Rating v Cov
#11
I read one report after the Coventry match that gave Chalobah a 3 the reporter must have watched a different match to me. He made a decent contribution while on the pitch including making the fist goal with a decent shot.
The hating of Chalobah on some social media is now a joke heist last few appearances have all been good and now we are seeing some of the qualities of why we signed him.
Reply
#12
(11-01-2023, 01:49 PM)wba13 Wrote: I read one report after the Coventry match that gave Chalobah a 3 the reporter must have watched a different match to me. He made a decent contribution while on the pitch including making the fist goal with a decent shot.
The hating of Chalobah on some social media is now a joke heist last few appearances have all been good and now we are seeing some of the qualities of why we signed him.

I think he was decent v Cov but there were a few instances where he was caught on his heels when in defensive positions. There was a situation where he didn’t track his runner into the box as well first half.
Reply
#13
(11-01-2023, 03:05 PM)Fido Wrote:
(11-01-2023, 01:49 PM)wba13 Wrote: I read one report after the Coventry match that gave Chalobah a 3 the reporter must have watched a different match to me. He made a decent contribution while on the pitch including making the fist goal with a decent shot.
The hating of Chalobah on some social media is now a joke heist last few appearances have all been good and now we are seeing some of the qualities of why we signed him.

I think he was decent v Cov but there were a few instances where he was caught on his heels when in defensive positions. There was a situation where he didn’t track his runner into the box as well first half.

Yes but 3 rating never.
Reply
#14
My thought/the stats ... Wink

So as previously mentioned the team stats, especially in possession so a very one sided game. Cov had 2 to 3 times the amount of shots, shot creating actions, progressive passes and progressive carries and as such we had to defend much more than we have recently. 

Palmer - 7 - Testament to our defense, Alex only had 1 shots on target to face and the Post Shot xG was only 0.2, he did however claim a number of crosses really well and communicated as fantastically as usual.

Kipre - 9 - Full and utter beast mode. One crucial block, but that was one of 3 important shot blocks he made as well as clocking up the most clearances (7) and 3 interceptions and 5 loose ball recoveries. He also made 3 progressive passes which in a game of very few from us was really impressive. Almost MOTM.

Bartley - 7 - Solid, dependable and predictable. Statistically he didn't have much of an output much for the same reasons as Palmer. He did however made a good amount of clearances (5), 2 tackles and 1 interception. 

Pieters - 8 - Don't shout, Cuz!   Big Grin Erik, made joint highest number of interceptions (3), a good amount of clearances (4). But extra mark comes from his stats in possession. He had almost double the touches and progressive carry distance of the other CB's. He completed the most passes in the team and double any other CB and still managed to get the ball into the final 3rd on 2 occasions. He also had 2 sot creating actions and 1 goal creating action. 

Pipa - 5 - Not the best showing by the lad for me. CC explained he played him as he wanted our 2 best attacking wingbacks. His output in possession and in the final third was almost zero. 0 key passes, 0 passes into the final 3rd/penalty area, 0 crosses and only 1 progressive pass. He only received possession 16 times and not once progressively. His defensive stats were below average also, he only won 1/3 tackles but did make 2 clearances. What was worse for me was he was the only player who looked to be out of position regularly, and this probably explains why Kipre made so many tackles and blocked shots.

Okay - 9 - Defensive masterclass by Okay. Joint highest number of interceptions (3), 4 clearances made, and 3 interceptions, but more importantly he regained lose balls more than anyone (8). His screening in front of the back 3 was vital to us staying in the game first half. When he turned the ball over he tried to pass progressively (2) with him passing into the final 3rd more than anyone else (4), he was also 2nd only to Erik for the number of passes made. Almost MOTM.

Mowatt - 6 - Defensively he was great. He won his tackles (2/3), block and intercepted 4 passes and made a couple of clearances. Where he lost marks for me was his on the ball performance. He failed to help us progress through the pitch as he has been doing. He made 0 progressive receives, and only 2 progressive carries, he also only made 1 progressive pass, only finding a player in the final 3rd on 2 occasions. As this is his main job in our midfield he scores low for me. Cant fault his graft mind.

Chalobah - 7 - Jekyll and Hyde performance from Nate. In only 52 minutes he managed to make as many tackles as our other midfielders, and covered so much ground and carried the ball, too. He also was the only CM who had a shot creating action and a goal creating action with that thunder bolt of a shot. But where he looses marks is his inability to get into the game enough. He made less touches per 90 than his counterparts and some poor decision making when carrying the ball. Again cant fault the graft and his decent form continues.

Phillips - 10 - MOTM - Best performance of any player, all season. Firstly, a wonderful assist, gets him a clear mark added on alone. He then scored perfectly in every other area. Highest number of shot creating actions (4), most tackles and tackles won (3/5), 3 clearances and about 300 miles covered. In possession, he made the 4/5 of the teams key passes and the highest number of progressive receives in the team (4). He also showed real versatility by switching positions without his standards dropping. Just incredible, Matty.

Wallace - 7 - Better by Jed last night. Grafted as always but then also made the highest number of progressive carries in the team (4), which helped alleviate some pressure first half, he also made 4 tackles. He just isn't quite contributing enough offensively. None of his carries or passes were into the final 3rd or penalty area and didn't once take his man on. He also only created one shot action.

Grady - 8 - Good display both on and off the ball by Grady, both upfront and in that deeper role second half. As always he both attempted and completed the most take-on's for us (2/5), made the most carries (30) and the joint highest number of progressive passes (3) which is really impressive from such a forward position. He also scored a great forwards goal.

Subs: 

BTA - 7 - Its so good to see BTA in his proper role. Coming off the bench against a tiring team, and running them ragged. Gets a mark for the fact that in his 40-odd minutes , in possession, he made the same number of take-ons as Matty (2), shot creating actions as Grady (2) and progressive receives as Jed (3) but he did so in and around their box. Also what a finish, eh? But he loses one mark for the 2 mindless runs he made when we broke, and the fact he never squared it to Grady for a tap in after some great work. Hopefully we can get our forwards back so he can be an impact sub more often than not. 

Townsend - 6 - Did his job well when he replaced Jed. Added some defensive nous when needed which is highlighted by the 3 clearances he made in his half hour. Aside form that nothing to report. 

Molumby/Furlong/Fellows - Nothing to report. Just added some fresh legs. 


CC - 9 - Brilliant game management. Even though I still think the balance was off in midfield I could see what he was trying to do shape wise with the choice of wingbacks and the 2 false 9s, so I will excuse it. But what was so good was the speed at which he changed it second half, and got it bang on. More of that please Carlos.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#15
(11-01-2023, 11:56 AM)Cuzer Wrote:
(11-01-2023, 07:39 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-01-2023, 02:39 AM)rickbaggie Wrote:
(10-31-2023, 08:38 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Was one done? Went last night and bar 15 in the first half we dropped a little deep and invited them I thought it was an excellent away performance 

Palmer 7 Couple of routine saves, claimed crosses well, relatively untroubled

Pippa 7 Surprise inclusion but tidy enough and thought he defended well, sloppy once or twice in possession 

Phillips 9* Even without the world class assist I thought he was fantastic, that left footed cross he put in early on was tremendous and was begging to be tapped home. So good defensively as well, worked back to help Pieters on every occasion 

Kipre 8 Excellent again, solid and good with the ball, great to see him fit and well

Bartley 8 More physical which I like to see from him, good in the air and covered well

Pieters 7 Played well, couple of times loose in possession but defended well and looked to pass forward more than of late which was good to see

Okay 8 Thought he was excellent, time on the ball he creates goes so unoticed and constantly kept us ticking over as well as breaking up so many Potential Coventry attacks

Mowatt 7 Great shift, set pieces a mixed bag but never stopped all evening 

Chalobah 7 Another tidy performance, covered a lot of ground and always showed for the ball which is good to see

Wallace 7 Couldn’t fault the effort or work rate, looked so much better when he dropped a bit deeper though after BTA came on

Grady 8 Just that touch of class at all times, so quickly makes space with his quick feet. His passing also is criminally under rated, great to see him playing well and enjoying his football 

Subs

Townsend 7 Solid

BTA 8 Excellent, BTA with confidence and in full flow was on display tonight, good to see him run in behind more often, than he certainly does at home. Spun the defenders well and held up the ball. Impressive 

Molumby 7 Usual energetic performance 

Furlong 7 Slotted in fine, surprising omission 

Great win, be fantastic if we can follow it up v Dull at the weekend

Jayden Philogene, 5m, what a steal, sort of player I’d have loved here

Was always the brightest prospect in the seal academy whenever I had the misfortune to see them. Amazed the Vile let him go after his excellent season at Cardiff last year and he will certainly go on to play at a higher level, need to shackle him Saturday for sure

Cuzer

But what did your stat pack show?  Smile

I'll have a nosey at lunch   Wink

However, statistically as a team, in possession it was a massacre. But off the ball is another matter. So actually, this is a game for your eyes. Because positioning, shape and tactical discipline is hard to breakdown in stats as it is a qualitative thing. 

I do think, however that a few of those marks are maybe 1 too high.

Exactly, my eyes are my stat pack! :-)

I'd be very harsh to give anybody a 6 on that away showing, it was tactically spot on for me, as I said bar 15 in the first half where we got a tad deep

Agree re the sell on clauses etc with the Villa players by the way, covering their bases clearly but they've let a bit of talent go IMO

Cuzer

(11-01-2023, 07:21 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: My thought/the stats ... Wink

So as previously mentioned the team stats, especially in possession so a very one sided game. Cov had 2 to 3 times the amount of shots, shot creating actions, progressive passes and progressive carries and as such we had to defend much more than we have recently. 

Palmer - 7 - Testament to our defense, Alex only had 1 shots on target to face and the Post Shot xG was only 0.2, he did however claim a number of crosses really well and communicated as fantastically as usual.

Kipre - 9 - Full and utter beast mode. One crucial block, but that was one of 3 important shot blocks he made as well as clocking up the most clearances (7) and 3 interceptions and 5 loose ball recoveries. He also made 3 progressive passes which in a game of very few from us was really impressive. Almost MOTM.

Bartley - 7 - Solid, dependable and predictable. Statistically he didn't have much of an output much for the same reasons as Palmer. He did however made a good amount of clearances (5), 2 tackles and 1 interception. 

Pieters - 8 - Don't shout, Cuz!   Big Grin Erik, made joint highest number of interceptions (3), a good amount of clearances (4). But extra mark comes from his stats in possession. He had almost double the touches and progressive carry distance of the other CB's. He completed the most passes in the team and double any other CB and still managed to get the ball into the final 3rd on 2 occasions. He also had 2 sot creating actions and 1 goal creating action. 

Pipa - 5 - Not the best showing by the lad for me. CC explained he played him as he wanted our 2 best attacking wingbacks. His output in possession and in the final third was almost zero. 0 key passes, 0 passes into the final 3rd/penalty area, 0 crosses and only 1 progressive pass. He only received possession 16 times and not once progressively. His defensive stats were below average also, he only won 1/3 tackles but did make 2 clearances. What was worse for me was he was the only player who looked to be out of position regularly, and this probably explains why Kipre made so many tackles and blocked shots.

Okay - 9 - Defensive masterclass by Okay. Joint highest number of interceptions (3), 4 clearances made, and 3 interceptions, but more importantly he regained lose balls more than anyone (8). His screening in front of the back 3 was vital to us staying in the game first half. When he turned the ball over he tried to pass progressively (2) with him passing into the final 3rd more than anyone else (4), he was also 2nd only to Erik for the number of passes made. Almost MOTM.

Mowatt - 6 - Defensively he was great. He won his tackles (2/3), block and intercepted 4 passes and made a couple of clearances. Where he lost marks for me was his on the ball performance. He failed to help us progress through the pitch as he has been doing. He made 0 progressive receives, and only 2 progressive carries, he also only made 1 progressive pass, only finding a player in the final 3rd on 2 occasions. As this is his main job in our midfield he scores low for me. Cant fault his graft mind.

Chalobah - 7 - Jekyll and Hyde performance from Nate. In only 52 minutes he managed to make as many tackles as our other midfielders, and covered so much ground and carried the ball, too. He also was the only CM who had a shot creating action and a goal creating action with that thunder bolt of a shot. But where he looses marks is his inability to get into the game enough. He made less touches per 90 than his counterparts and some poor decision making when carrying the ball. Again cant fault the graft and his decent form continues.

Phillips - 10 - MOTM - Best performance of any player, all season. Firstly, a wonderful assist, gets him a clear mark added on alone. He then scored perfectly in every other area. Highest number of shot creating actions (4), most tackles and tackles won (3/5), 3 clearances and about 300 miles covered. In possession, he made the 4/5 of the teams key passes and the highest number of progressive receives in the team (4). He also showed real versatility by switching positions without his standards dropping. Just incredible, Matty.

Wallace - 7 - Better by Jed last night. Grafted as always but then also made the highest number of progressive carries in the team (4), which helped alleviate some pressure first half, he also made 4 tackles. He just isn't quite contributing enough offensively. None of his carries or passes were into the final 3rd or penalty area and didn't once take his man on. He also only created one shot action.

Grady - 8 - Good display both on and off the ball by Grady, both upfront and in that deeper role second half. As always he both attempted and completed the most take-on's for us (2/5), made the most carries (30) and the joint highest number of progressive passes (3) which is really impressive from such a forward position. He also scored a great forwards goal.

Subs: 

BTA - 7 - Its so good to see BTA in his proper role. Coming off the bench against a tiring team, and running them ragged. Gets a mark for the fact that in his 40-odd minutes , in possession, he made the same number of take-ons as Matty (2), shot creating actions as Grady (2) and progressive receives as Jed (3) but he did so in and around their box. Also what a finish, eh? But he loses one mark for the 2 mindless runs he made when we broke, and the fact he never squared it to Grady for a tap in after some great work. Hopefully we can get our forwards back so he can be an impact sub more often than not. 

Townsend - 6 - Did his job well when he replaced Jed. Added some defensive nous when needed which is highlighted by the 3 clearances he made in his half hour. Aside form that nothing to report. 

Molumby/Furlong/Fellows - Nothing to report. Just added some fresh legs. 


CC - 9 - Brilliant game management. Even though I still think the balance was off in midfield I could see what he was trying to do shape wise with the choice of wingbacks and the 2 false 9s, so I will excuse it. But what was so good was the speed at which he changed it second half, and got it bang on. More of that please Carlos.

As ever, excellent read Lurker.

Can only think CC wanted Mowatt to sit a little deeper as Chalobah has the most pace of the three to get back given how much speed the Cov side have. I think Bruce used him in that holding role post Val so it’s something he can do (not that Bruce should ever be the barometer of a players’ positional ability….)
Reply
#16
Yeh he definitely played deep with Okay. To be fair he has done more often that not. It's just he didn't have the same influence on the ball yesterday. But to be fair, we didn't exactly have much of the game generally.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#17
(11-01-2023, 09:23 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Yeh he definitely played deep with Okay. To be fair he has done more often that not. It's just he didn't have the same influence on the ball yesterday. But to be fair, we didn't exactly have much of the game generally.

Mind you none of them had the same influence on the ball yesterday, because we played on Monday. Rolleyes Smile Smile
Reply
#18
(11-01-2023, 10:15 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(11-01-2023, 09:23 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Yeh he definitely played deep with Okay. To be fair he has done more often that not. It's just he didn't have the same influence on the ball yesterday. But to be fair, we didn't exactly have much of the game generally.

Mind you none of them had the same influence on the ball yesterday, because we played on Monday. Rolleyes Smile Smile

Christ... it's been a long couple of days  Big Grin
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#19
No issue at all with Pieters on Monday Lurker, thought it was one of his better performances, especially of late

Cuzed
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#20
(11-01-2023, 10:17 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-01-2023, 10:15 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(11-01-2023, 09:23 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Yeh he definitely played deep with Okay. To be fair he has done more often that not. It's just he didn't have the same influence on the ball yesterday. But to be fair, we didn't exactly have much of the game generally.

Mind you none of them had the same influence on the ball yesterday, because we played on Monday. Rolleyes Smile Smile

Christ... it's been a long couple of days  Big Grin

I know loved your right up and agree. For me it was a Corberan master class.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)