Adam Reach
#21
(01-01-2024, 09:44 AM)Fido Wrote:
(01-01-2024, 12:33 AM)Peachy Wrote: Just playing devil's advocate here but what did Reach do the other night that Fellows couldn't have done? Anyone that has watched Fellows in the stiffs will know that he has played Full back/wing back for years, knows his defensive responsibilities, and offers us a real outlet on the counter attack with his pace. His crossing too has been brilliant. He is a very disciplined player.

I'm not knocking Reach btw. He is a solid pro who will do a job and it was a very tight game against Leeds so I can see why Carlos bought him on to keep things tight but I'm of the belief that we could still have won that game by trusting in Fellows.

Fellows is out of contract in the summer and is free to talk to anyone he wants from today. I'd hate him to think he is now behind Reach, a player who will be released himself in the summer......

I’m with you, Peach.

I don’t think Fellows is behind Reach.  Far too early to infer that. In one game, against tough opposition, CC obviously valued Reach’s vast experience to try to close out the game ahead of a lad who’s not yet started a single game. Nothing wrong with that from a tactical viewpoint. 

Let’s see what the coming weeks indicate before drawing any premature conclusions.
Reply
#22
(01-01-2024, 10:28 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: He can't pass either, although he does have a good shot on him. Agree about the comparison with Fellows

His 14th season in the Championship and the fact he has never played for a promoted side sums up
his ability, another strange signing

When we signed him he had the 3rd highest number of assists in the years prior. When played consistently he was hitting 16 G+A's for the season; he's not a world beater but he does contribute when he plays consistently.
Reply
#23
Five league goals and five assists the season before joining us, 2018-2019 is the only season in his career when he had sixteen goal involvements when he got eight of each. He's a steady player who has scored some spectacular goals but his output over the years doesn't match the stats you suggest.
Reply
#24
A more pertinent statistic is that he has never played in a side that has won promotion from the Championship.

How does Oliver Norwood measure up in your stats?
Reply
#25
(01-01-2024, 11:59 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote: Five league goals and five assists the season before joining us, 2018-2019 is the only season in his career when he had sixteen goal involvements when he got eight of each. He's a steady player who has scored some spectacular goals but his output over the years doesn't match the stats you suggest.

It wasn’t just one season. In 2017-18 he had 4 goals and 12 assists which is 16 goal involvements too. He subsequently had an injury problem and then Sheff Wed turned to shite.
Reply
#26
Well more of him this month.
Reply
#27
(01-01-2024, 12:13 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: A more pertinent statistic is that he has never played in a side that has won promotion from the Championship.

How does Oliver Norwood measure up in your stats?

It’s not a more pertinent stat because you can have good players in a bad team.

But even if it was I’m not saying he’s too good for the championship, but he is a good championship level player
Reply
#28
(01-01-2024, 12:17 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-01-2024, 11:59 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote: Five league goals and five assists the season before joining us, 2018-2019 is the only season in his career when he had sixteen goal involvements when he got eight of each. He's a steady player who has scored some spectacular goals but his output over the years doesn't match the stats you suggest.

It wasn’t just one season. In 2017-18 he had 4 goals and 12 assists which is 16 goal involvements too. He subsequently had an injury problem and then Sheff Wed turned to shite.

Apologies for missing his twelve assists five years ago. So that's two seasons where he's got a combined 16 goal involvements. I'm not knocking him as a player by the way, but it's fair to suggest his best and most productive days are likely to be behind him. Must admit I didn't realise he turns 31 next month.
Reply
#29
I think he gets far too much stick from some of our fans. He’s had a long-term injury, CC sees him in training and knows exactly what he can do.

With our full squad fit he wouldn’t make the matchday squad, but in the current situation he’s required to do a job. If we can send him out on loan (or on a free) and replace him with the saved wages then great, but I doubt that’s going to happen.
Reply
#30
Today showed that, whilst he’s an ok option to bring on when winning, to bring him on when losing is pretty pointless.
He made his name putting decent balls into the box and scoring from distance. He does neither for us. Not his fault just that his best years are behind him.
Fact that our squad is so depleted means he’s a piece of the jigsaw, but, to be honest, I would rather have got a glimpse of Higgins.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: