Not a very sure start to life
#61
Show me actual evidence to contest the data with respect to rises in private school fees being well above inflation instead of anecdotes. Average day fees are 2/5ths the median household income and a third of the 4th quintile.

Look at how much private school fees have risen above inflation since 1990, it's ridiculous.
Reply
#62
I’m out with a mate of mine who’s job it is to get the foreign students in, he’s in Uni’s so not exactly the same, so I’ll check with him but isn’t the VAT for overseas studens reclaimable?
Reply
#63
(02-08-2024, 10:38 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Show me actual evidence to contest the data with respect to rises in private school fees being well above inflation instead of anecdotes. Average day fees are 2/5ths the median household income and a third of the 4th quintile.

Look at how much private school fees have risen above inflation since 1990, it's ridiculous.

I think you only need to look at the rate of private school closures to tell you about the cost base spiral, particularly prep schools. Our work with private schools invariably involves the huge fixed costs, maintenance and rebuilding of older and often listed buildings, the consequent issues with energy use and energy efficiency, the inconsistent application of Business Rates, inflation in catering costs and a tight labour market.
Reply
#64
(02-08-2024, 10:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-08-2024, 10:38 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Show me actual evidence to contest the data with respect to rises in private school fees being well above inflation instead of anecdotes. Average day fees are 2/5ths the median household income and a third of the 4th quintile.

Look at how much private school fees have risen above inflation since 1990, it's ridiculous.

I think you only need to look at the rate of private school closures to tell you about the cost base spiral, particularly prep schools. Our work with private schools invariably involves the huge fixed costs, maintenance and rebuilding of older and often listed buildings, the consequent issues with energy use and energy efficiency, the inconsistent application of Business Rates, inflation in catering costs and a tight labour market.

So? Listings aside for the most part, so do state schools. Secondary state schools have had a real terms decrease in funding per pupil of 16% yet the average fees have risen by 470% in that time while CPI is tracked to 200% and average earnings have tracked 220%.

Fees are ridiculous, the demographics sending their kids to private schools are very different now compared with 35 years ago. The gap between state school spending per pupil and private school spending more than doubled from £3,500 in 2010 to £7,200 in 2022 which is 50% more than if it had tracked inflation.
Reply
#65
(02-08-2024, 11:06 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: So? 

So using your logic private education makes supernormal profits. 

If that's the case it makes absolutely no economic sense that the number of independent schools has not grown. In fact 46 independent schools closed in 2023.

So why is the sector not growing? Why are schools closing? And why are fees rising?

Our direct experience suggests much of it is due to the cost base - particularly land and buildings which have risen far in excess of inflation,  and latterly that borrowings are at much higher interest rates. The Independent sector has not historically benefitted from framework agreements for technology capital - for instance manufacturer price support means MFDs are virtually given away in the state sector these days. Sites tend to be larger and facilities also tend to be greater in the Independent sector- swimming pools for instance cost a lot to heat even before Putin invaded Ukraine. One school we worked with was losing £40,000 a year in a water leak beneath an accommodation block, but couldn't afford to both close the block and complete the remedial works necessary.

But as I said, if the Independent sector as a whole was truly benefiting from the profits you believe it's making there would be planning applications springing up everywhere across the home counties. As it is, there are none.
Reply
#66
I didn't mention anything about profits (not sure why that's relevant at all as independent schools are supposed to charities, not private businesses with shareholder demands), I talked about much fees have risen above inflation and as a result the demographics of the people that send their kids to private schools has changed since 35 years ago.
Reply
#67
I know you did. But if the Independent sector was making as much money as you think it is, the fundamental laws of economics would still apply.
Reply
#68
The fundamental laws of economics would imply that independent school fees are inelastic owing to the continued rate of increase in fees well above inflation in a linear pattern and the fact that the proportion of children enrolled in independent schools and direct grant grammar schools has been fairly static at between 6% and 7% since the mid-1980s.

That's a pretty big detail.
Reply
#69
BB. It's entirely your business if you choose to ignore the cost base for independent schools. However two of my colleagues have built their entire consultancy businesses around attempts to address it.
Reply
#70
What does that reply have to do with anything I've said?

It seems like you want to have an argument with me over something I really don't care about. I'm not writing about how much it costs to run an independent school to justify the price of fees, I'm on about the demand side response to inflation and enrollment. Independent school fees are inelastic, middle class families clearly don't rely on them as compared to 35 years ago owing to the rate of increases so why exactly would I believe that a 20% rise is going to impact their enrollments? They rose over 100% between 2010 and 2022, that didn't effect demand whatsoever.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)