Trump v The Sane World
#31
(09-28-2023, 09:42 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-27-2023, 08:00 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Life would be very dull on here if every thread took the predictable aren't all Tories / Business Owners / Home Owners / Landlords / Private School Subscribers awful people....

Arf wanging on about nuance then you make this statement… 

I don’t recall any criticism of home ownership.

No one has said all landlords are all bad or all good for that matter. Some might argue it’s a tad hypocritical to talk about wanting more affordable homes, whilst renting out one, two, three properties to families who would I’m sure if they could afford them prefer to own the one they are renting. Perhaps the landlords who do label others as nimbys etc could give the houses they own to young families at an affordable / below market price to help. 

Again I don’t recall people saying business owners are awful people, I think they have pointed to the disproportionate pay rises and dividends given out like sweets in large companies who are profiting from circumstances such as war, supply problems or fluctuations in the financial markets that have little to do with their skills or output/achievements, compared to the average worker struggling to make ends meet through no fault of their own. 

This Tory government is judged on its actions, words and achievements, if they are awful then the unfortunate few who aren’t prepared to lie, vote for awful policies and support awful leaders I agree are unfairly judged. Now you can argue they aren’t awful but you’re going to have to point to all the good things they’ve done over the past 13yrs to prove they aren’t awful... I await the long list of great or even good things they’ve done.

If you added some nuance to more of your posts you might get more respect.

There have been plenty of whinges about Boomers and their housing wealth. I've whinged myself about the lack of reflection about financing their own care amongst those with wholly unearned housing wealth. 

The remainder of your post is full of your usual value judgements. As a father, my family comes first - I'm a landlord to provide in part for my family and secure their future. It is entirely consistent with the view that there should be more affordable housing - as ultimately I will be able to provide a roof over my kids' heads or the deposit for a home of their own whether the State provides the conditions for more development or not (the likelihood is the State won't).

And our tenants are always free to make us an offer for the properties they rent. 

Your point on directors' remuneration draws false equivalence between those who establish and / or run companies and those who work for them. It's simple politics of envy and gets no one anywhere. Your ire really ought to be directed at those individuals who over extract dividends when company performance doesn't warrant it - like Wilkinsons, Arcadia or several of the Water Companies (though your ire really ought to be directed toward OFWAT & the government on that score).

As for the Tory government, I've criticised policy for the last 13 years as much if not more than you - always from a different perspective I'm sure. However, unlike you my starting premise is that government is a necessary evil. And the only thing I can really congratulate the government for in last 13 years is that things aren't an awful lot worse.

(09-28-2023, 10:01 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(09-26-2023, 07:18 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-26-2023, 06:01 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Which would suggest they have been taught to think freely. Thus debunking your daft Daily Mail driven notion that teachers are all on some weird socialist driven agenda

I don't think I was saying that at all. I'm sure as many  teachers are as ignorant of socialism as they are of markets. The fact is, that kids generally come out of school without an understanding of either. I had to explain the basic tenets of Communism the other day to a 27 year old psychology graduate.

And I am sure you were very objective.

Perhaps you might enlighten the board on this subject.

I was very objective - particularly on issues of individual liberty, markets, property rights and the substitution of the rule of law by summary justice.

As a gay left leaning Yorkshireman I also explained how Che Guevara would have sent him to a concentration camp.
Reply
#32
(09-28-2023, 11:16 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-28-2023, 09:42 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-27-2023, 08:00 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Life would be very dull on here if every thread took the predictable aren't all Tories / Business Owners / Home Owners / Landlords / Private School Subscribers awful people....

Arf wanging on about nuance then you make this statement… 

I don’t recall any criticism of home ownership.

No one has said all landlords are all bad or all good for that matter. Some might argue it’s a tad hypocritical to talk about wanting more affordable homes, whilst renting out one, two, three properties to families who would I’m sure if they could afford them prefer to own the one they are renting. Perhaps the landlords who do label others as nimbys etc could give the houses they own to young families at an affordable / below market price to help. 

Again I don’t recall people saying business owners are awful people, I think they have pointed to the disproportionate pay rises and dividends given out like sweets in large companies who are profiting from circumstances such as war, supply problems or fluctuations in the financial markets that have little to do with their skills or output/achievements, compared to the average worker struggling to make ends meet through no fault of their own. 

This Tory government is judged on its actions, words and achievements, if they are awful then the unfortunate few who aren’t prepared to lie, vote for awful policies and support awful leaders I agree are unfairly judged. Now you can argue they aren’t awful but you’re going to have to point to all the good things they’ve done over the past 13yrs to prove they aren’t awful... I await the long list of great or even good things they’ve done.

If you added some nuance to more of your posts you might get more respect.

There have been plenty of whinges about Boomers and their housing wealth. I've whinged myself about the lack of reflection about financing their own care amongst those with wholly unearned housing wealth. 

The remainder of your post is full of your usual value judgements. As a father, my family comes first - I'm a landlord to provide in part for my family and secure their future. It is entirely consistent with the view that there should be more affordable housing - as ultimately I will be able to provide a roof over my kids' heads or the deposit for a home of their own whether the State provides the conditions for more development or not (the likelihood is the State won't).

And our tenants are always free to make us an offer for the properties they rent. 

Your point on directors' remuneration draws false equivalence between those who establish and / or run companies and those who work for them. It's simple politics of envy and gets no one anywhere. Your ire really ought to be directed at those individuals who over extract dividends when company performance doesn't warrant it - like Wilkinsons, Arcadia or several of the Water Companies (though your ire really ought to be directed toward OFWAT & the government on that score).

As for the Tory government, I've criticised policy for the last 13 years as much if not more than you - always from a different perspective I'm sure. However, unlike you my starting premise is that government is a necessary evil. And the only thing I can really congratulate the government for in last 13 years is that things aren't an awful lot worse.

(09-28-2023, 10:01 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(09-26-2023, 07:18 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-26-2023, 06:01 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Which would suggest they have been taught to think freely. Thus debunking your daft Daily Mail driven notion that teachers are all on some weird socialist driven agenda

I don't think I was saying that at all. I'm sure as many  teachers are as ignorant of socialism as they are of markets. The fact is, that kids generally come out of school without an understanding of either. I had to explain the basic tenets of Communism the other day to a 27 year old psychology graduate.

And I am sure you were very objective.

Perhaps you might enlighten the board on this subject.

I was very objective - particularly on issues of individual liberty, markets, property rights and the substitution of the rule of law by summary justice.

As a gay left leaning Yorkshireman I also explained how Che Guevara would have sent him to a concentration camp.

I’m sure your respect for me is equal to mine for you. 

Politics of envy -  cliched drivel used to shut down criticism and justify reward for little achievement be that companies such as Serco, rail, energy, water companies, banks etc. 

Buying houses for rent simply reduces the housing stock  and damages communities. Whether your family benefit or not it doesn’t help anyone but you and them ultimately. 

As for your laughable argument that after 13 years this government haven’t made things much worse (awful) what fugging planet do you live on?
Reply
#33
(09-28-2023, 10:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Buying houses for rent simply reduces the housing stock  and damages communities. Whether your family benefit or not it doesn’t help anyone but you and them ultimately. 

As for your laughable argument that after 13 years this government haven’t made things much worse (awful) what fugging planet do you live on?

Can you explain to me HOW buying houses to let out reduces the housing stock and damages communities? If you're talking about coastal second homes I'll grant you with having a point, but a few 2-bedders in the Black Country? How exactly does it "reduce stock"? How exactly does it "damage communities"? And be honest with me - who do believe your first responsibility is to? Your family? Or some nebulous concept of society? I'm pretty certain where I stand on that.

You may find my latter point laughable, but the voting public has returned the Tories to government three times since 2015. Each time their judgement is that things would be worse with whatever combination of the other lot. Now they don't, and they're probably right.
Reply
#34
(09-29-2023, 08:16 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-28-2023, 10:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Buying houses for rent simply reduces the housing stock  and damages communities. Whether your family benefit or not it doesn’t help anyone but you and them ultimately. 

As for your laughable argument that after 13 years this government haven’t made things much worse (awful) what fugging planet do you live on?

Can you explain to me HOW buying houses to let out reduces the housing stock and damages communities? If you're talking about coastal second homes I'll grant you with having a point, but a few 2-bedders in the Black Country? How exactly does it "reduce stock"? How exactly does it "damage communities"? And be honest with me - who do believe your first responsibility is to? Your family? Or some nebulous concept of society? I'm pretty certain where I stand on that.

You may find my latter point laughable, but the voting public has returned the Tories to government three times since 2015. Each time their judgement is that things would be worse with whatever combination of the other lot. Now they don't, and they're probably right.

Hard to disagree with a lot of that first paragraph Proth but your approach is very much prevention rather than cure.
Reply
#35
(09-29-2023, 09:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(09-29-2023, 08:16 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-28-2023, 10:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Buying houses for rent simply reduces the housing stock  and damages communities. Whether your family benefit or not it doesn’t help anyone but you and them ultimately. 

As for your laughable argument that after 13 years this government haven’t made things much worse (awful) what fugging planet do you live on?

Can you explain to me HOW buying houses to let out reduces the housing stock and damages communities? If you're talking about coastal second homes I'll grant you with having a point, but a few 2-bedders in the Black Country? How exactly does it "reduce stock"? How exactly does it "damage communities"? And be honest with me - who do believe your first responsibility is to? Your family? Or some nebulous concept of society? I'm pretty certain where I stand on that.

You may find my latter point laughable, but the voting public has returned the Tories to government three times since 2015. Each time their judgement is that things would be worse with whatever combination of the other lot. Now they don't, and they're probably right.

Hard to disagree with a lot of that first paragraph Proth but your approach is very much prevention rather than cure.

I can't do anything personally about planning policy or funding for social housing. It doesn't help that there are £billions lying in Council coffers unspent n s106 obligations.
Reply
#36
(09-26-2023, 12:15 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-26-2023, 11:54 AM)DemonicBaggie Wrote: The key point of this thread though, which you well know, is that Sunak's policy turn attracted the praise of the western world's most egregious personality (I use the term lightly). I find that rather telling.

Why?

If anybody of note - from any political wing - says anything that can be twisted to accord with Trumps world view then he will shower them with praise. It doesn't tell you anything more than that.

(09-26-2023, 11:54 AM)DemonicBaggie Wrote: If the world's full of Socialists then hasn't Socialism obviously succeeded? 

No, it tells you our education system has failed.

(09-29-2023, 01:39 PM)DemonicBaggie Wrote:
(09-26-2023, 12:15 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-26-2023, 11:54 AM)DemonicBaggie Wrote: The key point of this thread though, which you well know, is that Sunak's policy turn attracted the praise of the western world's most egregious personality (I use the term lightly). I find that rather telling.

Why?

If anybody of note - from any political wing - says anything that can be twisted to accord with Trumps world view then he will shower them with praise. It doesn't tell you anything more than that.

(09-26-2023, 11:54 AM)DemonicBaggie Wrote: If the world's full of Socialists then hasn't Socialism obviously succeeded? 

No, it tells you our education system has failed.

But Trump hasn't twisted Sunak's words to fit his own world view or agenda. He hasn't needed to, he can use them verbatim. That's what's so telling.
Reply
#37
That's your opinion. I don't share it.
Reply
#38
(09-29-2023, 12:38 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-29-2023, 09:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(09-29-2023, 08:16 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-28-2023, 10:53 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Buying houses for rent simply reduces the housing stock  and damages communities. Whether your family benefit or not it doesn’t help anyone but you and them ultimately. 

As for your laughable argument that after 13 years this government haven’t made things much worse (awful) what fugging planet do you live on?

Can you explain to me HOW buying houses to let out reduces the housing stock and damages communities? If you're talking about coastal second homes I'll grant you with having a point, but a few 2-bedders in the Black Country? How exactly does it "reduce stock"? How exactly does it "damage communities"? And be honest with me - who do believe your first responsibility is to? Your family? Or some nebulous concept of society? I'm pretty certain where I stand on that.

You may find my latter point laughable, but the voting public has returned the Tories to government three times since 2015. Each time their judgement is that things would be worse with whatever combination of the other lot. Now they don't, and they're probably right.

Hard to disagree with a lot of that first paragraph Proth but your approach is very much prevention rather than cure.

I can't do anything personally about planning policy or funding for social housing. It doesn't help that there are £billions lying in Council coffers unspent n s106 obligations.

But, wouldn't councils be profligate to have nothing in reserve? For me, the lucky beneficient of a safe tenancy that housed  multi generations in the same house, each going on to get their council house, before their kids ( me and many cousins) going on to buy houses, well , we were lucky. The sale of council houses stopped this, the failure to provide social housing is inexcusable. This, and other Thatcherist idealists,  is all contributing to the fractured society we see. Unless you enjoy living behind gates ,  it isn't really the perfect world is it? Society should not be a bad word, its the only future that works.
Reply
#39
(09-29-2023, 09:38 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: But, wouldn't councils be profligate to have nothing in reserve? For me, the lucky beneficient of a safe tenancy that housed  multi generations in the same house, each going on to get their council house, before their kids ( me and many cousins) going on to buy houses, well , we were lucky. The sale of council houses stopped this, the failure to provide social housing is inexcusable. This, and other Thatcherist idealists,  is all contributing to the fractured society we see. Unless you enjoy living behind gates ,  it isn't really the perfect world is it? Society should not be a bad word, its the only future that works.

These aren't reserves. This is money specifically raised from developers to fund infrastructure and social housing.

I'd also argue that RTB massively improved most low rise estates by giving former tenants a stake. I was brought up next to Chelmsley Wood - RTB transformed it over a decade or more. I do take the point about the lack of replacement building though.

All that said, never let the truth get in the way of a good polemic - RTB was originally a Labour Party policy. Thatcher merely put rocket boosters under it.
Reply
#40
(09-30-2023, 07:34 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-29-2023, 09:38 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: But, wouldn't councils be profligate to have nothing in reserve? For me, the lucky beneficient of a safe tenancy that housed  multi generations in the same house, each going on to get their council house, before their kids ( me and many cousins) going on to buy houses, well , we were lucky. The sale of council houses stopped this, the failure to provide social housing is inexcusable. This, and other Thatcherist idealists,  is all contributing to the fractured society we see. Unless you enjoy living behind gates ,  it isn't really the perfect world is it? Society should not be a bad word, its the only future that works.

These aren't reserves. This is money specifically raised from developers to fund infrastructure and social housing.

I'd also argue that RTB massively improved most low rise estates by giving former tenants a stake. I was brought up next to Chelmsley Wood - RTB transformed it over a decade or more. I do take the point about the lack of replacement building though.

All that said, never let the truth get in the way of a good polemic - RTB was originally a Labour Party policy. Thatcher merely put rocket boosters under it.
Yes, I realise it wasn't her idea. I just believe the uncertainty of tenancy doesn't do anyone any good.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: