02-24-2024, 01:29 PM
For me there’s a few questions here. Was she trafficked (she seemed pretty keen to go to me), was she a danger at the time (yes, she was joining a proscribed organisation when all who travelled were warned of the consequence), is she believably contrite (she seems to be), and should that matter.
The last is the most difficult of all, and given the timing of all of this - polarisation of certain global events lending more than a little additional context to all of this now - I’m not surprised about the outcome; whatever the right or wrong answer is.
From the UK gov perspective, it was a no brainer at first; and was probably seen as a deterrent example. And why not - you can’t reasonably expect to go around saying you hate the UK, support atrocities in the UK, fuck off to join a bunch of radical animals in the desert and then say you want to come back to the UK when you discover that you don’t like the other side much either. But now, that situation has changed, and given the tone of the condemnation of Hamas all nations are somewhat compelled to adopt it would send out a very weak signal to simply repatriate her; punitively or not. It would show-up the UK as a very soft touch, during times all Western nations are preaching the need to be internationally resolute.
All in all, from a humanitarian point of view I don’t know if it’s right or wrong to leave her stateless. I’m glad it isn’t my decision. What I do know is that she has no-one else to blame but herself.
But above all, it would be nice to live in a country where the threat of radicalisation was never an issue in the first place. But I guess that’s the sticky thing about illegal wars.
The last is the most difficult of all, and given the timing of all of this - polarisation of certain global events lending more than a little additional context to all of this now - I’m not surprised about the outcome; whatever the right or wrong answer is.
From the UK gov perspective, it was a no brainer at first; and was probably seen as a deterrent example. And why not - you can’t reasonably expect to go around saying you hate the UK, support atrocities in the UK, fuck off to join a bunch of radical animals in the desert and then say you want to come back to the UK when you discover that you don’t like the other side much either. But now, that situation has changed, and given the tone of the condemnation of Hamas all nations are somewhat compelled to adopt it would send out a very weak signal to simply repatriate her; punitively or not. It would show-up the UK as a very soft touch, during times all Western nations are preaching the need to be internationally resolute.
All in all, from a humanitarian point of view I don’t know if it’s right or wrong to leave her stateless. I’m glad it isn’t my decision. What I do know is that she has no-one else to blame but herself.
But above all, it would be nice to live in a country where the threat of radicalisation was never an issue in the first place. But I guess that’s the sticky thing about illegal wars.


