Albion hall of shame
#61
(01-24-2024, 10:57 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(01-24-2024, 10:23 AM)Black Lake Victoria Wrote: 35000+ Irish men died in WWI

The UK Parliament voted for Home Rule for Ireland in 1914......what happened....I've read somewhere that we (UK) have tried on numerous occasions to pass Ulster onto the South!

Irish men had no choice to fight and die because all of Ireland was British ruled by Britain and as is well known in those times if you refused to fight, there was a very good chance of being executed, home rule was suspended until the conclusion of WW1, the 1916 uprising changed all that when the leaders were executed, in as much as it hardened the Irish stance for sef determination which led to the free state in 1922.
Only six counties of Ulster make up Northern Ireland, two are in the republic, as for repeared attempts to hand it back as you put it, that was impossible, as the loyalist majority would never allow it and as the gerrymandering ensured catholics could not vote so there would always be a loyalist majority, nothing would ever change, hence the cival rights movement and the start of the troubles.
You see an awful lot was going on before the terrorists were involved.
Did anyone really have a choice?
Reply
#62
(01-24-2024, 10:37 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If I'd had people murdered by the Spanish army I wouldn't go and live in Spain and contribute to said army through my taxes, no matter how much money was offered. That's my issue with him, if he really wanted to uphold his principles he could have refused to ply his trade here. Now that would have earned respect.

I would rationalise that the people of spain were innocent, that it's a fine country and the atrocities occured a generation ago. However, I wouldn't want to contribute to the care of those soldiers who participated. It may (or maybe not) worth adding that I would also keep quiet, sensitive of my position and if forced to, point out it was a difficult time with awful 'errors' made on both sides. But maybe I'm just a coward.

Thinking about it, this issue is going to come up with some muslim and arab descent people. Wouldn't it be easier to separate the two? An armed forces day and a remembrance day? The money from one goes to ex-soldiers, the money from the other goes to promote democracy, or erm...whatever
Reply
#63
(01-24-2024, 11:18 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(01-24-2024, 10:37 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If I'd had people murdered by the Spanish army I wouldn't go and live in Spain and contribute to said army through my taxes, no matter how much money was offered. That's my issue with him, if he really wanted to uphold his principles he could have refused to ply his trade here. Now that would have earned respect.

I would rationalise that the people of spain were innocent, that it's a fine country and the atrocities occured a generation ago. However, I wouldn't want to contribute to the care of those soldiers who participated. I might add that I would also keep quiet, sensitive of my position. But maybe I'm just a coward.

Most people who die in war are "innocent", whether soldiers or civilians, especially the World Wars, where the line between the two is virtually non-existent. The majority are working class cannon fodder, or those that sign up to genuinely defend their country and it's people, and I think that's who the poppy truly represents. Not the governments or the oppressors.
Reply
#64
(01-24-2024, 10:13 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(01-24-2024, 10:10 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-24-2024, 10:05 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(01-24-2024, 10:02 AM)NewWanker Wrote:
(01-24-2024, 09:59 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: If you'd had people murdered in your home town by the very Army the poppy is meant to commemorate, don't you think you'd be complete against the whole thing? Come on man, it isn't difficult.

Or if you live anywhere near Birmingham and know about the innocent lives lost of those going for a drink in the city centre... then you change your view on any support for the Irish terrorists.

This. 

I understand his stance on the conflict in his home land, but to completely disrespect and refuse to acknowledge the loss of life and sacrifice made in conflicts proper to those events is ignorant at best and totally disgusting at worst.

To my knowledge, and perhaps I'm wrong here, the poppy represents loss of life and honours the memory of those who have died in conflicts since the first world war. It has little to do specifically with any Irish conflict.

Ultimately the people who laid down their lives did so to protect the freedoms we enjoy today.

One such freedom is the right to choose whether to wear a poppy or not. People are free to agree or disagree with him, but one thing that should never change is McLean's right to make that choice.

Agree with this. 

I don't disagree with his stance, as such, I disagree with how he's gone about it and his actions down the years. There's respectful ways to chose to not wear the poppy and to publicise your reasons, should you chose to (you shouldn't be forced), sadly he hasn't done that.

(01-24-2024, 10:24 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(01-24-2024, 10:13 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(01-24-2024, 10:10 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-24-2024, 10:05 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(01-24-2024, 10:02 AM)NewWanker Wrote: Or if you live anywhere near Birmingham and know about the innocent lives lost of those going for a drink in the city centre... then you change your view on any support for the Irish terrorists.

This. 

I understand his stance on the conflict in his home land, but to completely disrespect and refuse to acknowledge the loss of life and sacrifice made in conflicts proper to those events is ignorant at best and totally disgusting at worst.

To my knowledge, and perhaps I'm wrong here, the poppy represents loss of life and honours the memory of those who have died in conflicts since the first world war. It has little to do specifically with any Irish conflict.

Ultimately the people who laid down their lives did so to protect the freedoms we enjoy today.

One such freedom is the right to choose whether to wear a poppy or not. People are free to agree or disagree with him, but one thing that should never change is McLean's right to make that choice.

Agree with this. 

I don't disagree with his stance, as such, I disagree with how he's gone about it and his actions down the years. There's respectful ways to chose to not wear the poppy and to publicise your reasons, should you chose to (you shouldn't be forced), sadly he hasn't done that.

Well this is just bollocks isn't it. You've disagreed with his stance in this very thread.

(01-24-2024, 09:52 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: I'm all for free choice, and it's his choice to not wear a poppy or acknowledge what it stands for. It doesn't mean I can't think he's a prick for showing utter disrespect for the millions who have paid the ultimate sacrifice for their countries, over the decades, and across numerous wars, all waged from a politicians office who see individual lives as nothing more than a pawn on a chessboard.

Mankind is a vile and horrible species when you consider the needless loss of life in many conflicts.

I don't believe that it is a contradiction. It is possible to understand the reasons for the actions of an individual, and accept it's their right, but also not agree with it. I dislike the idea of religion, in essence it's a load of nonsense born out of story telling thousands of years ago, but I respect everyone's right to believe in whatever they wish to, as long as they don't hurt anyone. I can also understand why people do believe in a greater being! It's not for me though. 

No one should be forced to wear a poppy. That'd be ridiculous. However, I believe it's disrespectful to not do so to those who have lost their lives in good faith in the two World Wars. I accept the reasons and I get his justifications, I haven't said otherwise, however he could have somehow shown respect to the fallen of those two conflicts, that's where my thoughts are. I'd hope he doesn't disrespect or have any negative comments on those who died during th two conflicts, but that's how it comes over to me. Million's of innocent people have died over the decades, is it so hard to pay respects to them without accepting what happened in your country in a completely separate conflict? If I'm missing something, I apologise and I'll accept the education (genuinely). 

He also doesn't help himself by antognising the public on his social media and in various interviews he has conducted over the years. Although, he receives, and has received, unacceptable abuse throughout his career, again, I could understand why he'd snap and say something he doesn't necessarily believe, but just says to get back at the neanderthals who have sent death threats to him. No one should face some of the things he has faced. Disagree, yes. But be respectful about it.

For what it's worth I genuinely don't have any negative memories of him and his time here. He always gave his all for us. He was technically limited but for the most part did a decent enough job. I've no real issues with him, and certainly wouldn't put him in a hall of shame. 

Anyway, as Duffers says this subject has been done to death, it never ends well, so I'm ducking out (flouncing).
Reply
#65
(01-24-2024, 11:24 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Most people who die in war are "innocent", whether soldiers or civilians, especially the World Wars, where the line between the two is virtually non-existent. The majority are working class cannon fodder, or those that sign up to genuinely defend their country and it's people, and I think that's who the poppy truly represents. Not the governments or the oppressors.

That's exactly what I believe, but that isn't what is officially celebrated or where the money goes.
Reply
#66
Well, this thread took a turn.

Crikey.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#67
(01-24-2024, 09:07 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(01-24-2024, 08:44 AM)Duffers Wrote: McLean outrage season starts earlier and earlier each year doesn't it?

I've not calmed down since Armistice day, tbh.

Not had a chance to take down last year's effigy yet.
Reply
#68
The Royal British Legion do an enormous amount of excellent work.

That is from personal experience.
Reply
#69
(01-24-2024, 12:04 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: The Royal British Legion do an enormous amount of excellent work.

That is from personal experience.

They absolutely totally do. They arranged my grandad a sea ceremony to scatter his ashes off a Navy boat. Even though he wasn't even in the Navy, but was Army (and had lost a leg on D-Day) they went above and beyond, absolutely amazing they were.

That said my Nan who was a WAAF in the war, then decided she wanted to better his send off, we managed to arrange for a Hercules to be test flown on the day and they scattered her ashes over the same harbour out the side of the plane (my cousin (RAF) was working at the Hercules base at the time and called in some favours from other RAF members, and they were all well up for it... and it just so happened they'd had to do some repairs on that Hercules on that day and it needed a test flight... that was special to say the least. Nowt to do with the Legion that one though Big Grin
Reply
#70
Wow, that's fantastic.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: