Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(02-07-2024, 02:24 PM)Jerry Wrote: (02-07-2024, 01:18 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: This Palmer "mistake". (Upthread). He saved it. Now he may have been thinking of tipping it over then realised he could keep it in. Or the flight of the ball varied so he just about got his hands behind it. Whatever it was, he saved a shot on target, it is not a mistake.
He almost let a simple catch through his hands and was lucky to catch it before it went over the line. Simplest of saves for a professional keeper or parks pitch keeper. You have made comments on the scores did you or have you not seen the game?
I was at the game, yes. Almost letting a ball through his hands is not the same as letting in a goal. That ball goes in, then it's a keeper's error, it didn't so it's a save. I don't care how he keeps clean sheets as long as he does. I don't care that we won ugly, just that we won.
Posts: 466
Threads: 1
Joined: Feb 2023
Reputation:
2
(02-07-2024, 05:46 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (02-07-2024, 02:24 PM)Jerry Wrote: (02-07-2024, 01:18 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: This Palmer "mistake". (Upthread). He saved it. Now he may have been thinking of tipping it over then realised he could keep it in. Or the flight of the ball varied so he just about got his hands behind it. Whatever it was, he saved a shot on target, it is not a mistake.
He almost let a simple catch through his hands and was lucky to catch it before it went over the line. Simplest of saves for a professional keeper or parks pitch keeper. You have made comments on the scores did you or have you not seen the game?
I was at the game, yes. Almost letting a ball through his hands is not the same as letting in a goal. That ball goes in, then it's a keeper's error, it didn't so it's a save. I don't care how he keeps clean sheets as long as he does. I don't care that we won ugly, just that we won.
Keep on track we are talking about performance scores and doing that would reduce his score.
Posts: 988
Threads: 43
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation:
0
Okay gets high marks yet I don't remember any of his headers finding our players. To a lesser extent both Bartley and Kipre were also guilty of this.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(02-07-2024, 05:53 PM)Jerry Wrote: (02-07-2024, 05:46 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (02-07-2024, 02:24 PM)Jerry Wrote: (02-07-2024, 01:18 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: This Palmer "mistake". (Upthread). He saved it. Now he may have been thinking of tipping it over then realised he could keep it in. Or the flight of the ball varied so he just about got his hands behind it. Whatever it was, he saved a shot on target, it is not a mistake.
He almost let a simple catch through his hands and was lucky to catch it before it went over the line. Simplest of saves for a professional keeper or parks pitch keeper. You have made comments on the scores did you or have you not seen the game?
I was at the game, yes. Almost letting a ball through his hands is not the same as letting in a goal. That ball goes in, then it's a keeper's error, it didn't so it's a save. I don't care how he keeps clean sheets as long as he does. I don't care that we won ugly, just that we won.
Keep on track we are talking about performance scores and doing that would reduce his score. OK, I see where we differ. I guess the stats score would have been lower had he let that shot in. He didn't so his mark remains as is. Just my supposition, I'm not a stats man, just interested to see where they differ from my opinion.
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(02-07-2024, 05:34 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I love reading these but my god some of them are so wide of the mark of watching the game with your own eyes
Players shouldn't be getting 10's in a tight one nil contest unless they don't put a foot wrong, see my marks below Furlong was my MOM but a 10? And an 8 for Townsend? Nooooooooooooooo
We won 1-0 and were below our best but won ugly, which was great to see but PNE away, Hull at Home etc we were full of 8's and 9's not Saturday
Palmer 6 Seemed extremely shaky for some reason and let a couple slip through his gloves
Furlong 8* Thought he was excellent personally, both defensively and attacking, assist for goal
Townsend 5 Again so often one paced when going forward or doing his defensive duties, weak link in the side currently I’d say
Kipre 5 Real off day today, sloppy defensively and gave the ball away at times too with wayward passing, good call from CC pulling him
Bartley 7 Got his head on most things and was certainly the stronger CH partner today
Okay 8 Another excellent showing, kept us ticking over through midfield and solid when at CH, loved the late aggression
Mowatt 7 Plenty of effort and running, tried to drive us forward and covered the ground well, some sloppy passing and set pieces again hit and miss
Swift 5 Miles off it today, nothing came off for him and rightly hauled off
Wallace 6 Though personally he was OK, no better, carried the ball well at times and as always plenty of running
Fellows 7 Constant menace on either flank, some great crosses and passing, have it away a few times which is understandable but good to see him comfortable on the left flank
BTA 5 Got little change out the Blues CH’s, back post volley from a corner he should have done better with
Subs
Marshall 5 Plenty of effort, thought he lacked pace a little with a couple of balls over the top but competed well and will improve for his outing
Johnston 7 Thought he showed good control and quick feet, couple of times on dangerous areas and have the ball away but clearly has talent going forward and played a part in the goal, promising start
Wienmann 7 Very very under rated finish for me, lovely to see a fox in the box type finish, something we’ve been crying out for all season as cross after cross came in and nobody was on the end of them
Chalobah 6 Going to play a big part between now and the end of the season with us down the 3 midfielders as things stand, slow start but improved and at times shows his quality
Dike 5 Came on and managed to put pressure on the blues defenders, pulled out of one 50/50 which was understandable
Yes Johnston deserves a 7 but Marshall surely deserves a 6 just for putting Furlong in that made the goal. Beautifully weighted pass.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
1st Half - Given the standard of play, the amount of times we gave the ball away in our own half from poor passing and general sloppiness I can't see how anyone can score 10/10. It was a very poor half with a malaise both on and off the pitch.
2nd Half - A bit better, we created a few chances and gave the ball away a bit less. We seemed to give the initiative away with the subs and looked weaker overall. And then we scored and everything was alright with the world again. A much feistier second half and an atmosphere to reflect that.
We probably shaded the better quality chances, but they had more shots overall and I'd suggest a fairly even game settled by a quality finish out of keeping with the other 90+ mins.
Marks ranging 5-7 are much more accurate and in keeping "with my eyes". We'll play better and lose (probably already have - Southampton away as an example).
Stats have a place but they only provide a certain amount of information that have to be reviewed in conjunction with the actual performance. Furlong had a decent game and probably was MotM seconded by Mowatt (if he could yed the ball he'd have got that accolade) but he was hardly faultless throughout.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(02-07-2024, 06:44 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: 1st Half - Given the standard of play, the amount of times we gave the ball away in our own half from poor passing and general sloppiness I can't see how anyone can score 10/10. It was a very poor half with a malaise both on and off the pitch.
2nd Half - A bit better, we created a few chances and gave the ball away a bit less. We seemed to give the initiative away with the subs and looked weaker overall. And then we scored and everything was alright with the world again. A much feistier second half and an atmosphere to reflect that.
We probably shaded the better quality chances, but they had more shots overall and I'd suggest a fairly even game settled by a quality finish out of keeping with the other 90+ mins.
Marks ranging 5-7 are much more accurate and in keeping "with my eyes". We'll play better and lose (probably already have - Southampton away as an example).
Stats have a place but they only provide a certain amount of information that have to be reviewed in conjunction with the actual performance. Furlong had a decent game and probably was MotM seconded by Mowatt (if he could yed the ball he'd have got that accolade) but he was hardly faultless throughout.
+1. Decent summary.
Posts: 9,630
Threads: 517
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(02-07-2024, 06:49 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (02-07-2024, 06:44 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: 1st Half - Given the standard of play, the amount of times we gave the ball away in our own half from poor passing and general sloppiness I can't see how anyone can score 10/10. It was a very poor half with a malaise both on and off the pitch.
2nd Half - A bit better, we created a few chances and gave the ball away a bit less. We seemed to give the initiative away with the subs and looked weaker overall. And then we scored and everything was alright with the world again. A much feistier second half and an atmosphere to reflect that.
We probably shaded the better quality chances, but they had more shots overall and I'd suggest a fairly even game settled by a quality finish out of keeping with the other 90+ mins.
Marks ranging 5-7 are much more accurate and in keeping "with my eyes". We'll play better and lose (probably already have - Southampton away as an example).
Stats have a place but they only provide a certain amount of information that have to be reviewed in conjunction with the actual performance. Furlong had a decent game and probably was MotM seconded by Mowatt (if he could yed the ball he'd have got that accolade) but he was hardly faultless throughout.
+1. Decent summary.
Furlong, Townsend and Mowatt played really well throughout and really kept us going in what was a really stodgy performance especially further up the pitch. That's why they get a few extra marks between them for me. But 6s and a 5 in the starting front 4 based on stats I think shows where we struggled.
Having those extra options, especially with a returning Grady will help no end.
"IMO of course..."
|