Saints match fred
Think we are slightly over egging Southampton.

They were outstanding for the first 30 mins, but then not good for the next 30 mins,then managed the last 30 mins well.

That spell for us either side of half time should have seen a goal for us, irrespective of the penalty decision. But we failed to take advantage of the period of the game when we were in the ascendancy.

On the subs, they clearly didn't help. But difficult to criticise without knowing if they were tactical or needed to give players a rest to protect from burn out and/or injury.
Reply
(02-17-2024, 08:01 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(02-17-2024, 02:02 AM)Squid Wrote:
(02-17-2024, 12:01 AM)Lightnin Wrote: Southampton were good, I’d say the best footballing side we’ve seen this season but my god it helps when you’ve got an extra bloke on your team. Shocking ref, absolutely shocking.

He really got quite a lot of things wrong tonight, pretty much up there with Blues away, but I think the feeling of anti-climax from the match performance has overshadowed that. We should have had a penalty. Had we put that away, the match may well have been different.

I couldn't see how it was a corner for the first goal, not at all obvious which of our players was supposed to get a touch. Furlong was fouled off the ball, definitely a push, not just "holding his ground". The handball was nailed on, it hit his leading arm, but he had his other hand raised to block it if necessary. By this stage the ref was letting the Southampton playere referee the match.

Did the ball go off before CC touched it? He knows the rules so it's hard to imagine otherwise. So where was the lino's flag? And did Russell Martin have to join in to get Carlos sent off?

A thoroughly atrocious performance by the officials.

Truely dreadful officiating all round.

The ref was so bad he will no doubt be in the Prem next year!

The Lino missed the ball being out and then and the handball which should have been clear from his view on the Halfords touch line.

Agree about Martin.
Reply
(02-17-2024, 08:37 AM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(02-17-2024, 08:01 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(02-17-2024, 02:02 AM)Squid Wrote:
(02-17-2024, 12:01 AM)Lightnin Wrote: Southampton were good, I’d say the best footballing side we’ve seen this season but my god it helps when you’ve got an extra bloke on your team. Shocking ref, absolutely shocking.

He really got quite a lot of things wrong tonight, pretty much up there with Blues away, but I think the feeling of anti-climax from the match performance has overshadowed that. We should have had a penalty. Had we put that away, the match may well have been different.

I couldn't see how it was a corner for the first goal, not at all obvious which of our players was supposed to get a touch. Furlong was fouled off the ball, definitely a push, not just "holding his ground". The handball was nailed on, it hit his leading arm, but he had his other hand raised to block it if necessary. By this stage the ref was letting the Southampton playere referee the match.

Did the ball go off before CC touched it? He knows the rules so it's hard to imagine otherwise. So where was the lino's flag? And did Russell Martin have to join in to get Carlos sent off?

A thoroughly atrocious performance by the officials.

Truely dreadful officiating all round.

The ref was so bad he will no doubt be in the Prem next year!

The Lino missed the ball being out and then and the handball which should have been clear from his view on the Halfords touch line.

Agree about Martin.

Whether the ball fully went out or not, it’s the same as “play to the whistle”.  The lino thought not, and that’s what counts, so the ball was still “live”.  A simple human error by CC, but an expensive one. 

I can sort of understand that the ref’s angle might have obscured the handball, but how on earth did the lino not see it?  He’d have had a perfect view.  That was the worst decision of all.
Reply
Re. The Carlos incident, where i sit i'm right in line with the touchline, and the ball didn't go out as far as i could tell. Close, but not out.
Reply
(02-17-2024, 08:07 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Think we are slightly over egging Southampton.

They were outstanding for the first 30 mins, but then not good for the next 30 mins,then managed the last 30 mins well.

That spell for us either side of half time should have seen a goal for us, irrespective of the penalty decision. But we failed to take advantage of the period of the game when we were in the ascendancy.

On the subs, they clearly didn't help. But difficult to criticise without knowing if they were tactical or needed to give players a rest to protect from burn out and/or injury.

I think the praise of the saints is fair. They manage the ball really well and we didn't really have an answer for 25 mins and could have been dead and buried. 

Credit to us for working them out and having a really good 30 mins as has also been said. But regarding the subs. Even if the likes of Johnston and Swift had to come off as they both had started the previous game. Grady and Pipa would have been the better choices as we were on top and they were deep and we needed technical ball players who can operate in right areas. 

Taking Wallace off was madness. He was fresh and playing really well up top at the time. 

Not one to remember for CC and his staff generally.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(02-16-2024, 10:01 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: You have to question if the subs are predefined. If the oppo scores first, we don’t win.
I wholeheartedly agree that the subs cost us any chance of getting anything from the game, albeit they managed to repel everything including that brilliant save and they had a 12th man too of course.

However, Mikey was definitely flagging, Swift was anonymous and I feel like Jed is playing through an injury. Since the Dingles game I have felt he has been poorer defensively tracking back and he was rested in midweek. And he did put in a mammoth effort v Ipswich.

So what would we have done?! I really like Chalobah as a no 10 but he would hardly be an attacking replacement. Weimann was ill or injured. I can’t see any alternatives. Pipa on the right wing and Tom on the left?

I truly think Pipa or Ajayi couldn’t have added less than Marshall. He looks so far off it it is unbelievable. My West Ham colleague keeps asking how he is doing and then saying he just needs time. I think he needs a league two loan first to be honest. I don’t recall Cleary looking this raw?
Reply
On the ref, I think people are being over critical.

Bit of a jobsworth on the red card, but technically correct.

Think it was a corner for the goal. Although I did wonder if Smallbone made an illegal block to stop a defender closing down the player who provided the cross.

Penalty almost impossible to give for the ref. One of the few incidents where var would be helpful.
Reply
The match was much more about the bigger takeover picture.

However, some very disappointing performances out there and, as mentioned, the subs added little.
I really don’t know what ‘handball’ is in football anymore after that and seeing much less given against us over the past few years ?
The referring was dire with his early zealot card waving against us and always giving them the benefit of corners and blocks/offsides which also led to the first goal. It was clear it wasn’t going to be our day.

The real concern on the pitch is the next three games that follow where I think we might struggle get even a single win and will see us swamped by the cluster of clubs below us. A couple of clubs could even put a mini run together and open a gap on us by the end of the Coventry weekend unless we can sort our dire away form out and start winning on our travels. Far too much pressure to win the home games at present.
Reply
Looking at the bigger picture here when Carlos got sent off we went rudderless in our leadership on the field ..nobody taking responsibility what was going on that's the most worrying thing about last night.
Reply
(02-17-2024, 08:07 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Think we are slightly over egging Southampton.

They were outstanding for the first 30 mins, but then not good for the next 30 mins,then managed the last 30 mins well.

That spell for us either side of half time should have seen a goal for us, irrespective of the penalty decision. But we failed to take advantage of the period of the game when we were in the ascendancy.

On the subs, they clearly didn't help. But difficult to criticise without knowing if they were tactical or needed to give players a rest to protect from burn out and/or injury.
How I saw it too. The difference was that we don't have a striker. That's all.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: