Shamima begum
#21
(02-24-2024, 02:11 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote:
(02-23-2024, 08:56 PM)Ada Wrote: She was British, and we should have dealt with her in the UK. Stripping her of her citizenship wasn’t the right thing to do, she was trafficked, and leaving her in limbo still isn’t the right thing to do. It says something about our values, whether lawful or not.

Couple of things to correct here. She and her two mates were not trafficked, they found their own way to ISIS. She's not in limbo, Bangladesh just can't be arsed to deal with her. Our values (via the Security Services, Courts and Government) have quite good and intelligence related reasons to believe She is a terrorist threat and national security threat. On these grounds, stripping her of her citizenship is 100% the right thing to do.

She had till she was 21 to apply for Bangladesh citizenship. She didn't and gambled on being allowed back to the UK. Not a case of Bangladesh not being arsed. Her choice.
Reply
#22
(02-24-2024, 07:52 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(02-24-2024, 06:30 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Is it me, or has she got better with age?

What at making bombs

Loffin  Big Grin

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#23
(02-24-2024, 12:03 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-23-2024, 08:59 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(02-23-2024, 08:56 PM)Ada Wrote: She was British, and we should have dealt with her in the UK. Stripping her of her citizenship wasn’t the right thing to do, she was trafficked, and leaving her in limbo still isn’t the right thing to do. It says something about our values, whether lawful or not.

I thought she had dual Brit / Pakistani? Why aren't they getting grief for not taking her back? She's a terrorist sympathiser and deserves nothing as far as I am concerned. She'd have happily celebrated the deaths of regular people going to and from work. Fuck her and everyone like her.

We say was eligible for Bangladeshi citizenship so they should deal with it, Bangladesh says she's not a citizen so we should deal with it. So she's functionally stateless as neither we nor Bangladesh want to deal with her and both say she's not a citizen of either territory.
She's never been to Bangladesh either.
Reply
#24
I disagree that we should have taken away her citizenship and made her stateless. Claiming she was eligible for another state’s citizenship, one where she had never lived and apparently never visited, just feels like us passing the buck. Similarly, leaving her to rot at the expense of another nation/organisation with far fewer resources than us stinks of us wanting to wash our hands of a problem and appease a segment of the electorate.

She was born, raised and radicalised in this country. Procedures in this country failed to prevent her from travelling to join ISIS and as such she should be our problem. Allowing a country to remove someone’s citizenship because they don’t want to deal with their crimes is a dangerous precedent to set, I’m not sure we’d be supportive of say Rwanda taking away the citizenship of people accused of participating in genocide who happened to be in U.K. prisons for example.

She should be brought back to the U.K, should be tried for her crimes and punished appropriately here. If she is a terror suspect, or deemed a danger to society, we have the means to ensure she is kept in solitary isolation for the rest of her life.

There is absolutely no way she should ever be allowed to return to her old life, to be allowed to just resettle into British society, but to leave her as the responsibility of another state is not right IMO.
Reply
#25
She got exactly the life she wanted - Good luck and goodbye
Reply
#26
Wonder what will happen to the Britons going to join the IDF. Hopefully they are locked up on return to Britain, to protect the public and/or have their citizenship revoked.
Reply
#27
(02-24-2024, 10:17 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I disagree that we should have taken away her citizenship and made her stateless. Claiming she was eligible for another state’s citizenship, one where she had never lived and apparently never visited, just feels like us passing the buck. Similarly, leaving her to rot at the expense of another nation/organisation with far fewer resources than us stinks of us wanting to wash our hands of a problem and appease a segment of the electorate.

She was born, raised and radicalised in this country. Procedures in this country failed to prevent her from travelling to join ISIS and as such she should be our problem. Allowing a country to remove someone’s citizenship because they don’t want to deal with their crimes is a dangerous precedent to set, I’m not sure we’d be supportive of say Rwanda taking away the citizenship of people accused of participating in genocide who happened to be in U.K. prisons for example.

She should be brought back to the U.K, should be tried for her crimes and punished appropriately here. If she is a terror suspect, or deemed a danger to society, we have the means to ensure she is kept in solitary isolation for the rest of her life.

There is absolutely no way she should ever be allowed to return to her old life, to be allowed to just resettle into British society, but to leave her as the responsibility of another state is not right IMO.

All of this. What the government can do to Person X today, they can do to Person Y tomorrow and it might be for considerably less compelling reasons.

In addition to that, enabling anyone who has the right to another nationality to have their citizenship removed creates a two tier system for nationality. By sheer accident of birth, some people will receive a more serious punishment than others, which doesn't fit the ethos of British justice, where all people should be equal before the law.
Reply
#28
(02-24-2024, 10:26 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Wonder what will happen to the Britons going to join the IDF. Hopefully they are locked up on return to Britain, to protect the public and/or have their citizenship revoked.

Your only punished if you join the wrong side.
Reply
#29
(02-24-2024, 10:17 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I disagree that we should have taken away her citizenship and made her stateless. Claiming she was eligible for another state’s citizenship, one where she had never lived and apparently never visited, just feels like us passing the buck. Similarly, leaving her to rot at the expense of another nation/organisation with far fewer resources than us stinks of us wanting to wash our hands of a problem and appease a segment of the electorate.

She was born, raised and radicalised in this country. Procedures in this country failed to prevent her from travelling to join ISIS and as such she should be our problem. Allowing a country to remove someone’s citizenship because they don’t want to deal with their crimes is a dangerous precedent to set, I’m not sure we’d be supportive of say Rwanda taking away the citizenship of people accused of participating in genocide who happened to be in U.K. prisons for example.

She should be brought back to the U.K, should be tried for her crimes and punished appropriately here. If she is a terror suspect, or deemed a danger to society, we have the means to ensure she is kept in solitary isolation for the rest of her life.

There is absolutely no way she should ever be allowed to return to her old life, to be allowed to just resettle into British society, but to leave her as the responsibility of another state is not right IMO.

Great post.
Reply
#30
What a weird thing to start a topic on on a football forum
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)