Action 4 Albion
#41
(02-19-2024, 06:51 AM)Johnny akes Wrote: Whether A4A achieved anything tangible or not, they became the public face of the fans’ disenchantment of what was going on. Without them, the fan base as a whole would have appeared to the outside world as uninterested and uncaring about the future of the club and, just maybe, not worth saving or investing in.

I would suggest that being the public face is tangible.  With no public face there was nothing to report.  No interviews from the club, nothing from the owners, it would have been relegated to a few column inches or a mention in the news.  Instead the media had someone to interview and actions to report on and it kept a light shinging on the issue (no pun intended)
Reply
#42
You're all missing the big thing here. A4A achieved all this without a single fatality.
Reply
#43
(02-19-2024, 09:13 AM)MrFizz Wrote: You're all missing the big thing here. A4A achieved all this without a single fatality.

You know what. You're right. 

The A4A Team are invincible.
Reply
#44
(02-19-2024, 09:13 AM)MrFizz Wrote: You're all missing the big thing here. A4A achieved all this without a single fatality.

Big Grin 

I see KKC is currently banned on here.  Not sure if that’s temporary nor if it was for his own personal safety due to the sudden influx of posters on here, following the sudden and unexpected announcement of the takeover.
Reply
#45
I missed that occurrence. What happened? Desecrating the memorials of those that fell?
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#46
(02-19-2024, 09:42 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: I missed that occurrence. What happened? Desecrating the memorials of those that fell?

He had a fight with a pigeon and lost. 

https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/showthread....#pid651439
Reply
#47
(02-19-2024, 08:16 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(02-19-2024, 06:51 AM)Johnny akes Wrote: Whether A4A achieved anything tangible or not, they became the public face of the fans’ disenchantment of what was going on. Without them, the fan base as a whole would have appeared to the outside world as uninterested and uncaring about the future of the club and, just maybe, not worth saving or investing in.

Well worded that mate. I got involved because of how desperate the apathy in the stadium and fanbase was starting to feel. To me it was a case of either give up or do something and it was probably having my 13 year old lad sat next to me that spurred the latter rather than the former.

Agree with TTM, it’s quite baffling to hear some of the stuff that gets said or more so the intent of where it stems from, although it didn’t surprise me I guess. Football fans are a funny old breed and we saw plenty of that from our own lot on many occasions.

Whether or not Burley is right that it ultimately made no difference is right we will never know, and I accepted that early on in the process. But to say that just because Kieran Maguire made the occasional tweet before that that we already had coverage is laughable compared to the level to which the profile was truly raised and makes it difficult to take much else he says seriously

We can give praise to A4A my point is they made no material difference to the direction the club was going in both in finance and ownership. My point in Kieran Maguire was that the people were already highlighting our plight and while A4A deserve some credit for maintaining that spotlight it really did not change the course of events. 

I severely disagree with other points made that it did not affect match days. It did. I was there. The lack of objectivity continues to baffle me. Bury, Derby, Bolton, Reading all had or have similar action groups, how is that going? The financial realities will always usurp good natured intervention, the point Id reflect on is whether we’d be so praising if we’d gone into Admin? As ultimately it wasn’t A4A that prevented this. 

Each to their own opinion on this, I respect those shining a light on A4A work and commitment. It is not how I would have handled it and at times made us look amateur in my opinion, but if people wish to praise them that is their right. Equally Inhave a right to dissent and disagree. It’s not jealously or chirlishness, it’s my objective view of the facts as I see them.
Reply
#48
As an example BB (and thanks for your reply) - it was A4A who ultimately got Nicola Richards and Andy Street involved. People who Patel has already met more than once and whom for someone who is very keen on investing in local infrastructure, would have undoubtedly added to the appeal that he had access to those kind of people from an early juncture
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#49
(02-19-2024, 10:02 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: As an example BB (and thanks for your reply) - it was A4A who ultimately got Nicola Richards and Andy Street involved. People who Patel has already met more than once and whom for someone who is very keen on investing in local infrastructure, would have undoubtedly added to the appeal that he had access to those kind of people from an early juncture

Ali also got in to No. 10

"Mrs. Sunak" has a bob or two and is well connected...

Anyway, aside from everything else, Ali received a shed load of abuse and threats. Threats! What is wrong with some people?

A weaker-willed person would have walked away from it all but he stuck with it and deserves, as he is generally getting, enormous credit for raising the profile of our plight, and indeed that of other Clubs.

In particular, the protest march down the Brummie Road was incredible.

If A4A and their activity improves the governance of our game and keeps a few charlatans away then that is yet another thing to be proud of being a Baggie.
Reply
#50
(02-19-2024, 10:02 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: As an example BB (and thanks for your reply) - it was A4A who ultimately got Nicola Richards and Andy Street involved. People who Patel has already met more than once and whom for someone who is very keen on investing in local infrastructure, would have undoubtedly added to the appeal that he had access to those kind of people from an early juncture

That’s not strictly true, S4A got Les Trumpeter involved regarding the Hawthorns becoming a community asset. As that was progressing Andy Street reached out and asked for a meeting with S4A and A4A. However, I think you might find A4A were in the gravity of the ask not the reason and cynically (I met Andy in government) was a very good publicity move for him. 

This is my continued point though, A4A did honest work they thought progressed the cause, I get that, I don’t necessarily think it was helpful at times

However, many many people across the Albion spectrum and beyond worked so hard on the takeover that deserve so much credit, while A4A seem to get the praise. They were at best, for my quite detailed and in room knowledge at best, in the peripheral.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)