Crossing / Goals
#1
When looking at some stats for CT and DF I noticed we are far and away the most prolific crossers in the league. Then I saw we have one of the lowest shots on target count in the league too. So I had a read through some research articles about its all. 

They pretty much unanimously agree that high number of crosses does not increase the likelihood of a positive outcome in a match. Especially when you increase the quality of competition. 

For example 25% of goals were scored from open play crosses in the Australian women's league, but only 15% were in the EPL. 
It has been documented that only 1 in 91.47 open play crosses result in a goal in the EPL. Now that is more inefficient than even I expected.  

Considering all the above its hardly surprising we are a low scoring team generally and we have very few shots on target. Something for CC to work on.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#2
I would have expected that, in fact it's a higher percentage than I'd have thought. In reality, how often do you see a well executed cross and finish? When you see a goal from a cross it's usually preceded by poor defending, rather than quality attacking.

Yes, I'm aware most goals can be brought back to some form of poor play. It's a pretty obvious tactic nowadays to be reluctant to cross the ball, given how often it results in a turnover in possession and a potential counter attack.
Reply
#3
Absolutely. I would love to see a deeper analysis into it. Cause it always seems to me that a first time cross from a through ball tends to be more efficient than one when a player has dribbled first. I think this is to do with how settled defenses are. When a team breaks, like we did twice yesterday, defenders are running towards their own goal and are not in the right body shape to defend.

Where as when a a cross is the result of a prolonged period of play where a defensive team is in their shape it is a low percentage way of opening teams up.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#4
Interesting but can also only surely also be considered in the face of how he had to go about fixing our very leaky defence early on. While that stays as robust as it is I’m not sure what you’ve identified needs fixing as it’s sufficient off the back of this
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#5
Also helps having someone to attack the cross, I like BTA but he's not the type of striker that makes great runs and finds space in the box like Phillips was. We're also woeful from corners suggesting we're not creating space to attack the ball, on top of quality issues relating to the delivery.

Fellows ability to dig the ball out and drop it into no-man's land is being wasted a bit because nobody is there to attack the ball.
Reply
#6
(02-14-2024, 02:46 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Also helps having someone to attack the cross, I like BTA but he's not the type of striker that makes great runs and finds space in the box like Phillips was. We're also woeful from corners suggesting we're not creating space to attack the ball, on top of quality issues relating to the delivery.

Fellows ability to dig the ball out and drop it into no-man's land is being wasted a bit because nobody is there to attack the ball.

I think this why open play crossing is so inefficient generally. Just under 1 in 5 are "accurate" according to the study above. So even then only 1 in 18 of those "accurate" crosses lead to goals. 

That's why I mentioned in my game report fred that I would love to see Fellows start attacking the box a little more with his brilliant off the ball running, I call it the "Theo Walcott" run. But I suppose on that side its more akin to Salah's running.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#7
What's defined as a cross though? Is it any ball from a wide position? A-la Fellows to Johnston last night or does it have to be a high ball?

Personally, I think low crosses are far more dangerous, as they are harder to defend, so get frustrated when we try to loft balls in only for them to be mopped up by giant centre halves or collected by the keeper.

Both Fellows and Wallace are experts at the "pull back", we just don't have a striker with the instinct to get on the end of them.
Reply
#8
(02-14-2024, 02:40 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Interesting but can also only surely also be considered in the face of how he had to go about fixing our very leaky defence early on. While that stays as robust as it is I’m not sure what you’ve identified needs fixing as it’s sufficient off the back of this

Oh absolutely mate. We win so many games because we are so solid and we do the basics right in possession and in transition. We give very few counter attacks away, even though we've had some big ones in recent weeks just to prove the rule. 

I think inefficiencies always need addressing, that's how we get better. If we could reduce our crossing by 25% and increase our shot count from live passes or previous shots we will score more goals. That doesn't have to affect our defensive and transitional play too much. In fact i think Mikey Johnston already helped in that regard last night as he like to cut in and play short passes and is always looking for 1,2's around the box, rather than hitting the byline.

(02-14-2024, 02:59 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: What's defined as a cross though? Is it any ball from a wide position? A-la Fellows to Johnston last night or does it have to be a high ball?

Personally, I think low crosses are far more dangerous, as they are harder to defend, so get frustrated when we try to loft balls in only for them to be mopped up by giant centre halves or collected by the keeper.

Both Fellows and Wallace are experts at the "pull back", we just don't have a striker with the instinct to get on the end of them.

Yes any delivery from a wide directly area into the box. I agree that its the stood up balls that are so inefficient. 

it was nice to hear Mikey Johnston talking about how CC has been drumming into him about making that run into the penalty area for pull backs. We so often only have BTA and perhaps swift in there. We need the opposite fullback to be attacking the back post, BTA to be getting across the near and the opposite winger and 10 getting around the penalty spot in our current shape. It should be drilled into them until they are sick of making the runs in training.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#9
(02-14-2024, 03:01 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-14-2024, 02:40 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Interesting but can also only surely also be considered in the face of how he had to go about fixing our very leaky defence early on. While that stays as robust as it is I’m not sure what you’ve identified needs fixing as it’s sufficient off the back of this

Oh absolutely mate. We win so many games because we are so solid and we do the basics right in possession and in transition. We give very few counter attacks away, even though we've had some big ones in recent weeks just to prove the rule. 

I think inefficiencies always need addressing, that's how we get better. If we could reduce our crossing by 25% and increase our shot count from live passes or previous shots we will score more goals. That doesn't have to affect our defensive and transitional play too much. In fact i think Mikey Johnston already helped in that regard last night as he like to cut in and play short passes and is always looking for 1,2's around the box, rather than hitting the byline.

(02-14-2024, 02:59 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: What's defined as a cross though? Is it any ball from a wide position? A-la Fellows to Johnston last night or does it have to be a high ball?

Personally, I think low crosses are far more dangerous, as they are harder to defend, so get frustrated when we try to loft balls in only for them to be mopped up by giant centre halves or collected by the keeper.

Both Fellows and Wallace are experts at the "pull back", we just don't have a striker with the instinct to get on the end of them.

Yes any delivery from a wide directly area into the box. I agree that its the stood up balls that are so inefficient. 

it was nice to hear Mikey Johnston talking about how CC has been drumming into him about making that run into the penalty area for pull backs. We so often only have BTA and perhaps swift in there. We need the opposite fullback to be attacking the back post, BTA to be getting across the near and the opposite winger and 10 getting around the penalty spot in our current shape. It should be drilled into them until they are sick of making the runs in training.
And then Townsend boots it into McDonalds. "Av it"  Big Grin

I would also like to see Fellows and Johnston drive into the box more, they are a defender's worst nightmare and should be worth 5 or 6 penalties a season in this league.
Reply
#10
Bang on about Johnston lurker. Reckon he could be absolute gold to us at this level
Someone could have been killed
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: