Not a very sure start to life
#11
(02-05-2024, 05:51 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Yeah of course, the old ‘Labour only did well because the Tories gave them the tap in’ line

https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/politicsandpolic...7-to-2008/

It's as true as "Gordon Brown caused the global financial crisis" and "The party of economic competency" lines they trot out that the hard-of-thinking still lap up.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#12
I don't agree with the premise that "A common view is that the performance of the UK economy between 1997 and 2010 under Labour was very weak and that the current economic problems are a consequence of poor policies in this period."

That's not a common view, at least not one I've heard. 2008-2010, yes. But not 1997-2008.

And a paper written in 2011 is no use whatsover as a commentary on how the disastrous response to the GFC has played out - in an era of low / no growth, sclerotic productivity, maxed-out personal and corporate taxation rates, a monetary straitjacket, a completely dysfunctional housing market, the tightest labour market in our history, interest rates sitting back at their long term average and, of course, embedded inflation.

Is it?

(02-05-2024, 06:30 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: It's as true as "Gordon Brown caused the global financial crisis" and "The party of economic competency" lines they trot out that the hard-of-thinking still lap up.

Who trots out the former line? 

Brown's regulation of the banking sector certainly didn't help (nor did any other governments), but their collective response to the GFC is the direct cause of our problems now.
Reply
#13
A large part of the current problems we have now in this country are directly down to the Tory party's austerity drive which should have been spread over a lot longer period rather than the scorched earth approach used to get it complete in two terms. We're also now struggling to deal with the privatisation of the public services that never sat into a competitive marketplace (water and rail) and the failure to invest in the future of our energy resources.

Whether you agree or not the combination of a public infrastructure and a strong business base in this country is what was always needed. We need to spend the money on the youth centres, community policing and unprofitable shite like that to bring through a workforce that feel part of society. We needed to build the houses rather than shift them all out to the private sector do their bit when it suits them so that the workers could have somewhere to live and aspire to. And we needed to use the taxes effectively rather than line the pockets of the Tory party donors.
Reply
#14
(02-05-2024, 08:09 PM)baggy1 Wrote: A large part of the current problems we have now in this country are directly down to the Tory party's austerity drive which should have been spread over a lot longer period rather than the scorched earth approach used to get it complete in two terms. We're also now struggling to deal with the privatisation of the public services that never sat into a competitive marketplace (water and rail) and the failure to invest in the future of our energy resources.

Whether you agree or not the combination of a public infrastructure and a strong business base in this country is what was always needed. We need to spend the money on the youth centres, community policing and unprofitable shite like that to bring through a workforce that feel part of society. We needed to build the houses rather than shift them all out to the private sector do their bit when it suits them so that the workers could have somewhere to live and aspire to. And we needed to use the taxes effectively rather than line the pockets of the Tory party donors.

All of this.

I will not view a party that spent £200+ on the Rwanda scheme as paragons of fiscal responsibility.
Reply
#15
For all the Billy Big Bollox economic tosh Proth types… the fact he fails to see that if society doesn’t look after its younger generations health and wellbeing it will simply cost more money in the long term. From rotting teeth to fat bellies the cost to everyone to address these conditions in adulthood will dwarf those of Sure Starr centres, youth clubs etc.

I would be embarrassed to have campaigned on behalf of a party who have wrecked every public service in the country over the past 14yrs.
Reply
#16
(02-05-2024, 08:09 PM)baggy1 Wrote: A large part of the current problems we have now in this country are directly down to the Tory party's austerity drive which should have been spread over a lot longer period rather than the scorched earth approach used to get it complete in two terms. We're also now struggling to deal with the privatisation of the public services that never sat into a competitive marketplace (water and rail) and the failure to invest in the future of our energy resources.

Whether you agree or not the combination of a public infrastructure and a strong business base in this country is what was always needed. We need to spend the money on the youth centres, community policing and unprofitable shite like that to bring through a workforce that feel part of society. We needed to build the houses rather than shift them all out to the private sector do their bit when it suits them so that the workers could have somewhere to live and aspire to. And we needed to use the taxes effectively rather than line the pockets of the Tory party donors.

You forgot public transport investment, it's no coincidence that the two UK metro areas with good public transport links to their economic centres (Edinburgh and London) are miles ahead of other UK metro areas where public transport is shite (especially Birmingham and Leeds). If you make it so people can actually get to work affordably and quickly then output improves, and when output improves the tax take goes up, and when the tax take goes up you have room for both tax cuts and operational government expenditure.
Reply
#17
(02-05-2024, 08:09 PM)baggy1 Wrote: A large part of the current problems we have now in this country are directly down to the Tory party's austerity drive which should have been spread over a lot longer period rather than the scorched earth approach used to get it complete in two terms. We're also now struggling to deal with the privatisation of the public services that never sat into a competitive marketplace (water and rail) and the failure to invest in the future of our energy resources.

Whether you agree or not the combination of a public infrastructure and a strong business base in this country is what was always needed. We need to spend the money on the youth centres, community policing and unprofitable shite like that to bring through a workforce that feel part of society. We needed to build the houses rather than shift them all out to the private sector do their bit when it suits them so that the workers could have somewhere to live and aspire to. And we needed to use the taxes effectively rather than line the pockets of the Tory party donors.

Let's not forget that the Tory Party's austerity drive was aped pretty much to the letter by Labour in their 2010 Manifesto. Labour proposed going further by not ringfencing the NHS from cuts as the Tories did. That is a fact, not an opinion.

By 2015 austerity was over and by every measure we've had, in public spending terms,  a massively expansionary period since. That's also a fact.

Our current problems are rooted in a failure to get to grips with public debt, no lessons were learned from 2008 with the Covid largesse advanced to businesses followed by ridiculously generous bungs to households who didn't need them for energy prices. 

Public Debt is over £2.5 TRILLION, that's nearly £40,000 for every man woman and child in the UK. Getting debt under control is one of very few things that matter if you wish to spend on pet projects - that's why Labour is retreating at a canter from several spending pledges. That's why the State Pension age will go up again for quite a few of us on here who were thinking of retiring at 67.

Regardless of anyone's opinion the legacy left by the Major government was, factually, exceptionally beneficial to the incoming Blair governments. What is also factually correct, is that Labour will inherit a deep and poisonous well from the Tories this time round. And at no point has Labour argued against the creation of ever more debt in the last 14 years (often arguing for more) - they've colluded in the conceit that debt is without consequences in the same way the Tories colluded with Brown to nationalise moral hazard in 2008.

I would dearly love profitability and productivity to be growing such that you can have all the Easter Eggs you want. But neither can thrive whilst weighed down by enormous debt, a shrinking, aging, increasingly unhealthy and increasingly workshy labour market. But simply changing government will not achieve that - we, the public will just end up being shafted by what appears to be merely a more sensitive rapist.
Reply
#18
There is a lot there that is factually correct and it is certainly fair to say that had Labour retained power in 2010 they would’ve faced the limiting circumstances that you describe. But there was still an ideological chasm between the direction under which those choices were implemented and the manner in which they were too.

You only have to look to the response to covid that you refer to - homeless people suddenly magically found shelter, public services were supported to deliver the expertise they are founded on and hey presto! Why? The motivation was suddenly a lot more crystallised when the systems that underpin the wealthy suddenly came under threat. Say what you want about Blair and Brown, but what drove them was very different to what drives this lot
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#19
I refer you to the final sentence in my last post.
Reply
#20
I read it. It’s way off the mark. Reducing poverty, improving healthcare, literacy, access to HE and growing communities isn’t a “different kind of rape”. And it would take a fairly blind set of eyes to suggest it is.
Someone could have been killed
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)