The Silent Majority
#51
(11-16-2023, 02:33 PM)Ournextstriker Wrote: When are adults gonna grow a pair and say what they believe?

Oh I can’t say what I think cos I will be shouted at and picked on online.

Do we really have a grown up population that can’t argue their position?

Wish it was that simple. Also, the context of holding a debate purely by what is written online is a different beast to a spoken discussion. The actual words only play a small part in communication, which is why so many have lost jobs and ended up in hot water over email.
I think unless you are very adept at the written word controversial topics are to be avoided, especially on forums where your identity is known.
Also the psyche of some is fragile. People have killed themselves over online abuse.
It's not really as straightforward as you say. this is good read explaining. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/08/07/fashi...tions.html

I particularly like:- Dr. Mayer noted that beyond speed, another problem with digital arguments is that people can’t detect tone, facial expression and, most of all, sarcasm. Numerous research studies have found that people try to detect these things, often looking for social cues in grammar and use of emoticons. But in a 140-character fight, that’s almost impossible.

His advice: Don't feed the Trolls.
Reply
#52
(11-16-2023, 02:16 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I sort of feel from Rich's original post this is going off kilter into a normal discussion on politics, which kind of defeats the question.
What I have found interesting is somehow there seems to be a belief amongst some in earlier threads that only those with extreme right wing views are silent as they will be found out when, as I have shown through that US academic research, and found in my own life, that's not the case.
Here's a scenario, one we know well, you could have people opposed to gay marriage, which was quite commonplace a decade ago. However, these people still exist and I know a few, who generally are older.
All I know are decent sorts and not right wing loons. The one I know very well, as he's a relation, says he believes legally gay people should have the same rights in a relationship, civil partnership, but believes marriage is purely a thing that in the whole species of man was between a man and a woman.
He's a reasonable guy, but could he get away with saying that now online and not get dog's abuse and be called a hater?
I do believe though we are in an era where a willingness to label too quickly is alienating people and fuelling the extremes. This is, as I'll reiterate once more, someone who sees myself left of centre and liberal.
Grown up discussions seem to have stopped in recent years and many just can't be doing with the slanging matches they know they'll be on the end of, so will keep their thoughts under lock and key.

I'd be more interested in why any grown adult would even need to feel an opinion on how two other grown adults pair off is any of their fookin business.

You know what they say about opinions and arseholes
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#53
(11-16-2023, 02:42 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-16-2023, 02:33 PM)Ournextstriker Wrote: When are adults gonna grow a pair and say what they believe?

Oh I can’t say what I think cos I will be shouted at and picked on online.

Do we really have a grown up population that can’t argue their position?

Wish it was that simple. Also, the context of holding a debate purely by what is written online is a different beast to a spoken discussion. The actual words only play a small part in communication, which is why so many have lost jobs and ended up in hot water over email.
I think unless you are very adept at the written word controversial topics are to be avoided, especially on forums where your identity is known.
Well if people aren’t confident in backing up their beliefs with facts and reasoned discussion it maybe best to stay silent.
Reply
#54
(11-16-2023, 02:47 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(11-16-2023, 02:16 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I sort of feel from Rich's original post this is going off kilter into a normal discussion on politics, which kind of defeats the question.
What I have found interesting is somehow there seems to be a belief amongst some in earlier threads that only those with extreme right wing views are silent as they will be found out when, as I have shown through that US academic research, and found in my own life, that's not the case.
Here's a scenario, one we know well, you could have people opposed to gay marriage, which was quite commonplace a decade ago. However, these people still exist and I know a few, who generally are older.
All I know are decent sorts and not right wing loons. The one I know very well, as he's a relation, says he believes legally gay people should have the same rights in a relationship, civil partnership, but believes marriage is purely a thing that in the whole species of man was between a man and a woman.
He's a reasonable guy, but could he get away with saying that now online and not get dog's abuse and be called a hater?
I do believe though we are in an era where a willingness to label too quickly is alienating people and fuelling the extremes. This is, as I'll reiterate once more, someone who sees myself left of centre and liberal.
Grown up discussions seem to have stopped in recent years and many just can't be doing with the slanging matches they know they'll be on the end of, so will keep their thoughts under lock and key.

I'd be more interested in why any grown adult would even need to feel an opinion on how two other grown adults pair off is any of their fookin business.

You know what they say about opinions and arseholes

There are laws and they change. This was one. We can choose many other topics. As I said mankind is a work in progress and that's why new laws are invented. However, we all have opinions, prejudices and they are shared on this platform, even about players.  This older relation has a right to express his opinion. That is what debate is about and so called freedom.

It seems some have a view that you have a right to your opinion so long as it's the one I agree with.
Reply
#55
(11-13-2023, 02:54 PM)richbaggie Wrote: Do they have a funny handshake so you know when you meet them?

That should rule out every pious Catholic...
Reply
#56
(11-16-2023, 02:47 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(11-16-2023, 02:16 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I sort of feel from Rich's original post this is going off kilter into a normal discussion on politics, which kind of defeats the question.
What I have found interesting is somehow there seems to be a belief amongst some in earlier threads that only those with extreme right wing views are silent as they will be found out when, as I have shown through that US academic research, and found in my own life, that's not the case.
Here's a scenario, one we know well, you could have people opposed to gay marriage, which was quite commonplace a decade ago. However, these people still exist and I know a few, who generally are older.
All I know are decent sorts and not right wing loons. The one I know very well, as he's a relation, says he believes legally gay people should have the same rights in a relationship, civil partnership, but believes marriage is purely a thing that in the whole species of man was between a man and a woman.
He's a reasonable guy, but could he get away with saying that now online and not get dog's abuse and be called a hater?
I do believe though we are in an era where a willingness to label too quickly is alienating people and fuelling the extremes. This is, as I'll reiterate once more, someone who sees myself left of centre and liberal.
Grown up discussions seem to have stopped in recent years and many just can't be doing with the slanging matches they know they'll be on the end of, so will keep their thoughts under lock and key.

I'd be more interested in why any grown adult would even need to feel an opinion on how two other grown adults pair off is any of their fookin business.

You know what they say about opinions and arseholes

It's the most narcissistic trait imaginable to believe you've any right to judge how anyone else chooses to live their life.

And to judge because a 2,000 year old book about a sky fairy who impregnated a virgin told you to is even more ridiculous.
Reply
#57
Post of the year lad that

(11-16-2023, 02:54 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-16-2023, 02:47 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(11-16-2023, 02:16 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I sort of feel from Rich's original post this is going off kilter into a normal discussion on politics, which kind of defeats the question.
What I have found interesting is somehow there seems to be a belief amongst some in earlier threads that only those with extreme right wing views are silent as they will be found out when, as I have shown through that US academic research, and found in my own life, that's not the case.
Here's a scenario, one we know well, you could have people opposed to gay marriage, which was quite commonplace a decade ago. However, these people still exist and I know a few, who generally are older.
All I know are decent sorts and not right wing loons. The one I know very well, as he's a relation, says he believes legally gay people should have the same rights in a relationship, civil partnership, but believes marriage is purely a thing that in the whole species of man was between a man and a woman.
He's a reasonable guy, but could he get away with saying that now online and not get dog's abuse and be called a hater?
I do believe though we are in an era where a willingness to label too quickly is alienating people and fuelling the extremes. This is, as I'll reiterate once more, someone who sees myself left of centre and liberal.
Grown up discussions seem to have stopped in recent years and many just can't be doing with the slanging matches they know they'll be on the end of, so will keep their thoughts under lock and key.

I'd be more interested in why any grown adult would even need to feel an opinion on how two other grown adults pair off is any of their fookin business.

You know what they say about opinions and arseholes

There are laws and they change. This was one. We can choose many other topics. As I said mankind is a work in progress and that's why new laws are invented. However, we all have opinions, prejudices and they are shared on this platform, even about players.  This older relation has a right to express his opinion. That is what debate is about and so called freedom.

It seems some have a view that you have a right to your opinion so long as it's the one I agree with.

I have a view that neither I or anyone else should be arrogant enough to believe how two other people constitute a private relationship is any of my or your business. So it doesn't differ for you or i
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#58
(11-16-2023, 05:07 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Post of the year lad that

(11-16-2023, 02:54 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-16-2023, 02:47 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(11-16-2023, 02:16 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I sort of feel from Rich's original post this is going off kilter into a normal discussion on politics, which kind of defeats the question.
What I have found interesting is somehow there seems to be a belief amongst some in earlier threads that only those with extreme right wing views are silent as they will be found out when, as I have shown through that US academic research, and found in my own life, that's not the case.
Here's a scenario, one we know well, you could have people opposed to gay marriage, which was quite commonplace a decade ago. However, these people still exist and I know a few, who generally are older.
All I know are decent sorts and not right wing loons. The one I know very well, as he's a relation, says he believes legally gay people should have the same rights in a relationship, civil partnership, but believes marriage is purely a thing that in the whole species of man was between a man and a woman.
He's a reasonable guy, but could he get away with saying that now online and not get dog's abuse and be called a hater?
I do believe though we are in an era where a willingness to label too quickly is alienating people and fuelling the extremes. This is, as I'll reiterate once more, someone who sees myself left of centre and liberal.
Grown up discussions seem to have stopped in recent years and many just can't be doing with the slanging matches they know they'll be on the end of, so will keep their thoughts under lock and key.

I'd be more interested in why any grown adult would even need to feel an opinion on how two other grown adults pair off is any of their fookin business.

You know what they say about opinions and arseholes

There are laws and they change. This was one. We can choose many other topics. As I said mankind is a work in progress and that's why new laws are invented. However, we all have opinions, prejudices and they are shared on this platform, even about players.  This older relation has a right to express his opinion. That is what debate is about and so called freedom.

It seems some have a view that you have a right to your opinion so long as it's the one I agree with.

I have a view that neither I or anyone else should be arrogant enough to believe how two other people constitute a private relationship is any of my or your business. So it doesn't differ for you or i

I don't have such a problem either. I agree with you. This relative, who is over 70 doesn't really either. He just has more of an issue with the term marriage.

Look up conservatism and what it means. Broadly it's about traditional and being reticent with change. There's millions in this country who are uncomfortable with the speed of change, it has been at a breakneck speed, and an anything goes ideology where it's all about the rights of the individual over the state.

I don't know your age Captain, but I guess you're under 45. Being over a decade above that I meet relations and friends etc who fall into that conservative with a small c group. I see both sides of the argument and I'd rather listen to people I disagree with as I'll learn more from them and what makes them tick. Listening to the echo chamber of ones exactly like us does no good.

As I said, I'm certainly seen as liberal to people who know me, but I'm more tolerant of people who are older and somewhat stuck in their ways.

I think we do now have a very narrow view now of what denotes acceptability in terms of views and a toxic issue with closing arguments down with labels, such as haters, fascists, racists, and homophobes. 

It's strange times over what people get offended by.
Reply
#59
Couldnt agree more about the echo chamber thing. I go out of my way to make sure I access mainstream and social media that is anything but that.

It's worth remembering what may appear to be offence is just as often more of a wind up based on just how attached to fixed notions some older generations are.

Oh and I understand what small and big C conservatism are, but thanks for the overview. It's my job to know those things.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#60
(11-17-2023, 11:30 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Couldnt agree more about the echo chamber thing. I go out of my way to make sure I access mainstream and social media that is anything but that.

It's worth remembering what may appear to be offence is just as often more of a wind up based on just how attached to fixed notions some older generations are.

Oh and I understand what small and big C conservatism are, but thanks for the overview. It's my job to know those things.

Cool, what do you do workwise?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)