Ray Tings
#11
I think our Palmer deserves at least 6.5 - didn't have to make any wonder saves but had all of their shots on target covered easily and always solid with crosses and distro. In fact right at the end he played a wonderball to Reach.

Agree that their Palmer was the biggest problem we had - Chalobah helped give us our muscle in the middle to dampen it down a little towards the end.
Reply
#12
Their Palmer is the sort of player we should be looking at when we get promoted ?
Or does he already belong to Man city!


When....is tongue in cheek btw.
Reply
#13
I thought it was a decent performance all said. We had the bottle when it mattered and played well without the ball. The shape was impenetrable at times, restricting Cov mainly to long range efforts that sailed well over or wide most of the time. A good win v a decent enough side.

Palmer - 7 One decent catch from a shot at him and plucked a couple of half chances from under the bar
Furlong - 6 . Worked hard and defended well most of the time, but poor first half when he gave away possession in a spell.
Townsend - 7 Always solid and supported the attack when he had to doubling up well. Solid.
Pieters - 8 . Would have been 9 but some longer passes went astray . Immense defending.
Kipre - 7 . Decent for a majority of the game , but struggled a little in a second half spell and gave a way the pen when he went with his wrong foot for the challenge.
Yokulsu 8- Another Yok performance . Never seems to concede possession , has time and strength (although I think he was caught once when they had two around him).
Mowatt 9 - MoM. A near to a complete a midfield performance as you'll ever see. He has energy in spades.
Fellows 6 - not as effective as normal but great run and cross for Grady's goal.
Diangana - 7 Worked tirelessly and was a threat. A couple of dribbles went astray first half, but Cov resorted to fouling him to stop him. Nice finish for the goal.
Johnstone - 7 Great goal and a menace in the first half when on the ball. Did the 'ugly stuff' when needed. Faded 2nd half.
Wallace - 6. Hard working performance, in for him, an unnatural position as lone man up top, but he worked hard and went wider in 2nd half after subs.

Subs

Reach 8 - Thought he slotted in effortlessly and used the ball well. One great through ball to Wallace.
Chalobah - 6 Not too bad , but gave the ball away a couple of times. Helped us gain control in middle of the park the later stages.
Swift - 6 Did ok, but didn't get too involved but he looked composed and helped us later on.
Bartley - 6 Only a few minutes but defended well enough.
Weimann - 5 . Didn't really influence much in the game, but worked hard to harry their defenders.

Not a top performance, but decent enough and one I think I deserved to win. On the ball we were better than Cov and clinical in front of goal. We had the mental strength and resilience to hold them off in a tricky last 20 minutes. But apart from a half chance, Coventry never looked like equalising , for all their huff and puff. The defensive shape was very good collectively.
Reply
#14
(03-01-2024, 11:07 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Haha... Those scores are so wide if the mark. And that's before I even lay eyes on the stats tomorrow.

What my eyes see:

Palmer - 6

Furlong - 7
Kipre - 7
Pieters - 7
Townsend - 7

Okay - 7
Mowatt - 8

Fellows - 7
Grady - 8
Johnston - 8

Wallace - 7

Subs:
Reach - 6
Swift - 5
Chalobah - 6
Weimann - 6
Bart's - 6
I tend to agree with Bristol okay and Mowatt with 8 but the reset around 7 except for Furlong who was poor last night 5. On the subs Reach was easily our best sub 7 Swift I thought was poor 5.the rest 6.
Reply
#15
(03-01-2024, 11:02 PM)Bristol Baggie Wrote: Palmer 6

Furlong 4
Kipre 7
Pieters 7
Townsend 5

Johnson 7.5
Mowatt 8
Okay 7
Grady 6
Fellows 6

Wallace 6

Subs

Reach 7
Swift 7
Chabolah 6
Wieman 6
Barts 7

CC 7.5
Think 6 or below is harsh for anyone. 
In truth you beat a half decent Cov side at a canter. After 13 years of watching us home and away in this dump of a league that was a better than good performance and you look a better side month on month I reckon
Reply
#16
(03-02-2024, 09:20 AM)KRO Wrote:
(03-01-2024, 11:02 PM)Bristol Baggie Wrote: Palmer 6

Furlong 4
Kipre 7
Pieters 7
Townsend 5

Johnson 7.5
Mowatt 8
Okay 7
Grady 6
Fellows 6

Wallace 6

Subs

Reach 7
Swift 7
Chabolah 6
Wieman 6
Barts 7

CC 7.5
Think 6 or below is harsh for anyone. 
In truth you beat a half decent Cov side at a canter. After 13 years of watching us home and away in this dump of a league that was a better than good performance and you look a better side month on month I reckon

Well said KRO… Think some people on here expect us to be hammering men forward and peppering opponents’ goals all game to class it as a good performance. Last night we were thoroughly composed and professional. We got an early goal and then played the game we wanted to play until a nervy final 15 after a silly penalty. Any chance they had came from sloppiness or complacency on our part, but in truth an extensively assembled team in very good form were kept at arms length.

Palmer 6.5 - by virtue of having nothing to do, made a couple routine saves.

Furlong 6.5 - couple mistakes and his weakest performance for a while but generally did his job outside of a few daft minutes.
Kipré 6.5 - would be higher but for the penalty challenge. Otherwise solid, but rarely tested.
Pieters 7.5 - still a class act, a couple of delightful throughballs into midfield to set us going - the shirt is his currently, and nice to have a left footer to balance the back line.
Townsend 7 - rare he’s the better of the two fullbacks but supported the attack better today than in recent games. Hopefully not a lengthy injury.

Mowatt 9 - MOTM an absolute class act in the middle, expect to see very high pass numbers and completions and plenty of defensive actions. 
Yokuslu 8.5 - ran Mowatt close and would be MOTM on another day. These two played like a PL midfield against a Championship one last night, they were sublime.

Johnston 8.5 - Why the hell Celtic let him go I’ve no idea, so direct, carries the ball so threateningly, and rarely wastes an outball. 
Grady 7.5 - would have been higher but for a few losses of possession where he’d taken one or two too many touches. Tends to create the pass before the assist, lots of of very good work going often unseen, adapting well to the number 10 role.
Fellows 7 - devastating first half but went quiet after HT, rightly hooked. Lovely assist for GD’s goal

Wallace 7.5 - again lots of running and intelligent movement. For all our misfortune with strikers, Wallace up top creates so much space for the trio behind, and having so much ball carrying and flexibility in positions by playing him up top really seems to bring out the best in the attacking quartet. 

—-

Swift 6 - seems to have lost form at the worst possible time, just as competition returns!
Reach 7 - slotted in well at LB, turned in his usual 7/10 performance.
Chalobah 6 - added a little energy but we lost the total control of the midfield we’d enjoyed with the subs in quick succession.
Weimann 6 - saw out the final 15
Bartley N/A - just good to see him back on the pitch. 

CC 7… Plan A excellent, first half was a joy to watch, rarely felt so untroubled watching a game. Second half the subs nearly handed Coventry something. Understand why he does what he does, but 4 subs in fast succession threw all our rhythm.

Was nice to see us take 3 points with such ease, it felt like we were barely breaking a sweat at times last night which after the exertions of recent games, that’s a big plus. We’ve just come through a 4 week spell  with 7 tricky games in quick succession that included very long away trips to Devon, East Anglia and Humberside with 1 defeat and 14 points, whilst the club went through a takeover. 

Let’s sit back and enjoy the weekend’s matches in comfort knowing we’ve done what we needed to.
Reply
#17
(03-02-2024, 04:10 AM)Jacko Wrote: Palmer was Cov's best player by a distance, seemed to win so many 50/50s and plenty of 40/60's. Furlong in particular struggled with him as did Mowatt when Palmer came central.

Palmer 6 (nothing to do really except pick the pen out of the net)

Furlong 5 (really struggled with Palmer)
Kipre 6 (had a good game but marked down for the rash challenge for the penalty)
Pieters 7 (didn't put a foot wrong)
Townsend 6 (steady performance, caught wrong side of the ball occasionally)

Yokuslu 8 (look what happened when he went off)
Mowatt 7 (standard AM performance without standing out, bought a lot of late freekicks)

Fellows 7 (excellent for the 2nd goal, otherwise anonymous)
Diangana 8 (great goal and constanty fouled though they weren't given, got us moving forward)
Johnston 8 (wonderful goal and a constant threat)

Wallace 7 (ineffective as a centre forward in the traditional sense - scoring; made some superb runs, organised the press and stood up to be counted at the end.

Reach 5 (pretty poor at left back and in midfield)
Chalobah 4 (had an absolute stinker replacing Yok, gave the ball away on numerous occasions)
Swift 6 (looked composed last 15 mins which was needed)
Bartley 6 (Only on for a few minutes but won everything he needed to)
Weimann 5 (not involved in his short stint on the pitch)

Seriously, how does Reach get a 5 and poor? I just don't get it. He came on and didn't put a foot wrong, used the ball wrll and got in some good challenges.

It's like I've watched a completely different game to you.
Reply
#18
(03-02-2024, 07:38 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: Reach - 5 and Swift - 6? This is the beauty of football and how fans see things differently.

I personally thought Reach was great and swift did sod all other than give the ball away!

+1
Reply
#19
Reach 76% pass completion rate, zero tackles.

Swift 80% pass  completion rate, two tackles.

Figures courtesy of whoscored.com and widely available on the Internet.

So don't @ me  Big Grin .
Reply
#20
My own

Palmer 6 - a dropped cross dropped him a mark.

Furlong 6 - poor 15 minutes first half but improved

Townsend 7 - works well with Johnston. Steady game until injury.

Pieters -7 creaked a little 2nd half when they got on top but once again did well.

Kipre - 7 as above

Diangana 7 still not convinced he's a 10 but better last night and smart finish.

Johnston 7 unplayable first 25 mins. Faded a little but love watching him when at his best.

Mowatt - 9 Our heartbeat

Yokuslu -7 brilliant first half, really tired 2nd. Harmed us him going off but need to protect him.

Fellows 6 Quieter but great work for 2nd.

Wallace - 6 never stopped all night without causing too much trouble for them. Not a striker though.

Subs
Reach 7 clearly an important player to Carlos. Could have been a problem with CT going off but came on and did a good solid professional job, again.

Chalobah - 6 prefer him higher up pitch but did ok

Swift 5 Needs to improve. Nowhere near level he was prior to injury.

Wiemann 5 no impact

(03-02-2024, 10:38 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote: Reach 76% pass completion rate, zero tackles.

Swift 80% pass  completion rate, two tackles.

Figures courtesy of whoscored.com and widely available on the Internet.

So don't @ me  Big Grin .

That's absolute rubbish. I can recall at least 3 challenges that he won.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: