Cornwall 2.7 - 4.8 Dudley
#11
(11-19-2023, 06:31 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-19-2023, 04:09 PM)NewWanker Wrote: Why did a regularly occuring thing that caused no damage even make the news?

Why did a post about a natural geological event have a reply that is not relevant as the geological activity related to that is known to lubricate faults which increases slippage in turn scaling up the effect of both natural and induced seismic activity in a scalable manner?

There's another question.

Aaaaand your point is? If the one plate goes over the other plate trapping magma between the two plates, do the plates become bread and the magma jam, and we get a jam sandwich which never even made the list?!
Reply
#12
(11-19-2023, 06:35 PM)NewWanker Wrote:
(11-19-2023, 06:31 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-19-2023, 04:09 PM)NewWanker Wrote: Why did a regularly occuring thing that caused no damage even make the news?

Why did a post about a natural geological event have a reply that is not relevant as the geological activity related to that is known to lubricate faults which increases slippage in turn scaling up the effect of both natural and induced seismic activity in a scalable manner?

There's another question.

Aaaaand your point is? If the one plate goes over the other plate trapping magma between the two plates, do the plates become bread and the magma jam, and we get a jam sandwich which never even made the list?!

My point is why did Protheroe bring up fracking on a post unrelated to fracking and which has nothing to do with the scalability of occurrence and magnitude of seismic activity related to the lubrication of faults.
Reply
#13
(11-19-2023, 06:44 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-19-2023, 06:35 PM)NewWanker Wrote:
(11-19-2023, 06:31 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-19-2023, 04:09 PM)NewWanker Wrote: Why did a regularly occuring thing that caused no damage even make the news?

Why did a post about a natural geological event have a reply that is not relevant as the geological activity related to that is known to lubricate faults which increases slippage in turn scaling up the effect of both natural and induced seismic activity in a scalable manner?

There's another question.

Aaaaand your point is? If the one plate goes over the other plate trapping magma between the two plates, do the plates become bread and the magma jam, and we get a jam sandwich which never even made the list?!

My point is why did Protheroe bring up fracking on a post unrelated to fracking and which has nothing to do with the scalability of occurrence and magnitude of seismic activity related to the lubrication of faults.

Proth turning unrelated post into bee in his bonnet shocker.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#14
YpoU knew 'eer?
Reply
#15
(11-19-2023, 07:32 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Proth turning unrelated post into bee in his bonnet shocker.

I don't have a bee in my bonnet about fracking. BB does, along with the rest of the developed world who reckon the sun and wind will keep us warm in the Winter.
Reply
#16
(11-21-2023, 12:26 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-19-2023, 07:32 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Proth turning unrelated post into bee in his bonnet shocker.

I don't have a bee in my bonnet about fracking. BB does, along with the rest of the developed world who reckon the sun and wind will keep us warm in the Winter.

Uninformed nonsense, as per everything you say about UK shale gas extraction. You picked a position 13 years ago based on soundbites from snake oil salesmen and have completely ignored all the evidence in the subsequent 13 years which points out that it does not make sense in the UK.

It does not work here. We are not the United States. Our geology is different, our reserves are different, our population density is different, our infrastructure resilience is different, our gas market is different. Hydraulic fracturing in the UK should be limited to mechanisms where it actually makes sense in the UK like geothermal wells and pumped storage which work at much lower pressures, not shale gas. And lo and behold the exact same regulations that apply to shale gas has not affected the viability of those instances of hydraulic fracturing, almost as though it's UK shale gas that's the issue rather than the technology.

Even with respect to basic geology, look at the effects of low-level seismic activity from gas fields in the Netherlands on houses in Groningen. You don't need to be able to feel the tremors for a large concentration of them to cause damage to infrastructure, and our infrastructure and our geology is much more in line with the Netherlands than it is to the United States. If you apply constant low level stress on something then it will fail, that's basic mechanics.
Reply
#17
If you apply constant low level stress on something then it will fail, that's basic mechanics.

Shall we stop all the traffic on main roads as well BB?
Reply
#18
Is it really sensible to bring that up with the effects of a lack of care in road maintenance exacerbating problems in road quality and causing more issues with cars?

Not to mention bridges, the same also applies to the railways. And that's much easier and cheaper to keep up with maintenance than buildings that haven't been designed to manage the stress you want them to be applied with.

Not really the gotcha you think it is.
Reply
#19
Fracking is constant low level stress. So is road traffic.
Reply
#20
And the constant low level stress caused by road traffic leads to material degradation which requires maintenance lest the surface of the roads deteriorates to the point where it causes constant level of stress on vehicles which in turn damages vehicles. And we as a country are experiencing that right now with the impact of neglecting road maintenance.

The key difference, which makes this a false equivalence, is that maintaining and repairing roads as well as accommodating higher stress tolerances through material development is much easier and cheaper than shoring up and repairing building foundations that were not designed to cope with that level of constant stress being applied. And if we can't even keep up with the cost of the roads how the hell are we going to keep up with the costs of buildings? Especially when shale gas extraction in the UK has a 35 year time delay from exploration and set up to extraction (and the buildings would be experiencing that constant stress in the mean time) and the deposits available for extraction are looking like fuck all in terms of market profitability after being revised downwards.

That is why the seismic limits (independently set based on recommendations of the RS/REA and backed up by the BGS through review) are what they are. We are not the US, we have much tighter allowable limits due to our geology and population density. You need only look at Groningen for the impact and costs of dealing with constantly applied stresses on buildings that weren't designed to cope with them (which has resulted in capped extraction limits towards winding down extraction).
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: