
If you look at note 16 you will see “other debtors inc related party loan” dropped from circa £5m to £39k
The postings being
Dr Exceptional Item (p&l)
Cr Debtor Account
To then have a provision for the loan wouldn’t make sense, as it no longer exists on the balance sheet, as it’s already been fully charged to the p&l.
If a provision was created it would result in the p&l being debited twice for the same amount, in order to have a credit in the provision account in the balance sheet. There’s no such item shown in the p&l for an extra provision in addition to the exceptional charge.
The postings now Patel has paid the loan off are
Dr bank
Cr p&l exceptional item received
With your view point… the postings now would also need to clear down the provision
Dr provision ac (balance sheet)
Cr provision ac (p&l)
which would result in double the income to the p&l, having previously charged it twice.
I hope the above has made it clearer.
(03-16-2024, 01:16 AM)johntoewba Wrote: Fulham has to have the final say on everything. Quite frankly it’s pissing me off put your money where your mouth is and actually support the club . Ie buy a ticket and come instead of slagging everyone else off
No I don’t
CA, Fido & Soph were overjoyed believing I was wrong with what I had written and a group wank fest ensued.
My continued posts wouldn’t have occurred if they hadn’t got involved.
Re attending…. I posted recently I would attend a game before the end of the season and to see if anyone fancied a board meet up before the game.
Although it’s amused me no end that you’ve gone off in a little huff and sifted through the details to try and come back with something to validate yourself you’ve made enough financial faux pas on here not to be trusted. So, again, I’ll stick with Prag on this.
Posts: 7,412
Threads: 124
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(03-16-2024, 08:33 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (03-16-2024, 07:43 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: (03-16-2024, 12:16 AM)Jacko Wrote: Among all the squabbling have we got to the fact that this was the £5 million Lai took out of the club to prop up his other businesses, Patel has now paid it back to the club in full, therefore we are £5 million plus interest up on where we were yesterday. In effect he's now paid just over £15 million for the club if you wish to put it in Layman's terms.  Thanks. I can follow that!
Is this so? I thought he'd paid circa £30M plus inherited the MSD debts? Anyway, not quibbling, just relieved we are at last in what appears to be, a safe pair of hands.
That was the reported numbers, but some of that apparently depends on us getting promoted in the next few years.
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
(03-16-2024, 09:00 AM)Fido Wrote: (03-16-2024, 07:32 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: Prag
Note 4 states the carrying value had been reduced to nil, hence the loan was no longer included as a debtor in the balance sheet. The note also states the carrying value is nil and makes no mention of a provision.
If you look at note 16 you will see “other debtors inc related party loan” dropped from circa £5m to £39k
The postings being
Dr Exceptional Item (p&l)
Cr Debtor Account
To then have a provision for the loan wouldn’t make sense, as it no longer exists on the balance sheet, as it’s already been fully charged to the p&l.
If a provision was created it would result in the p&l being debited twice for the same amount, in order to have a credit in the provision account in the balance sheet. There’s no such item shown in the p&l for an extra provision in addition to the exceptional charge.
The postings now Patel has paid the loan off are
Dr bank
Cr p&l exceptional item received
With your view point… the postings now would also need to clear down the provision
Dr provision ac (balance sheet)
Cr provision ac (p&l)
which would result in double the income to the p&l, having previously charged it twice.
I hope the above has made it clearer.
(03-16-2024, 01:16 AM)johntoewba Wrote: Fulham has to have the final say on everything. Quite frankly it’s pissing me off put your money where your mouth is and actually support the club . Ie buy a ticket and come instead of slagging everyone else off
No I don’t
CA, Fido & Soph were overjoyed believing I was wrong with what I had written and a group wank fest ensued.
My continued posts wouldn’t have occurred if they hadn’t got involved.
Re attending…. I posted recently I would attend a game before the end of the season and to see if anyone fancied a board meet up before the game.
Although it’s amused me no end that you’ve gone off in a little huff and sifted through the details to try and come back with something to validate yourself you’ve made enough financial faux pas on here not to be trusted. So, again, I’ll stick with Prag on this.
Not a huff at all. I was intrigued when Prag mentioned a provision and had decided to go and take a further look as that slightly contradicted what I’d posted. If you look at my reply to CA Baggie you will see this is the case.
Why not look at the accounts yourself and see who is right for yourself, rather than believing other people?
Posts: 8,846
Threads: 270
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(03-16-2024, 09:14 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (03-16-2024, 09:00 AM)Fido Wrote: (03-16-2024, 07:32 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: Prag
Note 4 states the carrying value had been reduced to nil, hence the loan was no longer included as a debtor in the balance sheet. The note also states the carrying value is nil and makes no mention of a provision.
If you look at note 16 you will see “other debtors inc related party loan” dropped from circa £5m to £39k
The postings being
Dr Exceptional Item (p&l)
Cr Debtor Account
To then have a provision for the loan wouldn’t make sense, as it no longer exists on the balance sheet, as it’s already been fully charged to the p&l.
If a provision was created it would result in the p&l being debited twice for the same amount, in order to have a credit in the provision account in the balance sheet. There’s no such item shown in the p&l for an extra provision in addition to the exceptional charge.
The postings now Patel has paid the loan off are
Dr bank
Cr p&l exceptional item received
With your view point… the postings now would also need to clear down the provision
Dr provision ac (balance sheet)
Cr provision ac (p&l)
which would result in double the income to the p&l, having previously charged it twice.
I hope the above has made it clearer.
(03-16-2024, 01:16 AM)johntoewba Wrote: Fulham has to have the final say on everything. Quite frankly it’s pissing me off put your money where your mouth is and actually support the club . Ie buy a ticket and come instead of slagging everyone else off
No I don’t
CA, Fido & Soph were overjoyed believing I was wrong with what I had written and a group wank fest ensued.
My continued posts wouldn’t have occurred if they hadn’t got involved.
Re attending…. I posted recently I would attend a game before the end of the season and to see if anyone fancied a board meet up before the game.
Although it’s amused me no end that you’ve gone off in a little huff and sifted through the details to try and come back with something to validate yourself you’ve made enough financial faux pas on here not to be trusted. So, again, I’ll stick with Prag on this.
Not a huff at all. I was intrigued when Prag mentioned a provision and had decided to go and take a further look as that slightly contradicted what I’d posted. If you look at my reply to CA Baggie you will see this is the case.
Why not look at the accounts yourself and see who is right for yourself, rather than believing other people?
1) You're missing the point, it's not my bag and I can't be arsed.
2) Other people are more believable
3) I'll just wait for Prag anyway. Tends to be easier that way.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
One ticket left for today. Go get it FF
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
(03-16-2024, 10:31 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: One ticket left for today. Go get it FF
He's making cheese on toast with his lad.
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
03-16-2024, 10:57 AM
(This post was last modified: 03-16-2024, 10:57 AM by Fulham Fallout.)
(03-16-2024, 10:18 AM)Fido Wrote: (03-16-2024, 09:14 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (03-16-2024, 09:00 AM)Fido Wrote: (03-16-2024, 07:32 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: Prag
Note 4 states the carrying value had been reduced to nil, hence the loan was no longer included as a debtor in the balance sheet. The note also states the carrying value is nil and makes no mention of a provision.
If you look at note 16 you will see “other debtors inc related party loan” dropped from circa £5m to £39k
The postings being
Dr Exceptional Item (p&l)
Cr Debtor Account
To then have a provision for the loan wouldn’t make sense, as it no longer exists on the balance sheet, as it’s already been fully charged to the p&l.
If a provision was created it would result in the p&l being debited twice for the same amount, in order to have a credit in the provision account in the balance sheet. There’s no such item shown in the p&l for an extra provision in addition to the exceptional charge.
The postings now Patel has paid the loan off are
Dr bank
Cr p&l exceptional item received
With your view point… the postings now would also need to clear down the provision
Dr provision ac (balance sheet)
Cr provision ac (p&l)
which would result in double the income to the p&l, having previously charged it twice.
I hope the above has made it clearer.
(03-16-2024, 01:16 AM)johntoewba Wrote: Fulham has to have the final say on everything. Quite frankly it’s pissing me off put your money where your mouth is and actually support the club . Ie buy a ticket and come instead of slagging everyone else off
No I don’t
CA, Fido & Soph were overjoyed believing I was wrong with what I had written and a group wank fest ensued.
My continued posts wouldn’t have occurred if they hadn’t got involved.
Re attending…. I posted recently I would attend a game before the end of the season and to see if anyone fancied a board meet up before the game.
Although it’s amused me no end that you’ve gone off in a little huff and sifted through the details to try and come back with something to validate yourself you’ve made enough financial faux pas on here not to be trusted. So, again, I’ll stick with Prag on this.
Not a huff at all. I was intrigued when Prag mentioned a provision and had decided to go and take a further look as that slightly contradicted what I’d posted. If you look at my reply to CA Baggie you will see this is the case.
Why not look at the accounts yourself and see who is right for yourself, rather than believing other people?
1) You're missing the point, it's not my bag and I can't be arsed.
2) Other people are more believable
3) I'll just wait for Prag anyway. Tends to be easier that way.
Why back people’s sides when you clearly haven’t a clue what they are talking about? I’m rather flattered that I wind you up that much, you troll me.
Anyhow, when Prag looks at the accounts again, I’m sure he will see there wasn’t a provision and will post to confirm, so we can put this discussion to bed.
(03-16-2024, 10:45 AM)MrBater Wrote: (03-16-2024, 10:31 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: One ticket left for today. Go get it FF
He's making cheese on toast with his lad.
That did make me loff tbf
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(03-16-2024, 10:57 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: Anyhow, when Prag looks at the accounts again, I’m sure he will see there wasn’t a provision and will post to confirm, so we can put this discussion to bed.
I think most people reading this are already asleep
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
(03-16-2024, 10:59 AM)Sliced Wrote: (03-16-2024, 10:57 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: Anyhow, when Prag looks at the accounts again, I’m sure he will see there wasn’t a provision and will post to confirm, so we can put this discussion to bed.
I think most people reading this are already asleep
Good olde double entry book keeping.
We should ask M Galeo and Lurker for their onions.
Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(03-16-2024, 09:14 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (03-16-2024, 09:00 AM)Fido Wrote: (03-16-2024, 07:32 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: Prag
Note 4 states the carrying value had been reduced to nil, hence the loan was no longer included as a debtor in the balance sheet. The note also states the carrying value is nil and makes no mention of a provision.
If you look at note 16 you will see “other debtors inc related party loan” dropped from circa £5m to £39k
The postings being
Dr Exceptional Item (p&l)
Cr Debtor Account
To then have a provision for the loan wouldn’t make sense, as it no longer exists on the balance sheet, as it’s already been fully charged to the p&l.
If a provision was created it would result in the p&l being debited twice for the same amount, in order to have a credit in the provision account in the balance sheet. There’s no such item shown in the p&l for an extra provision in addition to the exceptional charge.
The postings now Patel has paid the loan off are
Dr bank
Cr p&l exceptional item received
With your view point… the postings now would also need to clear down the provision
Dr provision ac (balance sheet)
Cr provision ac (p&l)
which would result in double the income to the p&l, having previously charged it twice.
I hope the above has made it clearer.
(03-16-2024, 01:16 AM)johntoewba Wrote: Fulham has to have the final say on everything. Quite frankly it’s pissing me off put your money where your mouth is and actually support the club . Ie buy a ticket and come instead of slagging everyone else off
No I don’t
CA, Fido & Soph were overjoyed believing I was wrong with what I had written and a group wank fest ensued.
My continued posts wouldn’t have occurred if they hadn’t got involved.
Re attending…. I posted recently I would attend a game before the end of the season and to see if anyone fancied a board meet up before the game.
Although it’s amused me no end that you’ve gone off in a little huff and sifted through the details to try and come back with something to validate yourself you’ve made enough financial faux pas on here not to be trusted. So, again, I’ll stick with Prag on this.
Not a huff at all. I was intrigued when Prag mentioned a provision and had decided to go and take a further look as that slightly contradicted what I’d posted. If you look at my reply to CA Baggie you will see this is the case.
Why not look at the accounts yourself and see who is right for yourself, rather than believing other people?
No idea why you’re making this so complicated.
The Notes to the Accounts very clearly refer to the impairment of the loan. The effect of the impairment is to reduce the VALUE of the loan asset to nil on the balance sheet, but it’s still “on the balance sheet”, albeit it at nil value, because it still existed. The other side of the bookkeeping entry for the impairment (which is a provision!) is to have debited the P&L Account/Reserves.
Now, with the loan repaid, the impairment is reversed to restore the loan at full value to the balance sheet, which means a Debit of £5m to the Balance Sheet and a Credit of £5m to the P&L Account. And then the next step is to Debit Cash with £5m, and Credit the newly-restored Loans Receivable with £5m to get rid of the loan references altogether.
|