WBA official takeover
(02-17-2024, 10:28 AM)wba8 Wrote: Wonder who owns the other 12.2%, new owner has 87.8%.
He may wish to get to 90% and then a full takeover.
Gives him more options perhaps re handling debts.

The minority shareholders Big Grin  represented by S4A

(02-17-2024, 10:32 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(02-16-2024, 06:55 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I did think it was a bit unfair on Hearn, who is disliked by some on here mainly because he's sockless and a Villa fan.  He might be some average bloke, with a family, who's lost his life savings, through dealing with a Chinese charlatan - and we all know how that feels.

But then I remember he's a sockless Villa cunt.
Fuck him. I take great delight in the fact the slimey villa twat is going to be chasing Lai for money for months to come. The charmless, smug chancer.




5% per month default interest rate!!  Arf.  

Lai should give him the security taken against the loan and send him a share certificate for West Bromwich Holdings Limited.  At least Hearn would then have something for his £2m.  A piece of A4 worth nowt, with no rights to stop Lai transferring all the cash to China.
Reply
(02-17-2024, 10:28 AM)wba8 Wrote: Wonder who owns the other 12.2%, new owner has 87.8%.
He may wish to get to 90% and then a full takeover.
Gives him more options perhaps re handling debts.

The other 12.2% is owned by hundreds of individuals

(02-17-2024, 10:39 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(02-17-2024, 10:28 AM)wba8 Wrote: Wonder who owns the other 12.2%, new owner has 87.8%.
He may wish to get to 90% and then a full takeover.
Gives him more options perhaps re handling debts.

The minority shareholders Big Grin  represented by S4A

(02-17-2024, 10:32 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(02-16-2024, 06:55 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I did think it was a bit unfair on Hearn, who is disliked by some on here mainly because he's sockless and a Villa fan.  He might be some average bloke, with a family, who's lost his life savings, through dealing with a Chinese charlatan - and we all know how that feels.

But then I remember he's a sockless Villa cunt.
Fuck him. I take great delight in the fact the slimey villa twat is going to be chasing Lai for money for months to come. The charmless, smug chancer.




5% per month default interest rate!!  Arf.  

Lai should give him the security taken against the loan and send him a share certificate for West Bromwich Holdings Limited.  At least Hearn would then have something for his £2m.  A piece of A4 worth nowt, with no rights to stop Lai transferring all the cash to China.

Not correct, at least not legally.  Holdings would have to settle its obligations before distributing to shareholders.

(02-17-2024, 10:28 AM)wba8 Wrote: Wonder who owns the other 12.2%, new owner has 87.8%.
He may wish to get to 90% and then a full takeover.
Gives him more options perhaps re handling debts.

The other 12.2% is owned by hundreds of individuals
Reply
(02-17-2024, 11:04 AM)wba8 Wrote: ^^^^
New owner may wish to approach them with a view to buying their shares, if he gets to 90% can buy remaining shares.
Would perhaps enable him to do a share issue to repay the debts and consolidate into the club equity. Would be the £20m paid for 82.8%, whatever paid for the remaining 12.2%, plus the debts £40m.

Why pay more when he already has control over the company?

As an investor, Patel will want to grow the club and sell his shares when we’re established in the Premier league.  

Sadly, the minority shareholders have shares which are difficult to sell which don’t have a dividend income stream either.
Reply
(02-17-2024, 11:04 AM)wba8 Wrote: ^^^^
New owner may wish to approach them with a view to buying their shares, if he gets to 90% can buy remaining shares.
Would perhaps enable him to do a share issue to repay the debts and consolidate into the club equity. Would be the £20m paid for 87.8%, whatever paid for the remaining 12.2%, plus the debts £40m.

If the club was valued at £60m, then 12.2% pro-rats is around £7.3m.  Could arguably discount for a minority stake, but maybe not to persuade sellers. 

But some probably wouldn’t sell and if there’s even one minority shareholder then there’s always minority shareholders’ rights to have to consider.
Reply
(02-17-2024, 11:11 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(02-17-2024, 11:04 AM)wba8 Wrote: ^^^^
New owner may wish to approach them with a view to buying their shares, if he gets to 90% can buy remaining shares.
Would perhaps enable him to do a share issue to repay the debts and consolidate into the club equity. Would be the £20m paid for 82.8%, whatever paid for the remaining 12.2%, plus the debts £40m.

Why pay more when he already has control over the company?

As an investor, Patel will want to grow the club and sell his shares when we’re established in the Premier league.  

Sadly, the minority shareholders have shares which are difficult to sell which don’t have a dividend income stream either.

Minority shareholders have rights which cannot be ridden roughshod over, as Lai found out.  The existence of those minority shareholders’ rights prevented further raping of the club once the minority shareholders found out what he had already done.  It quite possibly saved the club from a far worse fate.
Reply
I think there should be always be fans who have shares and a place around the top table who have business sense to see how the club is developing from the fans point of view and not just giving us lip service.
Reply
(02-17-2024, 11:17 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(02-17-2024, 11:11 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(02-17-2024, 11:04 AM)wba8 Wrote: ^^^^
New owner may wish to approach them with a view to buying their shares, if he gets to 90% can buy remaining shares.
Would perhaps enable him to do a share issue to repay the debts and consolidate into the club equity. Would be the £20m paid for 82.8%, whatever paid for the remaining 12.2%, plus the debts £40m.

Why pay more when he already has control over the company?

As an investor, Patel will want to grow the club and sell his shares when we’re established in the Premier league.  

Sadly, the minority shareholders have shares which are difficult to sell which don’t have a dividend income stream either.

Minority shareholders have rights which cannot be ridden roughshod over, as Lai found out.  The existence of those minority shareholders’ rights prevented further raping of the club once the minority shareholders found out what he had already done.  It quite possibly saved the club from a far worse fate.
This. We’ve much to thank those minority shareholders for, and I for one would prefer them to remain in place just in case the Patel regime doesn’t measure up to our hopes and expectations in the future.
Reply
(02-17-2024, 11:23 AM)wba8 Wrote:
(02-17-2024, 11:17 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(02-17-2024, 11:11 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(02-17-2024, 11:04 AM)wba8 Wrote: ^^^^
New owner may wish to approach them with a view to buying their shares, if he gets to 90% can buy remaining shares.
Would perhaps enable him to do a share issue to repay the debts and consolidate into the club equity. Would be the £20m paid for 82.8%, whatever paid for the remaining 12.2%, plus the debts £40m.

Why pay more when he already has control over the company?

As an investor, Patel will want to grow the club and sell his shares when we’re established in the Premier league.  

Sadly, the minority shareholders have shares which are difficult to sell which don’t have a dividend income stream either.

Minority shareholders have rights which cannot be ridden roughshod over, as Lai found out.  The existence of those minority shareholders’ rights prevented further raping of the club once the minority shareholders found out what he had already done.  It quite possibly saved the club from a far worse fate.

Good point.
Leaves question to explore of how to deal with debt £40m. Could be left on balance sheet until repaid. Or new owner could repay earlier, eg now, but may want a share issue to do so, underwritten by him. But if approved would take him over the 90% which would enable him to buy out the minority investors. Perhaps he might agree not to exercise that right.
Next few weeks/months we'll see.

I understand that the MSD is being repaid in full. That’s why the net cash to seller is £20m, not £60m.
Reply
(02-17-2024, 01:06 PM)wba8 Wrote:
(02-17-2024, 11:30 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(02-17-2024, 11:23 AM)wba8 Wrote:
(02-17-2024, 11:17 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(02-17-2024, 11:11 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: Why pay more when he already has control over the company?

As an investor, Patel will want to grow the club and sell his shares when we’re established in the Premier league.  

Sadly, the minority shareholders have shares which are difficult to sell which don’t have a dividend income stream either.

Minority shareholders have rights which cannot be ridden roughshod over, as Lai found out.  The existence of those minority shareholders’ rights prevented further raping of the club once the minority shareholders found out what he had already done.  It quite possibly saved the club from a far worse fate.

Good point.
Leaves question to explore of how to deal with debt £40m. Could be left on balance sheet until repaid. Or new owner could repay earlier, eg now, but may want a share issue to do so, underwritten by him. But if approved would take him over the 90% which would enable him to buy out the minority investors. Perhaps he might agree not to exercise that right.
Next few weeks/months we'll see.

I understand that the MSD is being repaid in full. That’s why the net cash to seller is £20m, not £60m.

Yes.
Suppose my point is shares worth £20m for 87.8% with 12.2% held by others.
But debt £40m far bigger than share valuation. So if debt repaid by new owner does it sit as debt to him on the balance sheet or does he try and convert into shares, that would hugely dilute the proportion held by the minority shareholders. 
A puzzle which should be clarified in due course.

Yes that’s a very good point.  It’s only worth £60m if the debt disappears, so how that’s technically achieved is important.   Keeping the debt on the balance sheet only makes sense if it’s interest-free debt.
Reply
(02-17-2024, 11:19 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: I think there should be always be fans who have shares and a place around the top table who have business sense to see how the club is developing from the fans point of view and not just giving us lip service.

Amen to this. we all owe those minority shareholders a drink after blowing the whistle on Lai's shenanigans.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)