Brianna
#1
What possible benefit is there in naming the two children who killed her. They are going to be relased into society in a  few years, hopefully having undergone some intensive therapy and care. It's difficult to understand their mindset, but from what Ive read they are nothing approaching normal. Do we seriously want to make this any worse. The media have made money on the back of Jamie Bulger for 30 years.
Reply
#2
I think it's a discussion about punishment vs rehabilitation.

Those who want the killers named are more focused on a lifetime of punishment, and those who don't want to name them for the most part probably think they could be rehabilitated and at least deserve a chance at rehabilitation after they've done their prison time.
Reply
#3
(12-21-2023, 07:55 AM)Sliced Wrote: I think it's a discussion about punishment vs rehabilitation.

Those who want the killers named are more focused on a lifetime of punishment, and those who don't want to name them for the most part probably think they could be rehabilitated and at least deserve a chance at rehabilitation after they've done their prison time.
Lifetime of punishment for me, if bring back the death penalty for cases like this.
Reply
#4
(12-21-2023, 10:05 AM)1952 Wrote:
(12-21-2023, 07:55 AM)Sliced Wrote: I think it's a discussion about punishment vs rehabilitation.

Those who want the killers named are more focused on a lifetime of punishment, and those who don't want to name them for the most part probably think they could be rehabilitated and at least deserve a chance at rehabilitation after they've done their prison time.
Lifetime of punishment for me, if bring back the death penalty for cases like this.

I’m with you,some say rehabilitation might work, in some cases that might be right, but what about the ones it doesn’t rehabilitate and they do it again. All life is short so why should someone take it away from you.
Reply
#5
Big difference to Venables and Thompson, they were 10 years old, these two were 15 ffs, they should not be released for a very long time.
Reply
#6
I don't think any cruel fuckers like them pair deserve protection in any way shape or form.
Reply
#7
They'll be named at sentencing in Feb.

Which means we'll find out before then.
Reply
#8
I am usually pro-rehabilitation. I even think that the gradual creep upwards of minimum tariffs in life sentences is not always a good thing, especially considering the woeful conditions of our prisons.

But, for these two individuals, what they've done needs to follow them around. They knew exactly what they were doing. Someone who stabs another human being 28 times without any remorse needs to be kept far away from the rest of society for a very long time and society needs to know what they've done.
Reply
#9
Quite often have discussions with my mates and usually come to the conclusion that anyone who commits pre meditated murder is mentally unstable.

These two by the sounds of it have both got autism and quite obviously to me very ill in the head.

Not sure naming them is very fair on there families who might have been doing there best.
Reply
#10
(12-21-2023, 07:55 AM)Sliced Wrote: I think it's a discussion about punishment vs rehabilitation.

Those who want the killers named are more focused on a lifetime of punishment, and those who don't want to name them for the most part probably think they could be rehabilitated and at least deserve a chance at rehabilitation after they've done their prison time.

Ay it. 
I genuinely do not know. If it was my child I would want the very worst outcome for them, thankfully it isn't but should that change my opinion? Even after a lifetime of varied experiences, I feel no more qualified to give an answer now than I did when I was young. One thing is sure, they need removing from society for a very long time.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: