Andi Weimann
(01-13-2024, 11:53 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote:
(01-13-2024, 11:46 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(01-13-2024, 11:35 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-13-2024, 11:29 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(01-13-2024, 11:26 AM)wba13 Wrote: Posters keep going on about TGH and how Bristol love him, well he’s only started 13 of there league games and one goal, so he’s not a regular starter as we are more than halfway though the season. Why some posters make out he doing brilliant at Bristol makes me laugh,he’s doing ok. Weimann is a seasoned professional who knows his way around the championship and if Carlos wants him I will take his word over all you football geniuses on here.

One will be worth a couple of £m in 18 months time, whilst the other zilch.

But right now we need forward cover not, midfield/right back utility cover, FF. 

Sadly we are, right now, a '6 month at a time' sort of club until the take over goes through. We need to try and protect our most valuable, long term playing assets; Okay, Swift, Wallace, BTA, Dike, Grady. Even Kipre/Mowatt perhaps. And wheel and deal with everyone else to get the balance of the squad right. Once the sale goes through we can start to plan solely for the future.

I agree.  It’s the potential for an 18 month contract that worries me (that’s if Andi does have a 12 month option at city.). He could I guess be here for 6 months and then take the extension at city (if there is one). 

But if it is a permanent signing, then it’s not the best and will go totally against what Miles said we would be doing going forward. I.e.  bringing in players that will have a resale value. 

I guess we will have to wait and see.

There will always be exceptions to that rule. We’ve brought in our own youngsters, plus Dike, BTA, Mulumby who are all under 23. The Dowling years are gone , thankfully. Plus every squad needs experienced players.

It doesn’t matter what Weimann is worth in a couple of years time he won’t be here. As I’ve heard he will only be here till the end of season at present, that is what we need cover across the front line.As for TGH he wouldn’t get in our side we have a good midfield and good midfield cover.
Reply
People keep saying “but but they said they’d buy younger players!” are either deliberately missing the point or just being thick.

I’m certain once the takeover is complete and finances are back on track then yes we hopefully change transfer policy and look at younger players with resale value. But right now we need players in through the door who can do a job immediately and won’t cost the earth.

Weiman is not an exciting signing, he isn’t young and isn’t going to have any resale value, but he is what we need and are able to bring in right now.
Reply
(01-13-2024, 01:08 PM)Duffers Wrote: People keep saying “but but they said they’d buy younger players!” are either deliberately missing the point or just being thick.

I’m certain once the takeover is complete and finances are back on track then yes we hopefully change transfer policy and look at younger players with resale value. But right now we need players in through the door who can do a job immediately and won’t cost the earth.

Weiman is not an exciting signing, he isn’t young and isn’t going to have any resale value, but he is what we need and are able to bring in right now.

Common sense at last!
Reply
(01-13-2024, 11:26 AM)wba13 Wrote: Posters keep going on about TGH and how Bristol love him, well he’s only started 13 of there league games and one goal, so he’s not a regular starter as we are more than halfway though the season. Why some posters make out he doing brilliant at Bristol makes me laugh,he’s doing ok. Weimann is a seasoned professional who knows his way around the championship and if Carlos wants him I will take his word over all you football geniuses on here.


This is misleading. 

In the league he has started 14 games, but he’s also started 13 of the last 17 and made an appearance in all 17. In the first 2 months of the season he only started 1.

He didn’t start out as a regular, but he is now.
Reply
Haven't got a pot to piss in until a new owner is confirmed, and due to injury we are desperately short up font.

Weimann can play across the front line and he may not be the most prolific but is know to be a hard running and hard working player, he is obviously also a leader. On a loan with an option this looks sensible business and as has been mentioned we may be offsetting.

I still get surprised by some posters. There would be much excitement if we were linked with loaning or even buying players we obviously couldn't afford, or if some random 19 year old export arrived from a PL reserve side with zero Champ experience was mentioned! but we can't afford to waste a loan heavily loaded with risk.

Albrighton came with high expectation and was a huge disappointment. If this fella does arrive it will be with low expectation and he may just surprise a few.
Reply
(01-13-2024, 01:21 PM)Mr Nimbus Wrote: Haven't got a pot to piss in until a new owner is confirmed,  and due to injury we are desperately short up font.

Weimann can play across the front line and he may not be the most prolific but is know to be a hard running and hard working player, he is obviously also a leader.  On a loan with an option this looks sensible business and as has been mentioned we may be offsetting.

I still get surprised by some posters.  There would be much excitement if we were linked with loaning or even buying players we obviously couldn't afford, or if some random 19 year old export arrived from a PL reserve side with zero Champ experience was mentioned! but we can't afford to waste a loan heavily loaded with risk.

Albrighton came with high expectation and was a huge disappointment.  If this fella does arrive it will be with low expectation and he may just surprise a few.

This is also a valid point. Is a playoff battle the time to be lobbing untested kids into the mix?
Reply
(01-13-2024, 01:42 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-13-2024, 01:21 PM)Mr Nimbus Wrote: Haven't got a pot to piss in until a new owner is confirmed,  and due to injury we are desperately short up font.

Weimann can play across the front line and he may not be the most prolific but is know to be a hard running and hard working player, he is obviously also a leader.  On a loan with an option this looks sensible business and as has been mentioned we may be offsetting.

I still get surprised by some posters.  There would be much excitement if we were linked with loaning or even buying players we obviously couldn't afford, or if some random 19 year old export arrived from a PL reserve side with zero Champ experience was mentioned! but we can't afford to waste a loan heavily loaded with risk.

Albrighton came with high expectation and was a huge disappointment.  If this fella does arrive it will be with low expectation and he may just surprise a few.

This is also a valid point. Is a playoff battle the time to be lobbing untested kids into the mix?

Sarmiento and Fellows want a word.
Reply
I agree. You need one or two experienced heads who can fill in numerous areas of the squad. Reach is another example. Pieters too. Dependable, but not 'sexy' enough for some. Many fans seem to think it's like playing Championship Manager or FIFA.

(01-13-2024, 01:44 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(01-13-2024, 01:42 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-13-2024, 01:21 PM)Mr Nimbus Wrote: Haven't got a pot to piss in until a new owner is confirmed,  and due to injury we are desperately short up font.

Weimann can play across the front line and he may not be the most prolific but is know to be a hard running and hard working player, he is obviously also a leader.  On a loan with an option this looks sensible business and as has been mentioned we may be offsetting.

I still get surprised by some posters.  There would be much excitement if we were linked with loaning or even buying players we obviously couldn't afford, or if some random 19 year old export arrived from a PL reserve side with zero Champ experience was mentioned! but we can't afford to waste a loan heavily loaded with risk.

Albrighton came with high expectation and was a huge disappointment.  If this fella does arrive it will be with low expectation and he may just surprise a few.

This is also a valid point. Is a playoff battle the time to be lobbing untested kids into the mix?

Sarmiento and Fellows want a word.

Fellows has promise, but is still inexperienced. He was fairly quiet v Norwich , when he came on, for example.  Sarmiento wasn't the answer at all.
Reply
(01-13-2024, 01:44 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(01-13-2024, 01:42 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-13-2024, 01:21 PM)Mr Nimbus Wrote: Haven't got a pot to piss in until a new owner is confirmed,  and due to injury we are desperately short up font.

Weimann can play across the front line and he may not be the most prolific but is know to be a hard running and hard working player, he is obviously also a leader.  On a loan with an option this looks sensible business and as has been mentioned we may be offsetting.

I still get surprised by some posters.  There would be much excitement if we were linked with loaning or even buying players we obviously couldn't afford, or if some random 19 year old export arrived from a PL reserve side with zero Champ experience was mentioned! but we can't afford to waste a loan heavily loaded with risk.

Albrighton came with high expectation and was a huge disappointment.  If this fella does arrive it will be with low expectation and he may just surprise a few.

This is also a valid point. Is a playoff battle the time to be lobbing untested kids into the mix?

Sarmiento and Fellows want a word.

Sarmiento was not an untried teenager, he had gametine for Brighton and a world cup behind him, however it took half a season to build his fitness to be ready for a regular role before throwing a wobbly and leaving us in the lurch. When he did play his impact was sporadic (with those odd moments of brilliance)

Fellows looks a great prospect, but at times so did Edward's, Leko, Harper.  He IS the untested kid we are playing so why would we bring in more?

Its Champ Manager football fandom. Money gives you the freedom to take a few risks, and we aye got none.
Reply
(01-13-2024, 01:52 PM)Mr Nimbus Wrote:
(01-13-2024, 01:44 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(01-13-2024, 01:42 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-13-2024, 01:21 PM)Mr Nimbus Wrote: Haven't got a pot to piss in until a new owner is confirmed,  and due to injury we are desperately short up font.

Weimann can play across the front line and he may not be the most prolific but is know to be a hard running and hard working player, he is obviously also a leader.  On a loan with an option this looks sensible business and as has been mentioned we may be offsetting.

I still get surprised by some posters.  There would be much excitement if we were linked with loaning or even buying players we obviously couldn't afford, or if some random 19 year old export arrived from a PL reserve side with zero Champ experience was mentioned! but we can't afford to waste a loan heavily loaded with risk.

Albrighton came with high expectation and was a huge disappointment.  If this fella does arrive it will be with low expectation and he may just surprise a few.

This is also a valid point. Is a playoff battle the time to be lobbing untested kids into the mix?

Sarmiento and Fellows want a word.

Sarmiento was not an untried teenager, he had gametine for Brighton and a world cup behind him, however it took half a season to build his fitness to be ready for a regular role before throwing a wobbly and leaving us in the lurch.  When he did play his impact was sporadic (with those odd moments of brilliance)

Fellows looks a great prospect, but at times so did Edward's, Leko, Harper.  He IS the untested kid we are playing so why would we bring in more?

Its Champ Manager football fandom.  Money gives you the freedom to take a few risks, and we aye got none.

Also a huge difference between introducing a player gradually as the season progresses and lobbing them in after January and expecting results.

Fellows’ first start of the season was only a couple of weeks ago, so it’s not as if he’s been playing regularly all year.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)