02-18-2024, 10:35 PM
|
Action 4 Albion
|
|
02-18-2024, 11:13 PM
(02-18-2024, 10:35 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:(02-18-2024, 09:46 PM)Squid Wrote: A4A have done an excellent job and really helped move things forward and not just for the Albion either. It seems very poor form to disparage their efforts. I also have no issue with an independent supporters club. Seconded
02-18-2024, 11:14 PM
(02-18-2024, 11:13 PM)1952 Wrote:(02-18-2024, 10:35 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:(02-18-2024, 09:46 PM)Squid Wrote: A4A have done an excellent job and really helped move things forward and not just for the Albion either. It seems very poor form to disparage their efforts. I also have no issue with an independent supporters club. Thirded !
02-19-2024, 02:35 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-19-2024, 02:35 AM by BurleyBaggie.)
There some absolute nonsense on here. The work of A4A is hugely being overplayed and the financial reality (as Prag and FF have stated) are being hugely underplayed.
In answer to questions on what if have done, I would have stayed clear from any action whatsoever that impacted match days. In fact I’d have left it up to S4A and the financial diligence they were already doing - which was more powerful and more impactful than anything a wider supporters group could do. And yes I’m aware of the linkage as I’m actually involved not that I need to state that. Also, the financial reality was driving the pressure in two ways; media interest already existed after our financial accounts were published, just look at what Kieran Maguire was writing, more importantly our cash flow was such a sale was absolutely inevitable. A4A didn’t expedite this, maybe not even S4A, the reality was Lai and colleagues got something or nothing. I’ve written extensively on this previously, Gourlay taking the MSD loan on the way he did with the securities he did tied the club to one of two outcomes that had to resolve itself by this summer: sale or administration. I genuinely think Gourlay deserved far more credit than he gets regarding this and actually expedited the sale more than any light shining could have done. The structure of the loan gave MSD a king making position and meant Lai et al couldn’t take further money out and were at serious risk of losing all their investment. However, yes we can forget all the other facts and focus on A4A success. (02-19-2024, 02:35 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: There some absolute nonsense on here. The work of A4A is hugely being overplayed and the financial reality (as Prag and FF have stated) are being hugely underplayed. I refer you to my original reply, which I can only assume you’ve not read. No actions have “impacted match days” negatively whatsoever and that’s something A4A have had barrel loads of abuse for, including threats of violence, because of the commitment to peaceful and non violent protest. I’ll be honest, the constant references to “light shining” is really old and lazy now, it was only a week or so ago two representatives from the committee met with the EFL ffs - it’s been explained time and time again that it was a multi stranded approach. “Shining a light” was exactly what it said on the tin, no idea why people feel it’s something to take the piss out of - loads of people don’t use social media etc, they needed to be reached The people you mention - Kieran Maguire and especially S4A - have a good relationship with A4A. History will judge Gourlay very kindly - he put the plug in the bath before departing and without that it could’ve been so much worse. As I’ve already said, nobody at A4A has tried to take credit for anything, everyone is just happy the Lai era is over, as we all are. Not sure why there’s any need for the aggression and mean spirited nastiness towards a group of genuine Albion fans who just wanted to try and help. It’s really depressing to read. Nobody will ever know if A4A’s work has any influence over the end result, and nobody within it has tried to claim so, but if it’s made even the smallest contribution, even minuscule, then I know for a fact each member would do it all over again. The club we all love has got new owners who look on first scan to be good people. What’s not to like? No negatives here at all.
02-19-2024, 06:19 AM
A4A has done a "GREAT JOB' take bow boys and girls.
02-19-2024, 06:46 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-19-2024, 06:47 AM by Woodman scoreboard.)
The likes of TTM are good eggs who have put the AFA before their own family at times I know that for a fact .....do I agree what they done all the times absolutely no alot of us wanted an immediate impact and a few wanted disruption as tennis balls on the pitch .....but they have done the job what required are different times . Yes they was privileged to get to know what was going on behind the scenes and that's where lines are blurred with some people and they don't like it .
Well done to all involved time to put your feet up and enjoy family life and hopefully watch wba bloom under the new regime
02-19-2024, 06:51 AM
Whether A4A achieved anything tangible or not, they became the public face of the fans’ disenchantment of what was going on. Without them, the fan base as a whole would have appeared to the outside world as uninterested and uncaring about the future of the club and, just maybe, not worth saving or investing in.
02-19-2024, 07:38 AM
(02-19-2024, 06:51 AM)Johnny akes Wrote: Whether A4A achieved anything tangible or not, they became the public face of the fans’ disenchantment of what was going on. Without them, the fan base as a whole would have appeared to the outside world as uninterested and uncaring about the future of the club and, just maybe, not worth saving or investing in. Exactly. Even within the wider world of football, they became a face of fans having their club ground into the dust and helped to put the issue on the national agenda. This isn't just about the Albion for me. No fan should have to sit and watch their club go pop at the hands of unscrupulous/inept owners. There should be much, much tighter regulation Hopefully this will finally happen and A4A have been at the vanguard of that.
02-19-2024, 08:16 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-19-2024, 08:19 AM by CaptainFantastico.)
(02-19-2024, 06:51 AM)Johnny akes Wrote: Whether A4A achieved anything tangible or not, they became the public face of the fans’ disenchantment of what was going on. Without them, the fan base as a whole would have appeared to the outside world as uninterested and uncaring about the future of the club and, just maybe, not worth saving or investing in. Well worded that mate. I got involved because of how desperate the apathy in the stadium and fanbase was starting to feel. To me it was a case of either give up or do something and it was probably having my 13 year old lad sat next to me that spurred the latter rather than the former. Agree with TTM, it’s quite baffling to hear some of the stuff that gets said or more so the intent of where it stems from, although it didn’t surprise me I guess. Football fans are a funny old breed and we saw plenty of that from our own lot on many occasions. Whether or not Burley is right that it ultimately made no difference is right we will never know, and I accepted that early on in the process. But to say that just because Kieran Maguire made the occasional tweet before that that we already had coverage is laughable compared to the level to which the profile was truly raised and makes it difficult to take much else he says seriously
Someone could have been killed
|
|
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|
Users browsing this thread:


