Morgan Whittaker
#11
(01-02-2024, 08:48 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(01-02-2024, 12:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Yes, we need more experienced players like Barry, Livermore, Snodgrass, Kelly, Rogic, Button and Hugill

Don’t know what the point of that post is other than already winning the 2024 stupid post of the year competition. 

Livermore was excellent for a few seasons and why not lump in Gareth McAuley, signed at 31, whilst you’re at it. Hugill was a loan and we’ve had plenty of poor loans over the years. 

We could also do a list of young players as long as your arm that didn’t fulfil potential. Edwards, Harper and Leko jump to mind. Clubs who do fire sales and play kids tend to be relegated.

Poor recruitment for a multitude of reasons and stupid contracts have been the main problem as has been said, but trying to make out every experienced player signed is poor is a strange and ridiculous argument.

GMac was signed a long time before the seven listed above. My point is that most of the experienced players we have 
signed have not been very good, as we would agree that is because of poor recruitment. where we probably differ is that far too many experienced players have come for one last pay day, GMac differs from the above in that a move to us was a clear step up and the highest level that he had played at. 
 .
Reply
#12
(01-02-2024, 09:26 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(01-02-2024, 08:48 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(01-02-2024, 12:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Yes, we need more experienced players like Barry, Livermore, Snodgrass, Kelly, Rogic, Button and Hugill

Don’t know what the point of that post is other than already winning the 2024 stupid post of the year competition. 

Livermore was excellent for a few seasons and why not lump in Gareth McAuley, signed at 31, whilst you’re at it. Hugill was a loan and we’ve had plenty of poor loans over the years. 

We could also do a list of young players as long as your arm that didn’t fulfil potential. Edwards, Harper and Leko jump to mind. Clubs who do fire sales and play kids tend to be relegated.

Poor recruitment for a multitude of reasons and stupid contracts have been the main problem as has been said, but trying to make out every experienced player signed is poor is a strange and ridiculous argument.

GMac was signed a long time before the seven listed above. My point is that most of the experienced players we have 
signed have not been very good, as we would agree that is because of poor recruitment. where we probably differ is that far too many experienced players have come for one last pay day, GMac differs from the above in that a move to us was a clear step up and the highest level that he had played at. 
 .

We've simply been mismanaged by a rubbish ownership and it's not to do with age or experience. Plenty of good young uns and good old uns and plenty of bad ones at 20 or 33.

Stupid contracts have been the major issue. 

It is galling that under Dan Ashworth we had the blueprint to how a club like ours should be managed, but somehow the Chinese idiots who have overseen our demise ignored it.
Reply
#13
(01-02-2024, 09:26 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(01-02-2024, 08:48 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(01-02-2024, 12:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Yes, we need more experienced players like Barry, Livermore, Snodgrass, Kelly, Rogic, Button and Hugill

Don’t know what the point of that post is other than already winning the 2024 stupid post of the year competition. 

Livermore was excellent for a few seasons and why not lump in Gareth McAuley, signed at 31, whilst you’re at it. Hugill was a loan and we’ve had plenty of poor loans over the years. 

We could also do a list of young players as long as your arm that didn’t fulfil potential. Edwards, Harper and Leko jump to mind. Clubs who do fire sales and play kids tend to be relegated.

Poor recruitment for a multitude of reasons and stupid contracts have been the main problem as has been said, but trying to make out every experienced player signed is poor is a strange and ridiculous argument.

GMac was signed a long time before the seven listed above. My point is that most of the experienced players we have 
signed have not been very good, as we would agree that is because of poor recruitment. where we probably differ is that far too many experienced players have come for one last pay day, GMac differs from the above in that a move to us was a clear step up and the highest level that he had played at. 
 .

Spot on re GMac.  Sign players on the way up (so generally younger), not on the way down. 

My view is that no player over 30 should be signed in more than a 2-year deal, and no player over 32 should be signed on anything more than a 1-year deal.  Yes, they can be extended by a year at a time if appropriate, but our exposure is then always limited.  Some experienced players have a lot to offer on a short-term basis. 

Our daft mistake has been to bring in 30+ players on contracts which have been far too long.  Ok, some won’t come if they don’t get the security of a long-term deal, but so be it.  We cannot afford to take that risk.
Reply
#14
(01-02-2024, 09:40 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(01-02-2024, 09:26 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(01-02-2024, 08:48 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(01-02-2024, 12:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Yes, we need more experienced players like Barry, Livermore, Snodgrass, Kelly, Rogic, Button and Hugill

Don’t know what the point of that post is other than already winning the 2024 stupid post of the year competition. 

Livermore was excellent for a few seasons and why not lump in Gareth McAuley, signed at 31, whilst you’re at it. Hugill was a loan and we’ve had plenty of poor loans over the years. 

We could also do a list of young players as long as your arm that didn’t fulfil potential. Edwards, Harper and Leko jump to mind. Clubs who do fire sales and play kids tend to be relegated.

Poor recruitment for a multitude of reasons and stupid contracts have been the main problem as has been said, but trying to make out every experienced player signed is poor is a strange and ridiculous argument.

GMac was signed a long time before the seven listed above. My point is that most of the experienced players we have 
signed have not been very good, as we would agree that is because of poor recruitment. where we probably differ is that far too many experienced players have come for one last pay day, GMac differs from the above in that a move to us was a clear step up and the highest level that he had played at. 
 .

We've simply been mismanaged by a rubbish ownership and it's not to do with age or experience. Plenty of good young uns and good old uns and plenty of bad ones at 20 or 33.

Stupid contracts have been the major issue. 

It is galling that under Dan Ashworth we had the blueprint to how a club like ours should be managed, but somehow the Chinese idiots who have overseen our demise ignored it.

Ashworths blueprint was destroyed well before the Chinese took over McDonut tore that up.
Reply
#15
The blueprint for success was attracting the best people to those positions… after Ashworth left we carried on with the system under Garlic and Burton and it was bobbins.
Reply
#16
I don't know the specifics but he was definitely offered a deal to stay and chose Villa

As for which champ clubs could afford £2m at least half a dozen, the relegated sides, Boro, Cov, Ipswich, Sunderland without putting anymore thought into it than that, just look at their spending patterns

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#17
(01-02-2024, 02:02 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: We wanted Roger Wittaker, but he wouldn't leave Durham
Maybe the ship wasn`t rigged and ready in the harbour.
Reply
#18
(01-02-2024, 10:00 AM)Cuzer Wrote: I don't know the specifics but he was definitely offered a deal to stay and chose Villa

As for which champ clubs could afford £2m at least half a dozen, the relegated sides, Boro, Cov, Ipswich, Sunderland without putting anymore thought into it than that, just look at their spending patterns

Cuzer

Agreed on the relegated sides, but of the other 4 most have nearly gone bust in the past few years and Coventry do not own their own ground which limits their income.

(01-02-2024, 09:49 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-02-2024, 09:40 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(01-02-2024, 09:26 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(01-02-2024, 08:48 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(01-02-2024, 12:06 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Yes, we need more experienced players like Barry, Livermore, Snodgrass, Kelly, Rogic, Button and Hugill

Don’t know what the point of that post is other than already winning the 2024 stupid post of the year competition. 

Livermore was excellent for a few seasons and why not lump in Gareth McAuley, signed at 31, whilst you’re at it. Hugill was a loan and we’ve had plenty of poor loans over the years. 

We could also do a list of young players as long as your arm that didn’t fulfil potential. Edwards, Harper and Leko jump to mind. Clubs who do fire sales and play kids tend to be relegated.

Poor recruitment for a multitude of reasons and stupid contracts have been the main problem as has been said, but trying to make out every experienced player signed is poor is a strange and ridiculous argument.

GMac was signed a long time before the seven listed above. My point is that most of the experienced players we have 
signed have not been very good, as we would agree that is because of poor recruitment. where we probably differ is that far too many experienced players have come for one last pay day, GMac differs from the above in that a move to us was a clear step up and the highest level that he had played at. 
 .

We've simply been mismanaged by a rubbish ownership and it's not to do with age or experience. Plenty of good young uns and good old uns and plenty of bad ones at 20 or 33.

Stupid contracts have been the major issue. 

It is galling that under Dan Ashworth we had the blueprint to how a club like ours should be managed, but somehow the Chinese idiots who have overseen our demise ignored it.

Ashworths blueprint was destroyed well before the Chinese took over McDonut tore that up.

We really need someone to do the job that Ashworth did, preferably someone young who will stay for a few years
Reply
#19
Not anymore Gaz, Cov are in a much better place now financially, spent big this summer, Ellis Simms, Wright etc and also offered us good money for Mowatt and Swift, they have the potential to be active in January if needed

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#20
(01-02-2024, 11:21 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Not anymore Gaz, Cov are in a much better place now financially, spent big this summer, Ellis Simms, Wright etc and also offered us good money for Mowatt and Swift, they have the potential to be active in January if needed

Cuzer

Had significant income too though ...Hamer and Gyokeres.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)