Loan repaid
#41
No wonder you can never get hold of a half decent accountant, they're all on football forums arguing the toss all day! Big Grin
Reply
#42
Isnt it nice to have owners who have well being of our club heart and know what they are doing.
Reply
#43
(03-15-2024, 08:27 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-15-2024, 07:58 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-15-2024, 07:37 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-15-2024, 07:28 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(03-15-2024, 06:56 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: Huh?  It was owed by Wisdom Smart, not to Wisdom Smart!

The amount owed was deducted from the purchase price so that the repayment shows as “revenue” for FFP purposes due to it being a write back of the previous bad debt provision in the accounts


Not quite 100% correct as the loan was never written off.  It was merely fully provided for in the accounts as a doubtful debt.  It never ceased to be owed. 

For FFP purposes it’s the equivalent of selling an Academy player for £5m but without actually losing a player.

The difference between a provision and a write off.  I think some of of our #financial experts should stick to the #head chef threads.

Funny you say that, as I am going to go back and look at the last balance sheet to see if the loan was still in it or not. 

Whether the loan was or wasn’t in the last balance sheet, the net result to the P&L and FFP are identical. 

The chef is currently cooking dinner and will revert.

You’ll find it in Note 4 to the Accounts.  Still existed (so not written off) and fully impaired as a doubtful debt.  

Logically, if it had already been written off then it couldn’t have been repaid now!

The debtor for the loan (note 16) shows the loan present for 2021 and not for 2022 and states it’s carrying value was reduced to nil. 

If a provision had been made, the debtor would still be in the balance sheet with a corresponding credit for the provision sitting as a credit in the creditor section of the balance sheet.   There isn’t either. 

The entry made in the accounts was cr debtor, dr exceptional item in the p&l.

Re the loan being written off and repaid.  It doesn’t matter if it was previously written off in the accounts.  WBA did not sign a contract with wisdom to say you no longer need to pay us the money.  If wisdom had paid the money today, the loan would have been repaid.  We wouldn’t have said, “you can’t pay us back as we’ve debited the p&l with the full amount”.

(03-15-2024, 08:22 PM)Fido Wrote:
(03-15-2024, 08:14 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Remember that FootballBets account that got everything wrong, every time...

Oh, and how someone laughed...

I did when I saw your ugly face on the E&D post match interview. 

See my reply to Prag.

That’s incorrect re still showing the debtor on the balance sheet.  The provision to fully unpaid it would been DR P&L account, CR Loan due from Wisdom Smart.  Note 4 explains it clearly.

(03-15-2024, 08:56 PM)waffle Wrote:
(03-15-2024, 08:52 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-15-2024, 08:49 PM)waffle Wrote:
(03-15-2024, 08:27 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: If a provision had been made, the debtor would still be in the balance sheet with a corresponding credit for the provision sitting as a credit in the creditor section of the balance sheet.   There isn’t either. 

Maybe check again on that one.

Other debtors including related party loan £39k 2022, £5,072k 2021.

The bit about the provision sitting in the BS as creditor.  Not sure that’s the case.

You are right

(03-15-2024, 09:01 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-15-2024, 08:56 PM)waffle Wrote:
(03-15-2024, 08:52 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-15-2024, 08:49 PM)waffle Wrote:
(03-15-2024, 08:27 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: If a provision had been made, the debtor would still be in the balance sheet with a corresponding credit for the provision sitting as a credit in the creditor section of the balance sheet.   There isn’t either. 

Maybe check again on that one.

Other debtors including related party loan £39k 2022, £5,072k 2021.

The bit about the provision sitting in the BS as creditor.  Not sure that’s the case.

If you have a provision, you retain the debtor balance. So the net effect is 0 as there’s a debtor and a creditor with the same value (if fully provided for).

Nope

(03-15-2024, 09:48 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: You wouldn’t have a debtor and a creditor.  You’d just have no debtor.

Essentially it’s the same as it has gone through the P&L and therefore its repayment is a positive for FFP.

If you have any self awareness, even the slightest iota, you’d realise that people pick you for stuff like this because of your cunty, oneupmanship, narcissistic behaviour.

Try a different persona.

Correct on all counts!
Reply
#44
Among all the squabbling have we got to the fact that this was the £5 million Lai took out of the club to prop up his other businesses, Patel has now paid it back to the club in full, therefore we are £5 million plus interest up on where we were yesterday. In effect he's now paid just over £15 million for the club if you wish to put it in Layman's terms.  Wink
Reply
#45
Fulham has to have the final say on everything. Quite frankly it’s pissing me off put your money where your mouth is and actually support the club . Ie buy a ticket and come instead of slagging everyone else off
Reply
#46
At least they have chucked some cash in to the day to day business.

That hasn't happened in years, I don't think?
Reply
#47
(03-16-2024, 12:16 AM)Jacko Wrote: Among all the squabbling have we got to the fact that this was the £5 million Lai took out of the club to prop up his other businesses, Patel has now paid it back to the club in full, therefore we are £5 million plus interest up on where we were yesterday. In effect he's now paid just over £15 million for the club if you wish to put it in Layman's terms.  Wink

Agreed.  Good summary
Reply
#48
Prag

Note 4 states the carrying value had been reduced to nil, hence the loan was no longer included as a debtor in the balance sheet. The note also states the carrying value is nil and makes no mention of a provision.  

If you look at note 16 you will see “other debtors inc related party loan” dropped from circa £5m to £39k

The postings being
Dr Exceptional Item (p&l)
Cr Debtor Account

To then have a provision for the loan wouldn’t make sense, as it no longer exists on the balance sheet, as it’s already been fully charged to the p&l.

If a provision was created it would result in the p&l being debited twice for the same amount, in order to have a credit in the provision account in the balance sheet.  There’s no such item shown in the p&l for an extra provision in addition to the exceptional charge.

The postings now Patel has paid the loan off are
Dr bank
Cr p&l exceptional item received

With your view point… the postings now would also need to clear down the provision
Dr provision ac (balance sheet)
Cr provision ac (p&l)

which would result in double the income to the p&l, having previously charged it twice.

I hope the above has made it clearer.

(03-16-2024, 01:16 AM)johntoewba Wrote: Fulham has to have the final say on everything. Quite frankly it’s pissing me off put your money where your mouth is and actually support the club . Ie buy a ticket and come instead of slagging everyone else off

No I don’t Big Grin 


CA, Fido & Soph were overjoyed believing I was wrong with what I had written and a group wank fest ensued. 

My continued posts wouldn’t have occurred if they hadn’t got involved. 


Re attending…. I posted recently I would attend a game before the end of the season and to see if anyone fancied a board meet up before the game.
Reply
#49
(03-16-2024, 12:16 AM)Jacko Wrote: Among all the squabbling have we got to the fact that this was the £5 million Lai took out of the club to prop up his other businesses, Patel has now paid it back to the club in full, therefore we are £5 million plus interest up on where we were yesterday. In effect he's now paid just over £15 million for the club if you wish to put it in Layman's terms.  Wink
Thanks. I can follow that!
Reply
#50
(03-16-2024, 07:43 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(03-16-2024, 12:16 AM)Jacko Wrote: Among all the squabbling have we got to the fact that this was the £5 million Lai took out of the club to prop up his other businesses, Patel has now paid it back to the club in full, therefore we are £5 million plus interest up on where we were yesterday. In effect he's now paid just over £15 million for the club if you wish to put it in Layman's terms.  Wink
Thanks. I can follow that!

Is this so? I thought he'd paid circa £30M plus inherited the MSD debts? Anyway, not quibbling, just relieved we are at last in what appears to be, a safe pair of hands.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: