That Townsend cross
#61
Furlong iMO is a top end Champ full back, which is where we are as a club and has had a decent season. It might be the introduction of Pipa to the squad and that competition for places has given him a push. There’s also the CC effect as well as the team as a whole defending well.

Townsend has always been up against it in the fans eyes, we had Gibbs and we signed him from Scunthorpe as a L1 player. Townsend looked a bit raw by comparison and was seen as the understudy, I don’t think that’s ever helped him cement a positive view. He’s ok at this level, gets done at the far post too often for my liking and both the Leicester and the Wolves goal against us showed poor decision making. But players make mistakes, otherwise they wouldn’t be playing for West Brom. We certainly at least need competition for the position, Reach isn’t really that, and would be a position I’d be looking to strengthen if no one else was leaving in the summer. We’ll clearly have to look at CB options and CM with Mowatt and Chalobah both out of contract.

As for whoever said we’ve never had shit full backs. I’ll name a few…

Neil Parsley, Andy McDermott, Agnew, Paul Edwards, Tininho and Udeze. I reckon I’ve been kind to a few who I haven’t named too. There’s one particular one that might make Cuzer melt!
By shit, I mean relative to our team position and squad. They’re all better than me! I was trying to wrack my brains to late 80s/early 90s for some dross we had. Potter wasn’t great, I quite like Hodson and although Albiston wasn’t great for us he’d had a good career.

In recent years I’d say Townsend is below, Gibbs, Clement, Ridgewell and the badge kisser and that’s who is being compared to. Yet furlong stands against Jones, Bališ, Lyttle and Hoefkens as an equal.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#62
I think Ridgewell was the most maligned of all our fullbacks, especially considering he was nowhere as bad as many (both on here and in the ground) wanted him to be.
Reply
#63
CT just makes the same mistakes time and time again that's the frustration.
Reply
#64
(02-15-2024, 09:36 AM)Duffers Wrote: I think Ridgewell was the most maligned of all our fullbacks, especially considering he was nowhere as bad as many (both on here and in the ground) wanted him to be.

Signed as a centre half and got pushed to left back, if I recall? He played poor at centre half but did a decent job at left back. I thought he was a good player for us. 

Memory may be hazy and that may be bollocks.
Reply
#65
(02-14-2024, 08:17 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(02-14-2024, 08:15 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The age old WBAunoffficial pick on the fullback thread, it’s up there with Don Goodman has said something mildly critical of the club threads.

I have a season ticket for both threads ( in between finding out what Fulham Fallout is cooking for tea).

Peasants have tea, be told Big Grin
Reply
#66
(02-15-2024, 10:05 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(02-15-2024, 09:36 AM)Duffers Wrote: I think Ridgewell was the most maligned of all our fullbacks, especially considering he was nowhere as bad as many (both on here and in the ground) wanted him to be.

Signed as a centre half and got pushed to left back, if I recall? He played poor at centre half but did a decent job at left back. I thought he was a good player for us. 

Memory may be hazy and that may be bollocks.

Think he was already playing LB for Blues when we signed him. He was primarily bought as a LB who could fill in at CB when needed.

Very much a typical Roy-era signing - solid, unspectacular, wasn't too invested in crossing the halfway line... He was doomed from the start due to his Villa connections and the growing desire at the time for sexier signings.
Reply
#67
(02-15-2024, 09:36 AM)Duffers Wrote: I think Ridgewell was the most maligned of all our fullbacks, especially considering he was nowhere as bad as many (both on here and in the ground) wanted him to be.

Being an ex seal prick, & wiping his arse on £20 notes may have had summat to do with it.    Big Grin
Reply
#68
I’d be staggered if we could find an affordable upgrade on Furlong and possibly CT as well.

Furlong is presently one of the better full backs in the league. I’m struggling to think of one I would take over him other than Walker-Peters or Pereira in fact.
Reply
#69
I think we have to be realistic about the quality of player we can afford currently. Which makes it even more silly when we criticise those perfectly capable players we already have. Given our defensive record wtf are we even talking about weak links in our defence?!?!?
Reply
#70
(02-15-2024, 11:21 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(02-15-2024, 10:05 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(02-15-2024, 09:36 AM)Duffers Wrote: I think Ridgewell was the most maligned of all our fullbacks, especially considering he was nowhere as bad as many (both on here and in the ground) wanted him to be.

Signed as a centre half and got pushed to left back, if I recall? He played poor at centre half but did a decent job at left back. I thought he was a good player for us. 

Memory may be hazy and that may be bollocks.

Think he was already playing LB for Blues when we signed him. He was primarily bought as a LB who could fill in at CB when needed.

Very much a typical Roy-era signing - solid, unspectacular, wasn't too invested in crossing the halfway line... He was doomed from the start due to his Villa connections and the growing desire at the time for sexier signings.

I don't recall Ridgewell being particularly slagged off or hated.  He was a solid, dependable player.  The idea we hate fullbacks is just crap.

There's always a weakest player in an eleven, every fan base does it and maybe that has been both Furlong and maybe more so Townsend at times which is why they get highlighted.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: