Rating v Cov
#1
Was one done? Went last night and bar 15 in the first half we dropped a little deep and invited them I thought it was an excellent away performance 

Palmer 7 Couple of routine saves, claimed crosses well, relatively untroubled

Pippa 7 Surprise inclusion but tidy enough and thought he defended well, sloppy once or twice in possession 

Phillips 9* Even without the world class assist I thought he was fantastic, that left footed cross he put in early on was tremendous and was begging to be tapped home. So good defensively as well, worked back to help Pieters on every occasion 

Kipre 8 Excellent again, solid and good with the ball, great to see him fit and well

Bartley 8 More physical which I like to see from him, good in the air and covered well

Pieters 7 Played well, couple of times loose in possession but defended well and looked to pass forward more than of late which was good to see

Okay 8 Thought he was excellent, time on the ball he creates goes so unoticed and constantly kept us ticking over as well as breaking up so many Potential Coventry attacks

Mowatt 7 Great shift, set pieces a mixed bag but never stopped all evening 

Chalobah 7 Another tidy performance, covered a lot of ground and always showed for the ball which is good to see

Wallace 7 Couldn’t fault the effort or work rate, looked so much better when he dropped a bit deeper though after BTA came on

Grady 8 Just that touch of class at all times, so quickly makes space with his quick feet. His passing also is criminally under rated, great to see him playing well and enjoying his football 

Subs

Townsend 7 Solid

BTA 8 Excellent, BTA with confidence and in full flow was on display tonight, good to see him run in behind more often, than he certainly does at home. Spun the defenders well and held up the ball. Impressive 

Molumby 7 Usual energetic performance 

Furlong 7 Slotted in fine, surprising omission 

Great win, be fantastic if we can follow it up v Dull at the weekend

Jayden Philogene, 5m, what a steal, sort of player I’d have loved here

Was always the brightest prospect in the seal academy whenever I had the misfortune to see them. Amazed the Vile let him go after his excellent season at Cardiff last year and he will certainly go on to play at a higher level, need to shackle him Saturday for sure

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#2
(10-31-2023, 08:38 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Was one done? Went last night and bar 15 in the first half we dropped a little deep and invited them I thought it was an excellent away performance 

Palmer 7 Couple of routine saves, claimed crosses well, relatively untroubled

Pippa 7 Surprise inclusion but tidy enough and thought he defended well, sloppy once or twice in possession 

Phillips 9* Even without the world class assist I thought he was fantastic, that left footed cross he put in early on was tremendous and was begging to be tapped home. So good defensively as well, worked back to help Pieters on every occasion 

Kipre 8 Excellent again, solid and good with the ball, great to see him fit and well

Bartley 8 More physical which I like to see from him, good in the air and covered well

Pieters 7 Played well, couple of times loose in possession but defended well and looked to pass forward more than of late which was good to see

Okay 8 Thought he was excellent, time on the ball he creates goes so unoticed and constantly kept us ticking over as well as breaking up so many Potential Coventry attacks

Mowatt 7 Great shift, set pieces a mixed bag but never stopped all evening 

Chalobah 7 Another tidy performance, covered a lot of ground and always showed for the ball which is good to see

Wallace 7 Couldn’t fault the effort or work rate, looked so much better when he dropped a bit deeper though after BTA came on

Grady 8 Just that touch of class at all times, so quickly makes space with his quick feet. His passing also is criminally under rated, great to see him playing well and enjoying his football 

Subs

Townsend 7 Solid

BTA 8 Excellent, BTA with confidence and in full flow was on display tonight, good to see him run in behind more often, than he certainly does at home. Spun the defenders well and held up the ball. Impressive 

Molumby 7 Usual energetic performance 

Furlong 7 Slotted in fine, surprising omission 

Great win, be fantastic if we can follow it up v Dull at the weekend

Jayden Philogene, 5m, what a steal, sort of player I’d have loved here

Was always the brightest prospect in the seal academy whenever I had the misfortune to see them. Amazed the Vile let him go after his excellent season at Cardiff last year and he will certainly go on to play at a higher level, need to shackle him Saturday for sure

Cuzer

Tbf to Villa Cuz, now they’ve got all the Spaniards behind the scenes they’re adopting the Barca/Real models of selling with buy backs and big sell ons… Ramsey, Archer, Philogene all surprising sales this summer but they wouldn’t have got the consistent game time they needed. Looks an exciting player though.
Reply
#3
Agree with much of that Cuzer.

Phillips definitely my MOTM too. Let's hope we can keep him fit for the rest of the season, as we struggle to replace him when he's out.

Agree that no one was under a seven, and that usually means a positive result.
Reply
#4
(10-31-2023, 08:38 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Was one done? Went last night and bar 15 in the first half we dropped a little deep and invited them I thought it was an excellent away performance 

Palmer 7 Couple of routine saves, claimed crosses well, relatively untroubled

Pippa 7 Surprise inclusion but tidy enough and thought he defended well, sloppy once or twice in possession 

Phillips 9* Even without the world class assist I thought he was fantastic, that left footed cross he put in early on was tremendous and was begging to be tapped home. So good defensively as well, worked back to help Pieters on every occasion 

Kipre 8 Excellent again, solid and good with the ball, great to see him fit and well

Bartley 8 More physical which I like to see from him, good in the air and covered well

Pieters 7 Played well, couple of times loose in possession but defended well and looked to pass forward more than of late which was good to see

Okay 8 Thought he was excellent, time on the ball he creates goes so unoticed and constantly kept us ticking over as well as breaking up so many Potential Coventry attacks

Mowatt 7 Great shift, set pieces a mixed bag but never stopped all evening 

Chalobah 7 Another tidy performance, covered a lot of ground and always showed for the ball which is good to see

Wallace 7 Couldn’t fault the effort or work rate, looked so much better when he dropped a bit deeper though after BTA came on

Grady 8 Just that touch of class at all times, so quickly makes space with his quick feet. His passing also is criminally under rated, great to see him playing well and enjoying his football 

Subs

Townsend 7 Solid

BTA 8 Excellent, BTA with confidence and in full flow was on display tonight, good to see him run in behind more often, than he certainly does at home. Spun the defenders well and held up the ball. Impressive 

Molumby 7 Usual energetic performance 

Furlong 7 Slotted in fine, surprising omission 

Great win, be fantastic if we can follow it up v Dull at the weekend

Jayden Philogene, 5m, what a steal, sort of player I’d have loved here

Was always the brightest prospect in the seal academy whenever I had the misfortune to see them. Amazed the Vile let him go after his excellent season at Cardiff last year and he will certainly go on to play at a higher level, need to shackle him Saturday for sure

Cuzer

But what did your stat pack show?  Smile
Reply
#5
(11-01-2023, 02:39 AM)rickbaggie Wrote:
(10-31-2023, 08:38 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Was one done? Went last night and bar 15 in the first half we dropped a little deep and invited them I thought it was an excellent away performance 

Palmer 7 Couple of routine saves, claimed crosses well, relatively untroubled

Pippa 7 Surprise inclusion but tidy enough and thought he defended well, sloppy once or twice in possession 

Phillips 9* Even without the world class assist I thought he was fantastic, that left footed cross he put in early on was tremendous and was begging to be tapped home. So good defensively as well, worked back to help Pieters on every occasion 

Kipre 8 Excellent again, solid and good with the ball, great to see him fit and well

Bartley 8 More physical which I like to see from him, good in the air and covered well

Pieters 7 Played well, couple of times loose in possession but defended well and looked to pass forward more than of late which was good to see

Okay 8 Thought he was excellent, time on the ball he creates goes so unoticed and constantly kept us ticking over as well as breaking up so many Potential Coventry attacks

Mowatt 7 Great shift, set pieces a mixed bag but never stopped all evening 

Chalobah 7 Another tidy performance, covered a lot of ground and always showed for the ball which is good to see

Wallace 7 Couldn’t fault the effort or work rate, looked so much better when he dropped a bit deeper though after BTA came on

Grady 8 Just that touch of class at all times, so quickly makes space with his quick feet. His passing also is criminally under rated, great to see him playing well and enjoying his football 

Subs

Townsend 7 Solid

BTA 8 Excellent, BTA with confidence and in full flow was on display tonight, good to see him run in behind more often, than he certainly does at home. Spun the defenders well and held up the ball. Impressive 

Molumby 7 Usual energetic performance 

Furlong 7 Slotted in fine, surprising omission 

Great win, be fantastic if we can follow it up v Dull at the weekend

Jayden Philogene, 5m, what a steal, sort of player I’d have loved here

Was always the brightest prospect in the seal academy whenever I had the misfortune to see them. Amazed the Vile let him go after his excellent season at Cardiff last year and he will certainly go on to play at a higher level, need to shackle him Saturday for sure

Cuzer

But what did your stat pack show?  Smile

I'll have a nosey at lunch   Wink

However, statistically as a team, in possession it was a massacre. But off the ball is another matter. So actually, this is a game for your eyes. Because positioning, shape and tactical discipline is hard to breakdown in stats as it is a qualitative thing. 

I do think, however that a few of those marks are maybe 1 too high.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#6
"positioning, shape and tactical discipline is hard to breakdown in stats as it is a qualitative thing. "

That acknowledgement alone and the fact that it was so well delivered throughout tells you the marks are spot on
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#7
(11-01-2023, 07:39 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-01-2023, 02:39 AM)rickbaggie Wrote:
(10-31-2023, 08:38 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Was one done? Went last night and bar 15 in the first half we dropped a little deep and invited them I thought it was an excellent away performance 

Palmer 7 Couple of routine saves, claimed crosses well, relatively untroubled

Pippa 7 Surprise inclusion but tidy enough and thought he defended well, sloppy once or twice in possession 

Phillips 9* Even without the world class assist I thought he was fantastic, that left footed cross he put in early on was tremendous and was begging to be tapped home. So good defensively as well, worked back to help Pieters on every occasion 

Kipre 8 Excellent again, solid and good with the ball, great to see him fit and well

Bartley 8 More physical which I like to see from him, good in the air and covered well

Pieters 7 Played well, couple of times loose in possession but defended well and looked to pass forward more than of late which was good to see

Okay 8 Thought he was excellent, time on the ball he creates goes so unoticed and constantly kept us ticking over as well as breaking up so many Potential Coventry attacks

Mowatt 7 Great shift, set pieces a mixed bag but never stopped all evening 

Chalobah 7 Another tidy performance, covered a lot of ground and always showed for the ball which is good to see

Wallace 7 Couldn’t fault the effort or work rate, looked so much better when he dropped a bit deeper though after BTA came on

Grady 8 Just that touch of class at all times, so quickly makes space with his quick feet. His passing also is criminally under rated, great to see him playing well and enjoying his football 

Subs

Townsend 7 Solid

BTA 8 Excellent, BTA with confidence and in full flow was on display tonight, good to see him run in behind more often, than he certainly does at home. Spun the defenders well and held up the ball. Impressive 

Molumby 7 Usual energetic performance 

Furlong 7 Slotted in fine, surprising omission 

Great win, be fantastic if we can follow it up v Dull at the weekend

Jayden Philogene, 5m, what a steal, sort of player I’d have loved here

Was always the brightest prospect in the seal academy whenever I had the misfortune to see them. Amazed the Vile let him go after his excellent season at Cardiff last year and he will certainly go on to play at a higher level, need to shackle him Saturday for sure

Cuzer

But what did your stat pack show?  Smile

I'll have a nosey at lunch   Wink

However, statistically as a team, in possession it was a massacre. But off the ball is another matter. So actually, this is a game for your eyes. Because positioning, shape and tactical discipline is hard to breakdown in stats as it is a qualitative thing. 

I do think, however that a few of those marks are maybe 1 too high.

Exactly, my eyes are my stat pack! :-)

I'd be very harsh to give anybody a 6 on that away showing, it was tactically spot on for me, as I said bar 15 in the first half where we got a tad deep

Agree re the sell on clauses etc with the Villa players by the way, covering their bases clearly but they've let a bit of talent go IMO

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#8
Sadly Cuz the fishy fuggers have signed some talent too!
Reply
#9
I'd say Cuzers marks are spot on there, how I saw it too.
Reply
#10
Also don't know how noticed it was by others, but Chalobah made a few really great tackles to recover others lapses or wrong decisions when we were under the cosh, covered a lot of ground and stopped them really hurting us.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: