The cricket - - - -
(03-09-2024, 11:32 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: One stunning fact I've read encapsulates this pathetic shambles from England in this test. If you take Root out of the equation, the rest of the team batted for TWENTY SEVEN over! Over BOTH innings.
This is test cricket, not a circus.
Some of the awful shots from recognised batsmen would not be accepted in village cricket. Bazball has some positives I'm sure. But it is another fact that from being 4th in the WCT ranking in 22/23 England now sit above only Bangladesh. Test cricket Bazball needs to be re-invented otherwise we might as well do away with it as far as England are concerned when it comes to playing the elite nations.

Finally a sensible post that encapsulates what is wrong with the current style. 

I'm convinced with a traditional approach we'd have won the Ashes last Summer, yet we contrived to throw it away. Ditto Tests 2 & 3 of this series, by all accounts.
Reply
(03-09-2024, 11:32 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: One stunning fact I've read encapsulates this pathetic shambles from England in this test. If you take Root out of the equation, the rest of the team batted for TWENTY SEVEN over! Over BOTH innings.
This is test cricket, not a circus.
Some of the awful shots from recognised batsmen would not be accepted in village cricket. Bazball has some positives I'm sure. But it is another fact that from being 4th in the WCT ranking in 22/23 England now sit above only Bangladesh. Test cricket Bazball needs to be re-invented otherwise we might as well do away with it as far as England are concerned when it comes to playing the elite nations.

Good point, if a tad hyperbolic. 

I was watching yesterday morning when Sarfaraz and Paditak(sp) had come in after two quick wickets. India were not in trouble, but there was a chance for England to restrict Indias first innings lead. Both batsmen were initially patient, and that led to a 100+ partnership and took the game completely away from England.

Not sure our batsmen in a similar situation would have done this. We bat like we are playing limited overs cricket. How many times do we make the opposition take a second new ball...not often.
Reply
(03-09-2024, 01:38 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(03-09-2024, 11:32 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: One stunning fact I've read encapsulates this pathetic shambles from England in this test. If you take Root out of the equation, the rest of the team batted for TWENTY SEVEN over! Over BOTH innings.
This is test cricket, not a circus.
Some of the awful shots from recognised batsmen would not be accepted in village cricket. Bazball has some positives I'm sure. But it is another fact that from being 4th in the WCT ranking in 22/23 England now sit above only Bangladesh. Test cricket Bazball needs to be re-invented otherwise we might as well do away with it as far as England are concerned when it comes to playing the elite nations.

Good point, if a tad hyperbolic. 

I was watching yesterday morning when Sarfaraz and Paditak(sp) had come in after two quick wickets. India were not in trouble, but there was a chance for England to restrict Indias first innings lead. Both batsmen were initially patient, and that led to a 100+ partnership and took the game completely away from England.

Not sure our batsmen in a similar situation would have done this. We bat like we are playing limited overs cricket. How many times do we make the opposition take a second new ball...not often.
Hyperbolic and Bazball ... suited bedfellows! Big Grin
Reply
Jimmy Anderson 700 test wickets!!…great effort well done.
When Jimmy took his first test wicket & know taking his 700th England were near enough bottom of the Test rankings on both occasions
Reply
(03-09-2024, 11:52 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(03-09-2024, 11:32 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: One stunning fact I've read encapsulates this pathetic shambles from England in this test. If you take Root out of the equation, the rest of the team batted for TWENTY SEVEN over! Over BOTH innings.
This is test cricket, not a circus.
Some of the awful shots from recognised batsmen would not be accepted in village cricket. Bazball has some positives I'm sure. But it is another fact that from being 4th in the WCT ranking in 22/23 England now sit above only Bangladesh. Test cricket Bazball needs to be re-invented otherwise we might as well do away with it as far as England are concerned when it comes to playing the elite nations.

Finally a sensible post that encapsulates what is wrong with the current style. 

I'm convinced with a traditional approach we'd have won the Ashes last Summer, yet we contrived to throw it away. Ditto Tests 2 & 3 of this series, by all accounts.
Your numbers are not right, 27 for the second innings but not both innings, the openers combined are over 20 for the first innings alone
Reply
(03-09-2024, 03:38 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(03-09-2024, 11:52 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(03-09-2024, 11:32 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: One stunning fact I've read encapsulates this pathetic shambles from England in this test. If you take Root out of the equation, the rest of the team batted for TWENTY SEVEN over! Over BOTH innings.
This is test cricket, not a circus.
Some of the awful shots from recognised batsmen would not be accepted in village cricket. Bazball has some positives I'm sure. But it is another fact that from being 4th in the WCT ranking in 22/23 England now sit above only Bangladesh. Test cricket Bazball needs to be re-invented otherwise we might as well do away with it as far as England are concerned when it comes to playing the elite nations.

Finally a sensible post that encapsulates what is wrong with the current style. 

I'm convinced with a traditional approach we'd have won the Ashes last Summer, yet we contrived to throw it away. Ditto Tests 2 & 3 of this series, by all accounts.
Your numbers are not right, 27 for the second innings but not both innings, the openers combined are over 20 for the first innings alone

Not my numbers .. I had read it somewhere.  Should have checked of course.
Think the 2nd innings figures alone are a savage indictment of the careless and frivolous way England have gone about this last test. Dead rubber or not ... would we tolerate it from our football team?
Reply
England’s record in the 15 months before Bazball - P 17. 1 win, 5 draws, 11 defeats. Win percentage 5.9%.

With Bazball under McCullum and Stokes - Played 24. 14 wins, 1 draw, 9 defeats. Win percentage 59%. A ten times better win percentage!

Bazball clearly isn’t going to go away. But it does need some refinement. It can’t be 5th gear all the time against India (especially in India) or v Australia. 4th gear and even 3rd gear is the necessary tweak I think. Pointless is going back to traditional methods.
Reply
(03-09-2024, 04:24 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: England’s record in the 15 months before Bazball - P 17. 1 win, 5 draws, 11 defeats.  Win percentage 5.9%.

With Bazball under McCullum and Stokes - Played 24.  14 wins, 1 draw, 9 defeats.  Win percentage 59%.  A ten times better win percentage!

Bazball clearly isn’t going to go away. But it does need some refinement.  It can’t be 5th gear all the time against India (especially in India) or v Australia. 4th gear and even 3rd gear is the necessary tweak I think.  Pointless is going back to traditional methods.

There are lies damn lies & statistics!!!!…those England victories were against weaker opposition & at home mostly!!.The two biggest tests series they played facts are did England win the Ashes NO did England beat India in India another big fat NO.
I guess all will be great when England smash the WIs & Sri Lanka in the summer.
Reply
(03-09-2024, 04:57 PM)pindgill Wrote:
(03-09-2024, 04:24 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: England’s record in the 15 months before Bazball - P 17. 1 win, 5 draws, 11 defeats.  Win percentage 5.9%.

With Bazball under McCullum and Stokes - Played 24.  14 wins, 1 draw, 9 defeats.  Win percentage 59%.  A ten times better win percentage!

Bazball clearly isn’t going to go away. But it does need some refinement.  It can’t be 5th gear all the time against India (especially in India) or v Australia. 4th gear and even 3rd gear is the necessary tweak I think.  Pointless is going back to traditional methods.

There are lies damn lies & statistics!!!!…those England victories were against weaker opposition & at home mostly!!.The two biggest tests series they played facts are did England win the Ashes NO did England beat India in India another big fat NO.
I guess all will be great when England smash the WIs & Sri Lanka in the summer.

That only partly explains the stats, but that’s what I was trying to say.  Bazball doesn’t heed to be abandoned but needs to be tweaked for playing India (in India at least) and Australia.  We’ll hammer everyone else with it.
Reply
I don't think there was much Bazball played this series. Root dug in today, and also did in the last test. Robinson and Foulkes dug in when required last test. Some batsmen threw their wickets away, this has happened before the Bazball term was ever coined.  The new management has bought much good with it but hasn't managed to sweep away the previous bad. There are many positives about the current management but nothing can defend Duckett today, or Pope yesterday. And those things regularly happened before Bazball. I've been drinking fizzy, gassy bottles since we finished early today so will try and post something sensible tomorrow but I certainly don't blame either Bazball or the mentioned dead rubber ideas. Professional pride and personal responsibility should be the target of all sportsmen. (Says me!!! AWOL for a month but still capable of pointing out how it ought to be). Wounded to get rolled over though.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: