Mrs Chalobah…
(10-11-2023, 12:24 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: Until the mindset of Palistinans change and not teach their kids to hate Jews from birth nothing will change . They want to kill them all it's in there DNA .

https://twitter.com/raggedtp/status/1712..._PoDIO4aiQ

I think you can safely say both sides are like this.
Reply
(10-11-2023, 03:43 PM)Squid Wrote: Firstly, Israel does not recognised East Jerusalem as a separate entity. Again, in contravention of international law, it annexed in 1967 and it views Jerusalem as the "undivided, eternal capital" of Israel.

I am pleased you are looking at the Human Rights Watch website. Here is a 2021 summary titled "A Threshold Crossed
Israeli Authorities and the Crimes of Apartheid and Persecution"
https://www.hrw.org/report/2021/04/27/th...ersecution

I don't think there are easy answers, but mass bombing of Gaza (and it is mass bombing, as the media pictures clearly show) will not solve any issues, but will just increase support for Hamas, much as Bloody Sunday lead to PIRA recruitment soaring.

East Jerusalem was part of Jordan before the Arabs picked a fight again in 1967. Was Jordan also in contravention of international law having annexed Jerusalem itself in 1948? Were the Brits before them, or the Ottomans for 500 years before that, or the Romans? It seems there are different rules depending on who's doing the annexing.

Jerusalem has never belonged to any sovereign state for long, so how can it be annexed? It's as much a part of Israel as it is a part of Jordan of even some made up country of Palestine that never existed.

If Hamas aggression and the inevitable response it brings genuinely leads to more support from Gazans for Hamas then they're genuinely signing their own suicide note. Perhaps Gazans could have risen up against Hamas at some point since electing a fascist terrorist organisation - but maybe that's not so easy when Hamas governs Gaza with an iron fist and treats its own citizens with far more contempt than they'd receive in Israel proper.  

If you believe what HRW says about Israel, and there is truth in that Report - then equally you ought to believe how vile Hamas is, and how it is they that are harming the people the purport to stand for as an Iranian puppet regime.

It's very clear to me what side the world ought to be on.
Reply
(10-11-2023, 07:53 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-11-2023, 03:43 PM)Squid Wrote: Firstly, Israel does not recognised East Jerusalem as a separate entity. Again, in contravention of international law, it annexed in 1967 and it views Jerusalem as the "undivided, eternal capital" of Israel.

I am pleased you are looking at the Human Rights Watch website. Here is a 2021 summary titled "A Threshold Crossed
Israeli Authorities and the Crimes of Apartheid and Persecution"
https://www.hrw.org/report/2021/04/27/th...ersecution

I don't think there are easy answers, but mass bombing of Gaza (and it is mass bombing, as the media pictures clearly show) will not solve any issues, but will just increase support for Hamas, much as Bloody Sunday lead to PIRA recruitment soaring.

East Jerusalem was part of Jordan before the Arabs picked a fight again in 1967. Was Jordan also in contravention of international law having annexed Jerusalem itself in 1948? Were the Brits before them, or the Ottomans for 500 years before that, or the Romans? It seems there are different rules depending on who's doing the annexing.

Jerusalem has never belonged to any sovereign state for long, so how can it be annexed? It's as much a part of Israel as it is a part of Jordan of even some made up country of Palestine that never existed.

If Hamas aggression and the inevitable response it brings genuinely leads to more support from Gazans for Hamas then they're genuinely signing their own suicide note. Perhaps Gazans could have risen up against Hamas at some point since electing a fascist terrorist organisation - but maybe that's not so easy when Hamas governs Gaza with an iron fist and treats its own citizens with far more contempt than they'd receive in Israel proper.  

If you believe what HRW says about Israel, and there is truth in that Report - then equally you ought to believe how vile Hamas is, and how it is they that are harming the people the purport to stand for as an Iranian puppet regime.

It's very clear to me what side the world ought to be on.

Most of the powerful countries in the world are on Israel's side and have been for decades.

Yet there's still no peace for Palestinian or Israeli. 

Maybe because backing one side over the other isn't the answer
Reply
Might aswell say it religion of peace at it .
Reply
(10-11-2023, 03:58 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote: I don`t pretend to have any solution, or , TBH, any hope that this will get settled anytime soon. This world is seriously fucked. A lad I work with, of Irish descent, goes over a couple of times a year to visit family. With a black country accent, he is looked at suspiciously by some locals.Likewise, trouble again between Serbia / Kosovo. Still arguing over stuff that happened hundreds of years ago. Us and the Germans had two world wars, millions died.  Not all Germans are evil, after a while, we actually became friends / allies and have, generally, got on since.

I read something last year , after Russia invaded Ukraine, that there are 42 armed conflicts going on around the world. This is the story of mankind and it won’t ever change until,(in my opinion) eventually the nukes will destroy us all.It might be inevitable with the amount of nuclear warheads on the planet.
Reply
(10-11-2023, 08:13 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-11-2023, 07:53 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-11-2023, 03:43 PM)Squid Wrote: Firstly, Israel does not recognised East Jerusalem as a separate entity. Again, in contravention of international law, it annexed in 1967 and it views Jerusalem as the "undivided, eternal capital" of Israel.

I am pleased you are looking at the Human Rights Watch website. Here is a 2021 summary titled "A Threshold Crossed
Israeli Authorities and the Crimes of Apartheid and Persecution"
https://www.hrw.org/report/2021/04/27/th...ersecution

I don't think there are easy answers, but mass bombing of Gaza (and it is mass bombing, as the media pictures clearly show) will not solve any issues, but will just increase support for Hamas, much as Bloody Sunday lead to PIRA recruitment soaring.

East Jerusalem was part of Jordan before the Arabs picked a fight again in 1967. Was Jordan also in contravention of international law having annexed Jerusalem itself in 1948? Were the Brits before them, or the Ottomans for 500 years before that, or the Romans? It seems there are different rules depending on who's doing the annexing.

Jerusalem has never belonged to any sovereign state for long, so how can it be annexed? It's as much a part of Israel as it is a part of Jordan of even some made up country of Palestine that never existed.

If Hamas aggression and the inevitable response it brings genuinely leads to more support from Gazans for Hamas then they're genuinely signing their own suicide note. Perhaps Gazans could have risen up against Hamas at some point since electing a fascist terrorist organisation - but maybe that's not so easy when Hamas governs Gaza with an iron fist and treats its own citizens with far more contempt than they'd receive in Israel proper.  

If you believe what HRW says about Israel, and there is truth in that Report - then equally you ought to believe how vile Hamas is, and how it is they that are harming the people the purport to stand for as an Iranian puppet regime.

It's very clear to me what side the world ought to be on.

Most of the powerful countries in the world are on Israel's side and have been for decades.

Yet there's still no peace for Palestinian or Israeli. 

Maybe because backing one side over the other isn't the answer
..is clearly the only sensible response.

The arguments are well rehearsed above. And everywhere else, and will doubtless be long after we've all moved on.
The situation has barely changed since the 60s.

Fwiw my experience of Palestinians behind the Wall is of a kind and gentle (yes really) people.
Hamas are clearly different.
But guess what? You can't generalise.
Reply
(10-11-2023, 08:13 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-11-2023, 07:53 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-11-2023, 03:43 PM)Squid Wrote: Firstly, Israel does not recognised East Jerusalem as a separate entity. Again, in contravention of international law, it annexed in 1967 and it views Jerusalem as the "undivided, eternal capital" of Israel.

I am pleased you are looking at the Human Rights Watch website. Here is a 2021 summary titled "A Threshold Crossed
Israeli Authorities and the Crimes of Apartheid and Persecution"
https://www.hrw.org/report/2021/04/27/th...ersecution

I don't think there are easy answers, but mass bombing of Gaza (and it is mass bombing, as the media pictures clearly show) will not solve any issues, but will just increase support for Hamas, much as Bloody Sunday lead to PIRA recruitment soaring.

East Jerusalem was part of Jordan before the Arabs picked a fight again in 1967. Was Jordan also in contravention of international law having annexed Jerusalem itself in 1948? Were the Brits before them, or the Ottomans for 500 years before that, or the Romans? It seems there are different rules depending on who's doing the annexing.

Jerusalem has never belonged to any sovereign state for long, so how can it be annexed? It's as much a part of Israel as it is a part of Jordan of even some made up country of Palestine that never existed.

If Hamas aggression and the inevitable response it brings genuinely leads to more support from Gazans for Hamas then they're genuinely signing their own suicide note. Perhaps Gazans could have risen up against Hamas at some point since electing a fascist terrorist organisation - but maybe that's not so easy when Hamas governs Gaza with an iron fist and treats its own citizens with far more contempt than they'd receive in Israel proper.  

If you believe what HRW says about Israel, and there is truth in that Report - then equally you ought to believe how vile Hamas is, and how it is they that are harming the people the purport to stand for as an Iranian puppet regime.

It's very clear to me what side the world ought to be on.

Most of the powerful countries in the world are on Israel's side and have been for decades.

Yet there's still no peace for Palestinian or Israeli. 

Maybe because backing one side over the other isn't the answer

The International community provided the Palestinians with a two state solution in 1947 and then again in the Oslo Accords. They started a war the first time and walked away the second time. 

Again, I know which side I’m on.
Reply
(10-11-2023, 08:24 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: Might aswell say it religion of peace at it .

Ahh religion the biggest cause of conflict and trouble in the history of mankind imvho.
Reply
(10-12-2023, 05:23 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(10-11-2023, 08:24 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: Might aswell say it religion of peace at it .

Ahh religion the biggest cause of conflict and trouble in the history of mankind imvho.

That myth has been factually dispelled by numerous academic studies. For example, The Encycopedia of War counted 1763 conflicts and attributed less than 7% to 'religion' as a primary factor.

I mean, just taking the 20th century, looking at the biggest conflicts, none of them were about religion... WW1, WW2, Vietnam, Korea, Cambodia, Indochina, Gulf 1 and 2...
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
Until one side or the other are defeated the war will continue. The best the world can hope for is a negotiated peace happens after thousands of innocent lives have been taken.
Hamas have now become the new Isis and IMHO have no place in human society.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: