Has the EU ended the Tory Party?
#31
(10-13-2023, 09:21 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(10-13-2023, 07:19 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-13-2023, 06:50 AM)Pontificator Wrote: If the eleectorate had walked into the polling booth with full fat PR on offer it would have been rejected - end of

That is true.

But they weren't   so this is just speculation.

There is evidence so it is not speculation. The electorate chose to maintain the status quo FFS
Reply
#32
(10-13-2023, 09:34 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(10-13-2023, 09:21 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(10-13-2023, 07:19 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-13-2023, 06:50 AM)Pontificator Wrote: If the eleectorate had walked into the polling booth with full fat PR on offer it would have been rejected - end of

That is true.

But they weren't   so this is just speculation.

There is evidence so it is not speculation. The electorate chose to maintain the status quo FFS

I thought it was a heavily watered down version of PR that was offered, hence it didn't seem to have any real benefit or change involved. Might be mistaken though.
Reply
#33
(10-13-2023, 09:45 AM)Fido Wrote:
(10-13-2023, 09:34 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(10-13-2023, 09:21 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(10-13-2023, 07:19 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-13-2023, 06:50 AM)Pontificator Wrote: If the eleectorate had walked into the polling booth with full fat PR on offer it would have been rejected - end of

That is true.

But they weren't   so this is just speculation.

There is evidence so it is not speculation. The electorate chose to maintain the status quo FFS

I thought it was a heavily watered down version of PR that was offered, hence it didn't seem to have any real benefit or change involved. Might be mistaken though.

It's not PR, AV doesn't tend to proportionality so it's explicitly not proportional representation. If anything it is often less proportional than PR, as demonstrated by several Australian general elections.
Reply
#34
Then why did the Liberal Democrats agree to it being the basis for the referendum BB?
Reply
#35
Because Danny Alexander and Nick Clegg naively thought that pandering to Labour's preferred electoral system going back to the 1920s would mean Labour would come out in support of it, which didn't happen.

The only good thing about AV is that it doesn't have a spoiler effect, that's it. But it's not proportional.
Reply
#36
(10-13-2023, 02:54 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Then why did the Liberal Democrats agree to it being the basis for the referendum BB?

A good question. 

I suspect they were not very good at negotiating. 

Also they might have calculated that AV would be good for them. In any seat where they were second and the first candidate did not secure over 50% of the votes, they had a very good chance of winning. 

And to reiterate AV is not a type of PR. In my view it is a worse system than FPTP.

In the referendum the choice the electorate was given the choice between FPTP and AV, I think they made the write choice.

But let's be clear they were not offered any form of PR. They may well have stuck with the status quo if they had been given that choice, but that remains speculation.
Reply
#37
Have we got an archive of the AV referendum thread on here? I'd love to read some of the revisionism.
Reply
#38
A proportional voting system is a defined thing, AV does not tend to proportionality.

This really isn't up for debate. AV is not a type of PR. I don't know why FPTP obsessives lie that it is.
Reply
#39
If it walks like a duck, talks like a duck, it my be any of these, Tufted duck, long tailed duck, ruddy duck, mallard, mandarin duck, eider duck but it’s still a fucking duck and the voters know it and they didn’t want it- end of

There is more of a PR obsession than a FPTP obsession- factamundo
Reply
#40
It doesn't walk or talk like a duck because it doesn't tend to proportionality, which is the only defining characteristic of PR.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)