Posts: 27,980
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(03-05-2024, 12:55 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: (03-05-2024, 12:16 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (03-05-2024, 12:10 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Compare and contrast the atmosphere at the Manchester derby with that at the AFC Wimbledon vs Milton Keynes game. It's poles apart, one actually means something and the other is a TV show.
Hatred always creates a atmosphere look at us against wolves .......tribalism
Sky are Gradually getting what they set out to do sanitisation of football so it's just a family day out like going to alton towers ...
I kinda see where you're going with this. But no one wants to see violence or agro at games. It should be a safe environment for all to attend.
A few years ago, Yeltz V Stourbridge was a really great and hostile atmosphere, but due to a handful of kids chucking stuff at opposition fans, and fighting outside the ground, it has become a sterile atmosphere, as fans are now segregated and there is a police presence. Both clubs are 100% correct to take this course of action, but it has killed the atmosphere off.
Why can't fans create that atmosphere without acting like Neanderthal cunts, and ruining the experience for the majority of decent fans.
And that's the million dollar question: how do you create a passionate atmosphere without the intellectually challenged ruining it?
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(03-05-2024, 01:13 PM)Duffers Wrote: (03-05-2024, 12:55 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: (03-05-2024, 12:16 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (03-05-2024, 12:10 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Compare and contrast the atmosphere at the Manchester derby with that at the AFC Wimbledon vs Milton Keynes game. It's poles apart, one actually means something and the other is a TV show.
Hatred always creates a atmosphere look at us against wolves .......tribalism
Sky are Gradually getting what they set out to do sanitisation of football so it's just a family day out like going to alton towers ...
I kinda see where you're going with this. But no one wants to see violence or agro at games. It should be a safe environment for all to attend.
A few years ago, Yeltz V Stourbridge was a really great and hostile atmosphere, but due to a handful of kids chucking stuff at opposition fans, and fighting outside the ground, it has become a sterile atmosphere, as fans are now segregated and there is a police presence. Both clubs are 100% correct to take this course of action, but it has killed the atmosphere off.
Why can't fans create that atmosphere without acting like Neanderthal cunts, and ruining the experience for the majority of decent fans.
And that's the million dollar question: how do you create a passionate atmosphere without the intellectually challenged ruining it?
I did mention it after the Wolves games but like it or not the best atmospheres are generated when fans are stood and when fans are fired up. That comes hand in hand with a few who take it too far. It's almost unavoidable to have one without the other. The only exception would be games where a side has been promoted or won something where it's more of a party atmosphere but you can't generate that at every game.
If everyone went to the match and adopted the Derek approach there would be zero atmosphere and just some polite clapping, you can't have too much of that just as you can't have it go too far the other way like it did against Wolves. You need to make adequate provision for both otherwise for big games you'll end up with the crusties in the East Stand with some yoof stood in front of them all game. Introducing safe standing at the Hawthorns - obviously the whole of the SME, the Millenium Corner and parts of the BRE would help with this (if you're listening Mr Patel).
Also, completely disagree with Josh re the Stourbridge - Halesowen game. The 4-3 game earlier in the season had a great atmosphere, in part down to segregation. I'd say the balance that day was spot on in terms of being passionate from both sides without spilling over into any nonsense.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Normally the second game on the sky super Sunday programme kicks off at 4.30 pm.
So the timing of this game was moved, not sure why, but this also happened in the other Manchester Derby played this season.
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
Think far too many people are buying into the over-hyped histrionics surrounding the Wolves game. This game was a one off cup game between two rivals who hadn't played each other for donkey's and one had a massive, recent, advantage, which made the bragging rights all the more precious. Add in the issues around ticketing and allocations and you see a sequence of events that led to a minor but unfortunate, and understandable, "scuffle". It wasn't all out war or anything like we've seen in the 70's and, therefore should not be used to tarnish the name of OUR fans.
I know some on here love nothing better than to put our own fans down, but it's just not fair or true. I've been going for 40 odd years and our fans are amongst the best in the country and our ground is one of the safest because of that. We are certainly not a club full of braindead neanderthals. If anything, the atmosphere can be too subdued at times and that's probably because we are always a little bit scared to get over-excited in case we curse it and it all goes tits up!
Posts: 6,454
Threads: 192
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(03-05-2024, 02:29 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Think far too many people are buying into the over-hyped histrionics surrounding the Wolves game. This game was a one off cup game between two rivals who hadn't played each other for donkey's and one had a massive, recent, advantage, which made the bragging rights all the more precious. Add in the issues around ticketing and allocations and you see a sequence of events that led to a minor but unfortunate, and understandable, "scuffle". It wasn't all out war or anything like we've seen in the 70's and, therefore should not be used to tarnish the name of OUR fans.
I know some on here love nothing better than to put our own fans down, but it's just not fair or true. I've been going for 40 odd years and our fans are amongst the best in the country and our ground is one of the safest because of that. We are certainly not a club full of braindead neanderthals. If anything, the atmosphere can be too subdued at times and that's probably because we are always a little bit scared to get over-excited in case we curse it and it all goes tits up!
100% correct. The circumstances of the cup game with the 6 fingered lot were a bit one off and the trouble at the game, whilst very unacceptable, has been hyped and overblown. Not helped by the sensationalist reporting and TV exposure and by the overlong delay in restarting the game.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(03-05-2024, 02:29 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Think far too many people are buying into the over-hyped histrionics surrounding the Wolves game. This game was a one off cup game between two rivals who hadn't played each other for donkey's and one had a massive, recent, advantage, which made the bragging rights all the more precious. Add in the issues around ticketing and allocations and you see a sequence of events that led to a minor but unfortunate, and understandable, "scuffle". It wasn't all out war or anything like we've seen in the 70's and, therefore should not be used to tarnish the name of OUR fans.
I know some on here love nothing better than to put our own fans down, but it's just not fair or true. I've been going for 40 odd years and our fans are amongst the best in the country and our ground is one of the safest because of that. We are certainly not a club full of braindead neanderthals. If anything, the atmosphere can be too subdued at times and that's probably because we are always a little bit scared to get over-excited in case we curse it and it all goes tits up!
Fair post, I think.
Posts: 3,884
Threads: 161
Joined: Mar 2022
03-05-2024, 03:48 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-05-2024, 03:53 PM by Woodman scoreboard.)
(03-05-2024, 02:57 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (03-05-2024, 02:29 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Think far too many people are buying into the over-hyped histrionics surrounding the Wolves game. This game was a one off cup game between two rivals who hadn't played each other for donkey's and one had a massive, recent, advantage, which made the bragging rights all the more precious. Add in the issues around ticketing and allocations and you see a sequence of events that led to a minor but unfortunate, and understandable, "scuffle". It wasn't all out war or anything like we've seen in the 70's and, therefore should not be used to tarnish the name of OUR fans.
I know some on here love nothing better than to put our own fans down, but it's just not fair or true. I've been going for 40 odd years and our fans are amongst the best in the country and our ground is one of the safest because of that. We are certainly not a club full of braindead neanderthals. If anything, the atmosphere can be too subdued at times and that's probably because we are always a little bit scared to get over-excited in case we curse it and it all goes tits up!
100% correct. The circumstances of the cup game with the 6 fingered lot were a bit one off and the trouble at the game, whilst very unacceptable, has been hyped and overblown. Not helped by the sensationalist reporting and TV exposure and by the overlong delay in restarting the game.
Thank god for a sensible post are you new on here
(03-05-2024, 01:13 PM)Duffers Wrote: (03-05-2024, 12:55 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: (03-05-2024, 12:16 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (03-05-2024, 12:10 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Compare and contrast the atmosphere at the Manchester derby with that at the AFC Wimbledon vs Milton Keynes game. It's poles apart, one actually means something and the other is a TV show.
Hatred always creates a atmosphere look at us against wolves .......tribalism
Sky are Gradually getting what they set out to do sanitisation of football so it's just a family day out like going to alton towers ...
I kinda see where you're going with this. But no one wants to see violence or agro at games. It should be a safe environment for all to attend.
A few years ago, Yeltz V Stourbridge was a really great and hostile atmosphere, but due to a handful of kids chucking stuff at opposition fans, and fighting outside the ground, it has become a sterile atmosphere, as fans are now segregated and there is a police presence. Both clubs are 100% correct to take this course of action, but it has killed the atmosphere off.
Why can't fans create that atmosphere without acting like Neanderthal cunts, and ruining the experience for the majority of decent fans.
And that's the million dollar question: how do you create a passionate atmosphere without the intellectually challenged ruining it?
Calling people intellectually challenged is rather pitiful mate if I'm honest you are much better than that .......2 blokes who I know in their 50's who are very successful business men have had their season tickets suspended for pointing out wolves fans In corporate the police have told the club that they have done nothing but the club still havnt let them back in the ground .......not intellectually challenged .......now they won't bother renewing the corporate again ...
Posts: 1,987
Threads: 36
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation:
4
I disagree about a good atmosphere leads to trouble. Seals PO semi the other year was an awesome atmosphere, no trouble that I remember.
Posts: 27,980
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(03-05-2024, 03:48 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (03-05-2024, 02:57 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (03-05-2024, 02:29 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Think far too many people are buying into the over-hyped histrionics surrounding the Wolves game. This game was a one off cup game between two rivals who hadn't played each other for donkey's and one had a massive, recent, advantage, which made the bragging rights all the more precious. Add in the issues around ticketing and allocations and you see a sequence of events that led to a minor but unfortunate, and understandable, "scuffle". It wasn't all out war or anything like we've seen in the 70's and, therefore should not be used to tarnish the name of OUR fans.
I know some on here love nothing better than to put our own fans down, but it's just not fair or true. I've been going for 40 odd years and our fans are amongst the best in the country and our ground is one of the safest because of that. We are certainly not a club full of braindead neanderthals. If anything, the atmosphere can be too subdued at times and that's probably because we are always a little bit scared to get over-excited in case we curse it and it all goes tits up!
100% correct. The circumstances of the cup game with the 6 fingered lot were a bit one off and the trouble at the game, whilst very unacceptable, has been hyped and overblown. Not helped by the sensationalist reporting and TV exposure and by the overlong delay in restarting the game.
Thank god for a sensible post are you new on here 
(03-05-2024, 01:13 PM)Duffers Wrote: (03-05-2024, 12:55 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: (03-05-2024, 12:16 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (03-05-2024, 12:10 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Compare and contrast the atmosphere at the Manchester derby with that at the AFC Wimbledon vs Milton Keynes game. It's poles apart, one actually means something and the other is a TV show.
Hatred always creates a atmosphere look at us against wolves .......tribalism
Sky are Gradually getting what they set out to do sanitisation of football so it's just a family day out like going to alton towers ...
I kinda see where you're going with this. But no one wants to see violence or agro at games. It should be a safe environment for all to attend.
A few years ago, Yeltz V Stourbridge was a really great and hostile atmosphere, but due to a handful of kids chucking stuff at opposition fans, and fighting outside the ground, it has become a sterile atmosphere, as fans are now segregated and there is a police presence. Both clubs are 100% correct to take this course of action, but it has killed the atmosphere off.
Why can't fans create that atmosphere without acting like Neanderthal cunts, and ruining the experience for the majority of decent fans.
And that's the million dollar question: how do you create a passionate atmosphere without the intellectually challenged ruining it?
Calling people intellectually challenged is rather pitiful mate if I'm honest you are much better than that .......2 blokes who I know in their 50's who are very successful business men have had their season tickets suspended for pointing out wolves fans In corporate the police have told the club that they have done nothing but the club still havnt let them back in the ground .......not intellectually challenged .......now they won't bother renewing the corporate again ...
How would you describe the dozens of grown men who upon seeing one or two Dingles in the home end decided to kick off to the point the game needed to be stopped? How pathetic and thick must you be to be so enraged by that to such a level that you need to act like an horny gorilla? The people doing that are not intelligent people. Games don't get stopped for mere "pointing out" do they? What happened was the result of very stupid people being very stupid.
"Oooh they were goading us" the thickos will say. So fucking what? It's no excuse is it?
What should have happened was the Dingle or Dingles involved should have been kicked out and the people who gave them the tickets should have been prevented from ever buying them again. But no, a bunch of morons decided to take matters into their own hands and that's how we end up with the scenes we saw.
Posts: 3,884
Threads: 161
Joined: Mar 2022
(03-05-2024, 04:05 PM)Duffers Wrote: (03-05-2024, 03:48 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: (03-05-2024, 02:57 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (03-05-2024, 02:29 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Think far too many people are buying into the over-hyped histrionics surrounding the Wolves game. This game was a one off cup game between two rivals who hadn't played each other for donkey's and one had a massive, recent, advantage, which made the bragging rights all the more precious. Add in the issues around ticketing and allocations and you see a sequence of events that led to a minor but unfortunate, and understandable, "scuffle". It wasn't all out war or anything like we've seen in the 70's and, therefore should not be used to tarnish the name of OUR fans.
I know some on here love nothing better than to put our own fans down, but it's just not fair or true. I've been going for 40 odd years and our fans are amongst the best in the country and our ground is one of the safest because of that. We are certainly not a club full of braindead neanderthals. If anything, the atmosphere can be too subdued at times and that's probably because we are always a little bit scared to get over-excited in case we curse it and it all goes tits up!
100% correct. The circumstances of the cup game with the 6 fingered lot were a bit one off and the trouble at the game, whilst very unacceptable, has been hyped and overblown. Not helped by the sensationalist reporting and TV exposure and by the overlong delay in restarting the game.
Thank god for a sensible post are you new on here 
(03-05-2024, 01:13 PM)Duffers Wrote: (03-05-2024, 12:55 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: (03-05-2024, 12:16 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: Hatred always creates a atmosphere look at us against wolves .......tribalism
Sky are Gradually getting what they set out to do sanitisation of football so it's just a family day out like going to alton towers ...
I kinda see where you're going with this. But no one wants to see violence or agro at games. It should be a safe environment for all to attend.
A few years ago, Yeltz V Stourbridge was a really great and hostile atmosphere, but due to a handful of kids chucking stuff at opposition fans, and fighting outside the ground, it has become a sterile atmosphere, as fans are now segregated and there is a police presence. Both clubs are 100% correct to take this course of action, but it has killed the atmosphere off.
Why can't fans create that atmosphere without acting like Neanderthal cunts, and ruining the experience for the majority of decent fans.
And that's the million dollar question: how do you create a passionate atmosphere without the intellectually challenged ruining it?
Calling people intellectually challenged is rather pitiful mate if I'm honest you are much better than that .......2 blokes who I know in their 50's who are very successful business men have had their season tickets suspended for pointing out wolves fans In corporate the police have told the club that they have done nothing but the club still havnt let them back in the ground .......not intellectually challenged .......now they won't bother renewing the corporate again ...
How would you describe the dozens of grown men who upon seeing one or two Dingles in the home end decided to kick off to the point the game needed to be stopped? How pathetic and thick must you be to be so enraged by that to such a level that you need to act like an horny gorilla? The people doing that are not intelligent people. Games don't get stopped for mere "pointing out" do they? What happened was the result of very stupid people being very stupid.
"Oooh they were goading us" the thickos will say. So fucking what? It's no excuse is it?
What should have happened was the Dingle or Dingles involved should have been kicked out and the people who gave them the tickets should have been prevented from ever buying them again. But no, a bunch of morons decided to take matters into their own hands and that's how we end up with the scenes we saw.
So anyone who got nicked rightly or wrong are not intelligent.......nothing like a sweeping statement.
|