Mrs Chalobah…
#31
(10-07-2023, 04:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-07-2023, 04:17 PM)Squid Wrote: This happened literally the day before. A 19-year-old murdered by settlers on the rampage in the West Bank

https://abcnews.go.com/International/wir...-103787223

Two hundred Palestinians killed this year. Where was the media coverage? Nowhere.

Hamas are a bunch of murderous nihilists, but the Palestinians live in a world which seems to care not at all about their lives. What is the alternative for them? The two-state solution is dead and unworkable, mainly because of the increasing number of settlements.

"Following a brazen Palestinian shooting attack on an Israeli motorist along the volatile route through Hawara on Thursday, mobs from nearby Israeli settlements stormed into the town."

The story doesn't cite the Settlers as those involved in the shooting either, the conjecture is that it was the Security Services.

This is the bloody (literally) problem here. You've changed the story you cite.

Yes it does. Why didn't you continue the quote?

The article stated:

"Palestinians in Hawara claimed that an Israeli settler shot and killed Dumaidi, a freshman majoring in graphic design at the nearby Palestine Technical University, while he was standing on his rooftop watching clashes unfold on the street between settlers and Palestinians. The conflicting accounts could not immediately be reconciled."

It then went to state:

"Scores of settlers wreaked havoc, said Hawara mayor Moeen Dmeidi, torching at least three cars, shattering the windows of six homes and spraying bullets.

Although on a smaller scale, Thursday night's intrusion recalled the ferocious settler rampage through the same town in February that left a trail of destruction and one Palestinian dead.

That rampage, and other sporadic acts of revenge on Hawara residents following Palestinian shootings in the restive northern West Bank, have drawn attention to a sharp surge in settler violence under Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's far-right government."
Reply
#32
(10-07-2023, 04:31 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-07-2023, 04:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-07-2023, 04:17 PM)Squid Wrote: This happened literally the day before. A 19-year-old murdered by settlers on the rampage in the West Bank

https://abcnews.go.com/International/wir...-103787223

Two hundred Palestinians killed this year. Where was the media coverage? Nowhere.

Hamas are a bunch of murderous nihilists, but the Palestinians live in a world which seems to care not at all about their lives. What is the alternative for them? The two-state solution is dead and unworkable, mainly because of the increasing number of settlements.

"Following a brazen Palestinian shooting attack on an Israeli motorist along the volatile route through Hawara on Thursday, mobs from nearby Israeli settlements stormed into the town."

The story doesn't cite the Settlers as those involved in the shooting either, the conjecture is that it was the Security Services.

This is the bloody (literally) problem here. You've changed the story you cite.

Yes it does. Why didn't you continue the quote?

The article stated:

"Palestinians in Hawara claimed that an Israeli settler shot and killed Dumaidi, a freshman majoring in graphic design at the nearby Palestine Technical University, while he was standing on his rooftop watching clashes unfold on the street between settlers and Palestinians. The conflicting accounts could not immediately be reconciled."

It then went to state:

"Scores of settlers wreaked havoc, said Hawara mayor Moeen Dmeidi, torching at least three cars, shattering the windows of six homes and spraying bullets.

Although on a smaller scale, Thursday night's intrusion recalled the ferocious settler rampage through the same town in February that left a trail of destruction and one Palestinian dead.

That rampage, and other sporadic acts of revenge on Hawara residents following Palestinian shootings in the restive northern West Bank, have drawn attention to a sharp surge in settler violence under Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's far-right government."

Presumably Proth thought you were an idiot and wouldn’t notice.
Reply
#33
I worked there in the 90s, there was a lot of terrorist acts going on and thetefore retaliation and so it perpetuated.
The average person from both sides just wanted to live peaceful lives but it's impossible due to extremists, some masquerading as government entities.
It seemed to me that the Israelis did things to deliberately antagonise the situation and that caused conflicts. For example destroying Muslim artifacts. 
Without first hand experience its very difficult to view from afar and get a clear picture.
Reply
#34
(10-07-2023, 12:40 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-07-2023, 12:33 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: I've a lot of sympathy with the Palestinians.
But what are they trying to achieve beyond expressing an understandable frustration?
I doubt they have a tactical aim.

That Israeli/International intelligence had no idea that this was going to happen or that Hamas had the capacity to do this is the pivotal issue here. As for a wider aim, it's possibly to stall relations between Israel and Saudi Arabia.
Maybe.
Taking hostages is something new, and presumably something which will come into play later as bargaining post conflict starts.

As an observation, I don't agree that Hamas are any more the aggressor than Israel have been over many years.
The illegal settlements are everywhere in Palestine, while there are countless incidents of Palestinians being kicked out of their own land and worse.
But Israel's right to exist also has to be non negotiable.
This conflict was inevitable given the mutual intransigence.
Anyone of us who thinks we have a solution... doesn't understand the problem. Sadly.
Reply
#35
Imvho, and it is just my opinion Israel and Hamas are as bad as each other. Both constantly provoke and prod each other in various ways then procced to complain when the other retaliates,then retaliate themselves and so the cycle continues. I'm almost 60 yrs old now and its been like this for as long as can remember, there will never be peace in that region because quite frankly the politcal elite from both sides doesn't want it.
Reply
#36
(10-07-2023, 04:31 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-07-2023, 04:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-07-2023, 04:17 PM)Squid Wrote: This happened literally the day before. A 19-year-old murdered by settlers on the rampage in the West Bank

https://abcnews.go.com/International/wir...-103787223

Two hundred Palestinians killed this year. Where was the media coverage? Nowhere.

Hamas are a bunch of murderous nihilists, but the Palestinians live in a world which seems to care not at all about their lives. What is the alternative for them? The two-state solution is dead and unworkable, mainly because of the increasing number of settlements.

"Following a brazen Palestinian shooting attack on an Israeli motorist along the volatile route through Hawara on Thursday, mobs from nearby Israeli settlements stormed into the town."

The story doesn't cite the Settlers as those involved in the shooting either, the conjecture is that it was the Security Services.

This is the bloody (literally) problem here. You've changed the story you cite.

Yes it does. Why didn't you continue the quote?

The article stated:

"Palestinians in Hawara claimed that an Israeli settler shot and killed Dumaidi, a freshman majoring in graphic design at the nearby Palestine Technical University, while he was standing on his rooftop watching clashes unfold on the street between settlers and Palestinians. The conflicting accounts could not immediately be reconciled."

It then went to state:

"Scores of settlers wreaked havoc, said Hawara mayor Moeen Dmeidi, torching at least three cars, shattering the windows of six homes and spraying bullets.

Although on a smaller scale, Thursday night's intrusion recalled the ferocious settler rampage through the same town in February that left a trail of destruction and one Palestinian dead.

That rampage, and other sporadic acts of revenge on Hawara residents following Palestinian shootings in the restive northern West Bank, have drawn attention to a sharp surge in settler violence under Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's far-right government."

The article is inconclusive on who is to blame for shooting the poor kid. Your initial post didn’t make that clear. Like I say, you’re effectively dealing with the fog of war and two pretty much irreconcilable sides. 

And it’s worth making the point that if all its Arab neighbours hadn’t attempted to strangle Israel at birth and then twice more we wouldn’t be in this situation.
Reply
#37
Years ago, hitching in Israel, I discovered that there really is a place called Armageddon. ...
It's there, near the border.
Reply
#38
(10-07-2023, 06:14 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(10-07-2023, 12:40 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-07-2023, 12:33 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: I've a lot of sympathy with the Palestinians.
But what are they trying to achieve beyond expressing an understandable frustration?
I doubt they have a tactical aim.

That Israeli/International intelligence had no idea that this was going to happen or that Hamas had the capacity to do this is the pivotal issue here. As for a wider aim, it's possibly to stall relations between Israel and Saudi Arabia.
Maybe.
Taking hostages is something new, and presumably something which will come into play later as bargaining post conflict starts.

As an observation, I don't agree that Hamas are any more the aggressor than Israel have been over many years.
The illegal settlements are everywhere in Palestine, while there are countless incidents of Palestinians being kicked out of their own land and worse.
But Israel's right to exist also has to be non negotiable.
This conflict was inevitable given the mutual intransigence.
Anyone of us who thinks we have a solution... doesn't understand the problem. Sadly.

Palestinian terrorist organisations taking hostages is nothing new. 

There are no Israeli settlements in Gaza.

Gaza was part of Egypt until Egypt picked a fight with Israel.

Let’s have some facts, eh?
Reply
#39
(10-07-2023, 06:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-07-2023, 04:31 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-07-2023, 04:21 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-07-2023, 04:17 PM)Squid Wrote: This happened literally the day before. A 19-year-old murdered by settlers on the rampage in the West Bank

https://abcnews.go.com/International/wir...-103787223

Two hundred Palestinians killed this year. Where was the media coverage? Nowhere.

Hamas are a bunch of murderous nihilists, but the Palestinians live in a world which seems to care not at all about their lives. What is the alternative for them? The two-state solution is dead and unworkable, mainly because of the increasing number of settlements.

"Following a brazen Palestinian shooting attack on an Israeli motorist along the volatile route through Hawara on Thursday, mobs from nearby Israeli settlements stormed into the town."

The story doesn't cite the Settlers as those involved in the shooting either, the conjecture is that it was the Security Services.

This is the bloody (literally) problem here. You've changed the story you cite.

Yes it does. Why didn't you continue the quote?

The article stated:

"Palestinians in Hawara claimed that an Israeli settler shot and killed Dumaidi, a freshman majoring in graphic design at the nearby Palestine Technical University, while he was standing on his rooftop watching clashes unfold on the street between settlers and Palestinians. The conflicting accounts could not immediately be reconciled."

It then went to state:

"Scores of settlers wreaked havoc, said Hawara mayor Moeen Dmeidi, torching at least three cars, shattering the windows of six homes and spraying bullets.

Although on a smaller scale, Thursday night's intrusion recalled the ferocious settler rampage through the same town in February that left a trail of destruction and one Palestinian dead.

That rampage, and other sporadic acts of revenge on Hawara residents following Palestinian shootings in the restive northern West Bank, have drawn attention to a sharp surge in settler violence under Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's far-right government."

The article is inconclusive on who is to blame for shooting the poor kid. Your initial post didn’t make that clear. Like I say, you’re effectively dealing with the fog of war and two pretty much irreconcilable sides. 

And it’s worth making the point that if all its Arab neighbours hadn’t attempted to strangle Israel at birth and then twice more we wouldn’t be in this situation.

Or, if Israel hasn't forced many Palestinians from their homes and unilaterally declared an ethno-state, we wouldn't be in this situation.

Most people on here have said that they can see fault with both sides. It's only you who is convinced that only one party is at fault.
Reply
#40
Israel’s settlement policy is flawed and is being used by some as a deliberate provocation. That is wrong. That is the West Bank.

Hamas runs Gaza, where there are no settlements. Today’s aggression comes from Gaza.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)