VAR again
#11
Whatever the delights of seeing the bin dippers suffering at the hands of VAR, it was a catastrophic error and needs to be addressed.

However, for the ever maligned scousers (?) to then say  "In the meantime, we will explore the range of options available, given the clear need for escalation and resolution" ... WTF options are they looking at? Void the match, give them 3 points, call it a draw? Can we go back and have options for every time VAR has shown to have got it wrong, even marginally? This is the entitled Scousers again playing the ''we've been hard done by'' game. For me they can fuck right off.
Reply
#12
Bin VAR there was never this much controversy when it was just the ref a linesmen. Ball to hand or hand to ball unnatural position , onside offside the officials at the ground get more right than wrong. Anyway it’s totality unfair as it’s not used across the board. For me either all use it or no one use it. How can it be fair when only the big leagues use it.
Reply
#13
(10-02-2023, 09:45 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(10-02-2023, 08:49 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If it had been Liverpool vs Burnley or Luton or (insert name of non fashionable (rich) club here....) the discussion would have got no further than jug ears and co on MotD. Because it's Liverpool, and their gurning ventriloquist's dummy of a manager, it's made GMB and BBC Breakfast.

Terrible decision, great result  Big Grin

Not sure I agree with this,  well not the first paragraph. 

It's a really embarrassing screw up.

It's plausible that the var ref might have missed the linesman raising his flag for offside,, but to allow the game to start again with a free kick, not a kick off. When he saw that the ball was not being placed on the centre circle to restart the game, didn't he think that this would be a good time to tell the on pitch ref that a mighty fuck up was about to occur.

Don't think it matters which teams were involved...this is a big story.
If it had gone against Burnley in a 3-0 defeat to Liverpool, there is absolutely zero chance it would have made GMB. The human error angle would have been accepted and everyone would move on.
Remember ours against Saints, when they couldn't draw the line properly? No-one outside of the Black Country does.

Sheff Utd got relegated on a more obvious error and no-one outside of Sheffield gave a shit. It's now no more than an anecdote on a "When football goes wrong" schedule filler.
Reply
#14
(10-02-2023, 11:18 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(10-02-2023, 09:45 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(10-02-2023, 08:49 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If it had been Liverpool vs Burnley or Luton or (insert name of non fashionable (rich) club here....) the discussion would have got no further than jug ears and co on MotD. Because it's Liverpool, and their gurning ventriloquist's dummy of a manager, it's made GMB and BBC Breakfast.

Terrible decision, great result  Big Grin

Not sure I agree with this,  well not the first paragraph. 

It's a really embarrassing screw up.

It's plausible that the var ref might have missed the linesman raising his flag for offside,, but to allow the game to start again with a free kick, not a kick off. When he saw that the ball was not being placed on the centre circle to restart the game, didn't he think that this would be a good time to tell the on pitch ref that a mighty fuck up was about to occur.

Don't think it matters which teams were involved...this is a big story.
If it had gone against Burnley in a 3-0 defeat to Liverpool, there is absolutely zero chance it would have made GMB. The human error angle would have been accepted and everyone would move on.
Remember ours against Saints, when they couldn't draw the line properly? No-one outside of the Black Country does.

Sheff Utd got relegated on a more obvious error and no-one outside of Sheffield gave a shit. It's now no more than an anecdote on a "When football goes wrong" schedule filler.

Good point about the Sheff U non goal.
Far more important, far more controversial. Far more wrong.. but just a bit of a laff.
Same with us against Colin's lot - dreadful event in football terms, but brushed off by the sweet FA.
Reply
#15
If we're talking about the Villa Park goal I should just point out that Sheff U were comfortably mid table.

The issue was that it would have almost certainly relegated the fishy bastards.
Reply
#16
(10-02-2023, 12:24 PM)Duffers Wrote: If we're talking about the Villa Park goal I should just point out that Sheff U were comfortably mid table.

The issue was that it would have almost certainly relegated the fishy bastards.
You're right Duffers, Bournemouth and Watford were the aggrieved parties as the both finished a point behind Villa. Sheff Utd was the game that it happened in.
Reply
#17
Where was the outrage when Diange was mistook for a defender? Bartley?

I feel sorry for this guy...
[Image: Screenshot-2023-10-02-at-14-04-10.png]
Reply
#18
(10-02-2023, 10:32 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Whatever the delights of seeing the bin dippers suffering at the hands of VAR, it was a catastrophic error and needs to be addressed.

However, for the ever maligned scousers (?) to then say  "In the meantime, we will explore the range of options available, given the clear need for escalation and resolution" ... WTF options are they looking at? Void the match, give them 3 points, call it a draw? Can we go back and have options for every time VAR has shown to have got it wrong, even marginally? This is the entitled Scousers again playing the ''we've been hard done by'' game. For me they can fuck right off.

Quite. When did Liverpool `Explore the range of options available` when they benefited from a dodgy decision that meant the other team wrongly lost or had somebody sent off , like their Cup game v Wolves with an offside goal ? No, `we have to abide by the VAR decision` etc. Klopp wasn`t moaning with his Colgate `Ring of Confidence` then.

As for VAR, I said on another recent thread that, IMO, if a ref is dreadful when on the pitch, ( Mike Dean, Bobby Madley,David Coote, etc ), then why would anyone expect them to be any better when watching a video screen ?
Reply
#19
(10-02-2023, 08:49 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If it had been Liverpool vs Burnley or Luton or (insert name of non fashionable (rich) club here....) the discussion would have got no further than jug ears and co on MotD. Because it's Liverpool, and their gurning ventriloquist's dummy of a manager, it's made GMB and BBC Breakfast.

Terrible decision, great result  Big Grin

Agree 100%

Wasnt much fuss over villa staying up & sending Shef United down 

Was the machine broke or something from memory?

Or Villa FFP hanging over them that made sure it was switched off?
Reply
#20
(10-02-2023, 06:35 PM)Pipkins Wrote:
(10-02-2023, 08:49 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If it had been Liverpool vs Burnley or Luton or (insert name of non fashionable (rich) club here....) the discussion would have got no further than jug ears and co on MotD. Because it's Liverpool, and their gurning ventriloquist's dummy of a manager, it's made GMB and BBC Breakfast.

Terrible decision, great result  Big Grin

Agree 100%

Wasnt much fuss over villa staying up & sending Shef United down 

Was the machine broke or something from memory?

Or Villa FFP hanging over them that made sure it was switched off?

As previously stated Sheff Utd weren’t relegated.

The result actually had very little impact on their season.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: