Joey Barton…
#91
(01-10-2024, 01:36 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(01-10-2024, 01:28 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Does the same apply to Rowley Village restaurant or is free speech only when it’s speech people want to hear?

That's the thing isn't it nowadays. Vocal free speech advocates pick and choose where the rules should apply if they themselves get picked upon or they don't like an opinion.

Yep.

One minute you’ll hear anyone advocating for Palestinians should be locked up, the next minute outrage that Joey Barton is being cancelled.

Which one is it cos you can’t have both?

(01-10-2024, 01:36 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: The same applies to all speech. I’d defend the right for someone to say what I don’t want to hear all day long.

If someone takes legal action then that’s his problem to deal with, but it’s got jack all to do with the government, despite what the sports minister says.

Like anything, if you don’t like it, don’t read it. I apply that to many things in life, seems to work fine.

He doesn’t “need to be stopped”. He can deal with any legal ramifications, that’s his problem.

By and large about where I sit on it
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#92
(01-10-2024, 01:28 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Does the same apply to Rowley Village restaurant or is free speech only when it’s speech people want to hear?

Don't read it don't get offended

One thing I would say about Rowley village there is a difference wanting all Israelis dead compared to calling women grass flatners .......
Reply
#93
First part i agree with.

Thing about free speech is you either have it totally or you don’t. And same logic to don’t like it, don’t read it whatever the content.

Not a fan of the views of Barton or RV personally but I’d prefer a society where people are consistent with how we approach all of this.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#94
I’m using my right to free speech to call Barton a cunt.
Reply
#95
I'm all for free speech, but openly accusing someone of being a peadophile with no reasonable grounds isn't free speech, it's called being a horrible, vile and vindictive human being.

If he does have reasonable grounds then he should go to the police with his evidence.

There is a difference between making a reasoned argument with respect, and being a disrespectful bully who spouts inane bile just for the sake of it. Unfortunately, there's too much of the latter on social media and the former is dying out.

I still maintain he needs help, he's clearly mentally unstable, but that doesn't mean I don't think he's a vile cunt.
Reply
#96
(01-10-2024, 02:42 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: I'm all for free speech, but openly accusing someone of being a peadophile with no reasonable grounds isn't free speech, it's called being a horrible, vile and vindictive human being.

Accusing somebody of paedophilia isn't free speech, and I doubt anyone would ever claim it was. It's libel and anyone he's accused would be in their rights to seek damages.

(01-10-2024, 01:55 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: First part i agree with.

Thing about free speech is you either have it totally or you don’t. And same logic to don’t like it, don’t read it whatever the content.

Not a fan of the views of Barton or RV personally but I’d prefer a society where people are consistent with how we approach all of this.

I think some people conflate freedom of speech with freedom from consequence.

We have laws in this country around hate speech, discrimination, holocaust denial, etc and when someone's speech, either online or in person, breaks those laws they are rightfully punished.

Barton hasn't broken any laws I'm aware of so far but there will be far reaching consequences in terms of reputation, future employment prospects, personal relationships, etc. Just as he is entitled to spout his views the rest of us are equally entitled to call him out on his shite, ultimately he'll be one to lose out long term. Blowhards like that don't last too long before everyone gets bored and moves on, then what's next for him? Nothing. He won't be go back to the way things were before this, that's consequence.
Reply
#97
(01-10-2024, 02:52 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-10-2024, 02:42 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: I'm all for free speech, but openly accusing someone of being a peadophile with no reasonable grounds isn't free speech, it's called being a horrible, vile and vindictive human being.

Accusing somebody of paedophilia isn't free speech, and I doubt anyone would ever claim it was. It's libel and anyone he's accused would be in their rights to seek damages.

(01-10-2024, 01:55 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: First part i agree with.

Thing about free speech is you either have it totally or you don’t. And same logic to don’t like it, don’t read it whatever the content.

Not a fan of the views of Barton or RV personally but I’d prefer a society where people are consistent with how we approach all of this.

I think some people conflate freedom of speech with freedom from consequence.

We have laws in this country around hate speech, discrimination, holocaust denial, etc and when someone's speech, either online or in person, breaks those laws they are rightfully punished.

Barton hasn't broken any laws I'm aware of so far but there will be far reaching consequences in terms of reputation, future employment prospects, personal relationships, etc. Just as he is entitled to spout his views the rest of us are equally entitled to call him out on his shite, ultimately he'll be one to lose out long term. Blowhards like that don't last too long before everyone gets bored and moves on, then what's next for him? Nothing. He won't be go back to the way things were before this, that's consequence.

Indeed, he’ll deal with the ramifications if he’s broken any laws.

But in terms of reputational danage for future employment, he’s a multimillionaire who has probably doesn’t give a toss. So I doubt the consequences will be far reaching in the slightest. No more consequences than you’ll get for calling him a cunt (I don’t disagree btw). I think it’ll make zero difference to him (aside from any legal ramifications).
Reply
#98
Not sure how "rich" he is, most footballers piss their money away and he's dramatically reduced his future earnings potential over the last few weeks.

Give it five years and we'll see how funny he thinks he still is.
Reply
#99
His pension fund alone would be unreal.....a mate of mine who was a ex keeper of a midland club ......played professional until he was kicked out for fighting someone and he has a very good pension and he wasn't a professional long like Barton.
Reply
Maybe, but I doubt it.

If he has any legal ramifications, I suspect he might regret it.

But in terms of reputation and employment, I doubt it. Probably wouldn’t have got another management job anyway.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: