v Stoke - Ratings/The Stats
#11
(12-18-2023, 08:04 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-18-2023, 07:59 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Agree with much of this but puzzled at some of the stats.
Furlong for example, agree he had an excellent game but don't get why he made "no key passes". He set up our goal?
Townsend had a good 2nd half but was dire 1st 45. Could have done better for their goal and constantly passed the ball backwards when we had successfully played out from the back. Definitely our weak link.
Have to say Jed was MOTM, stonking performance but was run close by Kipre and as you say, maybe Furlong.

A 'key pass' is a pass that leads directly to a shot. Our goal came from a block from shot by Okay. In fact statistically, he didnt even register a Shot Creating Action as his cross got "blocked". 



But that's why you have to use stats along with any subjective analysis the game.

Have to disagree on the goal, watch it back, pal. His; body shape, positioning and level of engagement was fine. He just got 'beat' by a right shank of a cross.

No you don't "have to use the stats". Are you telling me my opinion is worthless because I haven't done a crash course in modern football bullshit speak? A better defender would have done something about that cross.

And I don't give a tuppenny one about the definition of a "Key Pass". Don't even try to tell me what a "Shot Creating Action" is. What I saw was a good performance undone by their goalie playing a blider and our weakest defender getting done, as happens to him far too often.

Seriously though, we leave ourselves far too exposed. The Stokies had far too many breakaways in the first half, with Barts and Kipper stranded on the halfway line. When you play such a dangerous game you've got to be incisive. Thinking back to Leicester's late winner, Townsend was caught completely stationary, totally out of position and indecisive when the shit hit the fan. Maybe minus 3 points is harsh, but I wouldn't give him a jot more than 6, stats or no stats.
Reply
#12
(12-18-2023, 10:36 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(12-18-2023, 08:04 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-18-2023, 07:59 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Agree with much of this but puzzled at some of the stats.
Furlong for example, agree he had an excellent game but don't get why he made "no key passes". He set up our goal?
Townsend had a good 2nd half but was dire 1st 45. Could have done better for their goal and constantly passed the ball backwards when we had successfully played out from the back. Definitely our weak link.
Have to say Jed was MOTM, stonking performance but was run close by Kipre and as you say, maybe Furlong.

A 'key pass' is a pass that leads directly to a shot. Our goal came from a block from shot by Okay. In fact statistically, he didnt even register a Shot Creating Action as his cross got "blocked". 



But that's why you have to use stats along with any subjective analysis the game.

Have to disagree on the goal, watch it back, pal. His; body shape, positioning and level of engagement was fine. He just got 'beat' by a right shank of a cross.

No you don't "have to use the stats". Are you telling me my opinion is worthless because I haven't done a crash course in modern football bullshit speak? A better defender would have done something about that cross.

And I don't give a tuppenny one about the definition of a "Key Pass". Don't even try to tell me what a "Shot Creating Action" is. What I saw was a good performance undone by their goalie playing a blider and our weakest defender getting done, as happens to him far too often.

Seriously though, we leave ourselves far too exposed. The Stokies had far too many breakaways in the first half, with Barts and Kipper stranded on the halfway line. When you play such a dangerous game you've got to be incisive. Thinking back to Leicester's late winner, Townsend was caught completely stationary, totally out of position and indecisive when the shit hit the fan. Maybe minus 3 points is harsh, but I wouldn't give him a jot more than 6, stats or no stats.

Erm... No? I haven't said that at all Chesh. In fact my sentence was clumsily constructed, so apologies for that. I should have said, "Any use of statistics should be alongside a subjective analysis for context". In
 fact my ratings are a combination of both. I tend to list my "what my eyes have seen" scores, then go through them and use the stats to either prove or disprove what my eyes have seen whilst watching the extended highlights. 

We just disagree on our left back, nothing to worry about too much, I don't think. That's what the games about.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#13
Bloody hell those scores sre very generous.....i would give wallace a 8 all the rest 6
Reply
#14
You're not getting an A* on these until ypou put some pretty graphs in.

Good stats.
Reply
#15
(12-18-2023, 11:26 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: Bloody hell those scores sre very generous.....i would give wallace a 8 all the rest 6

I agree. Furlong hasn’t been doing too badly recently but fugg me does he have his share of misplaced passes or quite often plays it behind the player running on.
Reply
#16
Furlong had some key moments re passes and recovery. However, his final touch is as subtle as a sledgehammer in a cow pat at times. Very frustrating player with the attention span of a gnat on speed.
Reply
#17
(12-19-2023, 06:39 AM)Fido Wrote:
(12-18-2023, 11:26 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: Bloody hell those scores sre very generous.....i would give wallace a 8 all the rest 6

I agree. Furlong hasn’t been doing too badly recently but fugg me does he have his share of misplaced passes or quite often plays it behind the player running on.

Boils my piss when anybody does this...
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#18
(12-19-2023, 08:38 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-19-2023, 06:39 AM)Fido Wrote:
(12-18-2023, 11:26 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: Bloody hell those scores sre very generous.....i would give wallace a 8 all the rest 6

I agree. Furlong hasn’t been doing too badly recently but fugg me does he have his share of misplaced passes or quite often plays it behind the player running on.

Boils my piss when anybody does this...

Ar. We differ on our opinions on Grady but he quite often has to receive the ball that way and puts him off his stride.
Reply
#19
(12-19-2023, 08:38 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-19-2023, 06:39 AM)Fido Wrote:
(12-18-2023, 11:26 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: Bloody hell those scores sre very generous.....i would give wallace a 8 all the rest 6

I agree. Furlong hasn’t been doing too badly recently but fugg me does he have his share of misplaced passes or quite often plays it behind the player running on.

Boils my piss when anybody does this...

Think this was the biggest frustration from Saturday and it wasn't just Grady, they were all at it, and our final ball, or the key pass in the build up ,just didn't hit the spot. If it had we would have been out of sight.
Part of the problem is not having a genuine centre forward who has that instinct to lag his run or spin out to lose a defender. BTA proved, yet again, that he can finish, his chance wasn't an easy one, but too often he gets ahead of the ball or lets the defender get goal side making it very difficult for the wide player to pick him out.
Hopefully Dike will be fit soon so that we have a different option but I would also hope that the takeover allows us to bring in someone who is a more natural goalscorer.
Reply
#20
Whilst the marks were generous, hard to disagree with the excellent comments Lurker.
It's pretty clear that Townsend has become chief spacegoat for a while now. Jed had taken the mantle but after a few good performances either side of injury, he's now in the "he's great" section. (Players are either great or shit according to a lot of our support)

Townsend had a really good game Sunday, especially 2nd half where some of his angled passing were superb. Yet on social media he has been roasted yet again for his performance driven mainly by the goal. Yet his position for the goal was about right. If the cross had been hit conventionally, it would have hit CT. But it was misfit by about 30 degrees, so it wasn't blocked.

Some of the stick he gets is ridiculous. He's a middle to top end championship left back. He has good games, average games and below average ones. He is where we are as a club.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: