The death of the Conservative Party
#51
(01-20-2024, 02:25 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: They wrote that with the context about lack of available access, not as a quantitative assessment of generational trends on the opinion of the public sector. The quantitative assessment from that article is about lack of access in parallel with the failings of the social-insurance healthcare model Britain had in the 1930s with the mixed system not being adequate.

That same article also contains the below passage:

"A much uglier similarity to the pre-NHS system is that more people are going without treatment. Eight in ten children are unable to register with an NHS dentist. A private knee-replacement procedure would cost a worker earning the median wage five months’ salary; for most people, the only option is to wait." - the generations affected by the lack of healthcare in the 1930s and went to the private sector for treatment directly instead of via insurance helped create the Beveridge Model and the NHS.

You are taking a sentence out of context and spinning it.

How is a statement of fact spinning it?

Healthcare is rationed by the NHS, and will continue to be whoever takes power. As the article states, more and more procedures are being outsourced to the private sector and more and more people are choosing to opt out to ensure care at a time and location convenient to them and with a consultant of their choice.

And as I stated earlier, younger generations are far less deferential to the institution (thank goodness) and will demand more. It's the silent generation and the boomers that remain in thrall to the NHS, despite all of its flaws.
Reply
#52
The point of that statement in that article is an anecdote about the trends of healthcare usage now vs the shitshow of the mixed system in the 1930s. You have taken that out of context, given it more value than it's worth and applied it to a completely unrelated context. That is the definition of spin - taking something out of context to support your own personal biases in an attempt to influence others, and you're still at it despite being called out on it by someone who has read the article so actually knows under what context it was actually used.

It is outright not a commentary on young people's attitudes to the public sector, it's a commentary on the similarities to the mismanagement of our healthcare system now vs the failures of the social insurance model in the 1930s. They're not "opting out", they're blocked out by a failing system that allocates too much of its resources to prop up a defunded and mismanaged social care sector via expensive hospital resources.
Reply
#53
(01-20-2024, 02:41 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(01-20-2024, 01:19 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(01-20-2024, 09:44 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-20-2024, 07:41 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(01-20-2024, 07:10 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You misunderstand. They’ve paid for treatment.

GPs have always been private businesses free at the point of use.

Care to link the data?

From The Economist 13 Jan issue:

"The nhs is not seen as the only option by Gen z, the generation that makes most use of private health care: four in ten 18- to 24-year-olds have used the private sector for things such as appointments with doctors, scans and diagnostics."

That was a qualitative survey commissioned by the Independent Healthcare Provider Network, a trade body representing the private healthcare sector which surveyed c2000 people initially and then asked people receptive to private healthcare follow up questions.

If they tried to present it to anyone remotely interested in evidence based research (which I acknowledge you are not) they would be laughed out of the room.

4/10 indeed! The only people who would fall for such shtick probably live in the Hagley Bubble.

My year 12s produce more reliable studies than that. Total waste of time

Allows the TPA/Tuftons to quote shite on the Internet though
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#54
(01-20-2024, 02:25 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: They wrote that with the context about lack of available access, not as a quantitative assessment of generational trends on the opinion of the public sector. The quantitative assessment from that article is about lack of access in parallel with the failings of the social-insurance healthcare model Britain had in the 1930s with the mixed system not being adequate.

That same article also contains the below passage:

"A much uglier similarity to the pre-NHS system is that more people are going without treatment. Eight in ten children are unable to register with an NHS dentist. A private knee-replacement procedure would cost a worker earning the median wage five months’ salary; for most people, the only option is to wait." - the generations affected by the lack of healthcare in the 1930s and went to the private sector for treatment directly instead of via insurance helped create the Beveridge Model and the NHS.

You are taking a sentence out of context and spinning it.

Proth wouldn’t move the goalposts to try and fit his Tufty Street private sector good public sector bad bullshit.
Reply
#55
As someone working in the NHS.

It needs a severe reform, most of us in it, know that too well. However, what does make me laugh, is a lot of the stuff that makes the NHS unfit for purpose, are decisions forced on it by the government. Then the government use those rules, they made, to knock it. It's all so stupid to score political points, rather than actually improve anything.

Tories will often point that 'spending has increased' however when you look at the way those funds were given and how hospitals have been told to spend that money, it's hilarious they dare to use it. We wanted to use some of the money to hire more Dr's and Nurses to clear the appointment backlog, it was refused since that money was for some vanity project no one at the hospital wants, but the government have declared we must do. Then our local Tory MP goes to the press to say how we are wasting money on vanity projects rather than extra staff.

Fact Proth is gullible enough to fall for it is disappointing with how know it all he tries to seem.
Reply
#56
(01-21-2024, 05:59 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:  fall for it

Fall for what?

The NHS is on its arse. Any meaningful reform will be totally resisted by the vested interests within the NHS just as it is in say, the rail industry.

As a user of private services (the best money I've ever spent) it's not just the standard of care that's light years ahead, but the culture of customer service. That's something else that younger people tend to expect as a given these days. Given the sheer scale of how much we pay for the NHS it never ceases to amaze me the appalling behaviour some people put up with from gatekeepers and "care" professionals.
Reply
#57
Didn't address a single point I made, well done Proth.
Reply
#58
It was left in a modern and functional if sometimes inefficient state in 2010. It’s been deliberately run into the ground and arguably beyond repair
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#59
(01-21-2024, 06:38 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-21-2024, 05:59 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:  fall for it

Fall for what?

The NHS is on its arse. Any meaningful reform will be totally resisted by the vested interests within the NHS just as it is in say, the rail industry.

As a user of private services (the best money I've ever spent) it's not just the standard of care that's light years ahead, but the culture of customer service. That's something else that younger people tend to expect as a given these days. Given the sheer scale of how much we pay for the NHS it never ceases to amaze me the appalling behaviour some people put up with from gatekeepers and "care" professionals.

Patient satisfaction was at an all time high and waiting lists were at an all time low when your shower of shite took power. The main problem with the NHS are the those you helped put in power.

Either you were a useful idiot for them or you know full well what the erm ‘hopes’ for the NHS amongst your Tory ‘friends’ are.
Reply
#60
(01-21-2024, 07:06 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Didn't address a single point I made, well done Proth.

I completely addressed your point. You complain about changes “forced” on the NHS. This doesn’t sound like an institution that’s ready for reform.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)