Not a very sure start to life
#91
(02-09-2024, 04:07 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-09-2024, 01:46 PM)Ossian Wrote: "It’s not a sacrifice of any note to go without a holiday (waaah)..."

Try telling that to somebody who spends the other 50 weeks of the year caring for elderly and disabled family members, you pompous arsehole.

I agree completely with what you’ve just said but we are talking about comfortably well off people who could afford two or three holidays a year if they chose to spend their money differently. We aren’t talking about full time carers who are desperate for respite, get paid a pittance and have to rely on charities to actually have a holiday/days rest rather than take their caring duties just to a different place in the country for a week etc.

I know, Derek; I was responding to Pontificator's judgemental, ill-informed... well, pontificating.
Reply
#92
(02-09-2024, 04:00 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Why do you need to be a Thatcherite to be of the opinion that if you can't afford it you can't have it?

My folks made sacrifices for me and my brother. Different sacrifices from those I might make for my kids. But sacrifices nevertheless. I suspect you're simply lacking in empathy for anyone who you perceive may be less deserving of your moral stamp of approval. Never mind.

All I have ever said about poverty is that relative poverty is a pretty poor measure of anything (it is), and that absolute poverty is well on its way to being eradicated in every country that adopts markets, property rights and the rule of law. And in several that don't necessarily have all three.

Then I know a hell of a lot of outliers BB.

So the rules change and some cannot afford to send their kids to private school anymore… following your own principles you’ve shown on here over the years that’s just tough. There’s a gap in the market for cheaper, no frills for private schools perhaps that’s the solution.
Reply
#93
(02-09-2024, 04:00 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Then I know a hell of a lot of outliers BB.

Anecdotes are not data
Reply
#94
(02-09-2024, 04:12 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: There’s a gap in the market for cheaper, no frills for private schools perhaps that’s the solution.

Education Vouchers. An excellent solution.

(02-09-2024, 04:31 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-09-2024, 04:00 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Then I know a hell of a lot of outliers BB.

Anecdotes are not data

The IFS calls out the weakness of the available data to back up your contention. There's plenty of data that shows independent schools closing through reduced rolls and increased costs. There also an obvious effect that if parents seek to keep their kids in independent schools their discretionary spending will reduce elsewhere negating the minor tax raising effect of the policy anyway.

Face it, it's simply optics to appeal to the resentful that infest the left of politics.
Reply
#95
"Most of the evidence suggests that the level of private schooling is quite inelastic and often shaped by other factors, such as values, culture and desires for a different type of education."

From the IFS report from July, the data uncertainty in their reports relates to primarily to the effects of labour supply and tax avoidance on revenue raising - not demand (they're pretty confident demand won't change).

And it's a popular measure, IPSOS polled this and 57% said they were in favour including don't knows (47% of 2019 Tory voters support it from that poll, 17% oppose). It looks like it has a pretty broad appeal across the centre and owing to everything pointing to demand being inelastic from a data perspective Labour are likely of the opinion that the risk of knock-on effects are low.
Reply
#96
It’s the ethically correct thing to do and the only real question is why it hasn’t always been thus.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#97
(02-09-2024, 07:27 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: "Most of the evidence suggests that the level of private schooling is quite inelastic and often shaped by other factors, such as values, culture and desires for a different type of education."

Whilst pointing out that the data that evidence is based on is weak. I've read the report too.

It states that demand has remained relatively inelastic after a real terms rise in fees of 20% between 2010-11 - 2022-23. What is being suggested is another 20% overnight.

Most of the (weak) evidence pointed to a dodgy throttle pot (£850) in one of my cars when the actual problem was a sheered Kayser valve (£70).

Here's my prediction, for what it's worth: the imposition of VAT on school fees will lead to the demise of many of the smaller cheaper independent schools. Independent provision will become wholly the preserve of exceptionally wealthy people further embedding inequalities. The net receipts from the policy will be minuscule if there are any at all. The Labour Party will feel better about itself for 5 minutes. 

After coming to their senses about so many things in the last few months, I'd hope this vindictive and divisive policy will remain off the statute book.
Reply
#98
Between 2003 and 2023, and as I already mentioned the 6-7% tracks for a lot longer than that - going back to the mid-1980s despite the makeup of fee payers moving away from the upper middle classes over that time (see below from a UCL study from 2017):

[Image: a-Share-of-Private-Schools-Pupils-and-Te...4-2010.ppm]

The evidence that they say is weak is related to revenue raising and labour and the impact that will have on total revenues, not demand.

My prediction is the trend of 6-7% participation rates of total full-time pupil enrollment will continue, fees more than doubling over a ten year period made no difference so I doubt this will. And quite frankly I am already of the opinion that independent schools are the preserve of the exceptionally wealthy owing to how much they've risen over the last 35 years (and that's why I want reform of charitable status with respect to tying eligibility to both access to facilities - especially sporting facilities - to nearby state schools and scholarships/bursaries as a percentage of enrollment).
Reply
#99
(02-09-2024, 08:24 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Between 2003 and 2023, and as I already mentioned the 6-7% tracks for a lot longer than that - going back to the mid-1980s despite the makeup of fee payers moving away from the upper middle classes over that time (see below from a UCL study from 2017):

[Image: a-Share-of-Private-Schools-Pupils-and-Te...4-2010.ppm]

The evidence that they say is weak is related to revenue raising and labour and the impact that will have on total revenues, not demand.

My prediction is the trend of 6-7% participation rates of total full-time pupil enrollment will continue, fees more than doubling over a ten year period made no difference so I doubt this will. And quite frankly I am already of the opinion that independent schools are the preserve of the exceptionally wealthy owing to how much they've risen over the last 35 years (and that's why I want reform of charitable status with respect to tying eligibility to both access to facilities - especially sporting facilities - to nearby state schools and scholarships/bursaries as a percentage of enrollment).

I disagree, naturally.

What you'll find is that scholarships / bursaries will completely disappear. Access to facilities (which my kids used to use at Bromsgrove for instance) will be withdrawn and smaller schools will simply close.

We'll see who's right again, won't we?
Reply
Update on the VAT situation - foreign students can claim it back so it won’t affect that market.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)