Laurence Fox
#61
(09-28-2023, 10:41 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I was actually discussing this with a German corporate law barrister at the weekend, whilst he was explaining how many British firms he knows who have lost millions and jobs galore due to Brexit.

Can we have a list of those firms?

Can we also have a list of German firms who've relocated to the US because of Mutti's ludicrous energy policy? And those now losing millions and shedding labour because of her?

Maybe we can also have a chat about mass youth unemployment across southern Europe #DespiteEU?

If not, then I suspect Brexit related nuance will still be in short supply on here...
Reply
#62
(09-28-2023, 11:25 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(09-28-2023, 11:12 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-28-2023, 10:41 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(09-28-2023, 10:11 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I think it’s a tad patronising to suggest people aren’t aware that they are being given choices that reflect what they read, listened to or watched previously. The idea that in previous generations people who got their news and current affairs by buying every morning the Daily Mail, Sun, Guardian and Mirror is a bit far fetched to say the least. Likewise that everyone listened intently to the other persons opinion and made ‘nuanced ffs’ arguments in reply. I’m old enough to remember that wasn’t the case at all, it was just not as easy to see millions of peoples opinions down the pub, in school, at work etc. 

It’s far easier to read, listen and watch articles, broadcasts and tv shows from across the political spectrum  now than it was in previous generations. I like to read opposing points of view of Twitter, in the news example and despite the caricature on here I have linked to pretty much every U.K. media outlets articles sometimes in support, sometimes just to provide a different angle and sometimes just to provoke a ‘heated’ debate Wink

My conclusion that we never used to live in an echo chamber, that we had nuanced arguments all the time and that people aren’t aware now that they are fed stuff the algorithm and company think will gain the the most clicks, viewers or listeners… is a generalisation that ahem lacks nuance. As with every generation you can seek out opinions and thoughts you don’t agree with and challenge you… whether you do or not is always up to the individual and people will always tend to flock together when they believe in the same values, that’s just human nature.

Regarding GB news they failed to uphold standards that are required by broadcasters, they had no choice but to suspend the two protagonists. It’s not difficult, it’s not about fugging nuance or about yawn cancel culture, they fell below the standards expected that’s it.

I'm happy to be patronising on this as I have a very low opinion of the general populace and think people have, by and large, got more stupid and easier to manipulate by those with half a brain. I was actually discussing this with a German corporate law barrister at the weekend, whilst he was explaining how many British firms he knows who have lost millions and jobs galore due to Brexit.

If you care to look at a political debate from 30 years ago on a TV channel you'll see people have become angrier and less willing to respect opposing views. The internet has done this. We've all become puppets of some kind, but some always

Just because a few well spoken ex-politicians, and professors all sat on comfy chairs in wobbly studios politely discussing politics did not translate into what was happening in society at the time. You’re  confusing BBC buttoned up conservatism with a small c at the time with actual political events. The Miners strikes, National Front demo’s the riots up and down the country showing only too well how polarised the real debates and political discourse was in the past.
I see your point, but mine is more general dumbing down in the news is the issue with more sophisticated media, armed with more data, pressing the buttons.

Again that is down to personal choice where you get your information. The Sun was the biggest selling newspaper for at least a decade I imagine, its third page was a teenage girl or young woman with her boobs out. and at the same time you had Sir Robin Day interviewing political heavyweights of the time The idea we have dumbed down is just rose tinted glasses. Yes people are less likely to care about being polite in how they express their opinion but that doesn’t mean they have dumbed down, more likely they can’t be bothered to show respect or dare I say faux respect to someone who they disagree with.

Anyway I’m just off to get my Stanley knife and bike chain and twat a few away fans to show how nuanced, respectful and intellectual my arguments are to persuade the opposition fans my club is best.
Reply
#63
Unless you go hunting for the opposing views then the algorithms will just keep feeding you similar views... Which in some cases leads to people believing that everyone shares their views... Perpetuating the cycle.

In short, social media controls people's views and thoughts like newspapers never could, all the while leaving you feeling smug thinking everyone agrees with you.

It's one of the many reasons I don't use any social media, except maybe this place, and the one thing guaranteed here is that there are no algorithms, so you blanket get all the views, and sometimes, cannot escape them.
Reply
#64
(09-28-2023, 11:23 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(09-28-2023, 11:11 AM)strawman Wrote: Confirmation bias - while it may make it easier to find other opinions - many people only seek out opinions that only confirm their view of the world

Which is what I do. I'm not the slightest bit interested in what Brexiteers, climate change deniers and far right-wing nutters in general think, although I am concerned by the extent to which their views can (and do) influence others.

Anyone I come across on Twitter (the only social media I use) writing stuff I strongly disagree with will get blocked if I see things like "Conservative", "anti-woke", "evangelical Christian", "Brexiteer" and so-on in their profile.

In which case are you not exactly the same as those you are talking about on your previous post? Ie by seeking only views you agree with, it just reinforces your beliefs anyway? That’s the other side of the same coin.

People may provide a view you disagree with on, say, brexit or the climate. If they disagree in some respects, does that automatically make anything they say nonsense to you? Can anyone be critical of a climate policy, or do you dismiss them as a “climate change denier”? (A phrase often used to shut down a genuine concern). These things are not binary. Likewise, an evangelical Christian is automatically dismissed? Do you think a Christian can’t debate or have a worthy view on anything in life? I’m atheist but I find that utterly bizarre. Surely just treat people as individuals and don’t label them, like, erm those “typical” brexiteers.

Someone has conservative in their profile so you don’t want to even hear what they may say on a particular issue? Again, bizarre. Very very closed minded. And an unhealthy view of the world IMO.

It’s so odd that so many people think this is a healthy way to debate. Opposing views, however offensive, are vital to any debate and society (within the law… I’m not talking about walking down the street screaming racial abuse at people btw).
Reply
#65
(09-28-2023, 11:35 AM)NewWanker Wrote: Unless you go hunting for the opposing views then the algorithms will just keep feeding you similar views... Which in some cases leads to people believing that everyone shares their views... Perpetuating the cycle.

In short, social media controls people's views and thoughts like newspapers never could, all the while leaving you feeling smug thinking everyone agrees with you.

It's one of the many reasons I don't use any social media, except maybe this place, and the one thing guaranteed here is that there are no algorithms, so you blanket get all the views, and sometimes, cannot escape them.

No, that is the choice the individual makes to not seek out the opposing point of view. The same as going to the newsagents and buying the paper that best fits your political and social views.

This is a general and personal point rather than you to you NW, if I didn’t want to know opposing opinions why would I spend far too many hours of my life arguing with those I disagree with on here Wink.
Reply
#66
(09-28-2023, 11:45 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-28-2023, 11:23 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(09-28-2023, 11:11 AM)strawman Wrote: Confirmation bias - while it may make it easier to find other opinions - many people only seek out opinions that only confirm their view of the world

Which is what I do. I'm not the slightest bit interested in what Brexiteers, climate change deniers and far right-wing nutters in general think, although I am concerned by the extent to which their views can (and do) influence others.

Anyone I come across on Twitter (the only social media I use) writing stuff I strongly disagree with will get blocked if I see things like "Conservative", "anti-woke", "evangelical Christian", "Brexiteer" and so-on in their profile.

In which case are you not exactly the same as those you are talking about on your previous post? Ie by seeking only views you agree with, it just reinforces your beliefs anyway? That’s the other side of the same coin.

People may provide a view you disagree with on, say, brexit or the climate. If they disagree in some respects, does that automatically make anything they say nonsense to you? Can anyone be critical of a climate policy, or do you dismiss them as a “climate change denier”? (A phrase often used to shut down a genuine concern). These things are not binary. Likewise, an evangelical Christian is automatically dismissed? Do you think a Christian can’t debate or have a worthy view on anything in life? I’m atheist but I find that utterly bizarre. Surely just treat people as individuals and don’t label them, like, erm those “typical” brexiteers.

Someone has conservative in their profile so you don’t want to even hear what they may say on a particular issue? Again, bizarre. Very very closed minded. And an unhealthy view of the world IMO.

It’s so odd that so many people think this is a healthy way to debate. Opposing views, however offensive, are vital to any debate and society (within the law… I’m not talking about walking down the street screaming racial abuse at people btw).

You missed where I said "writing stuff I strongly disagree with", by which time I'll have read their opposing view and made a value judgement on it.
Reply
#67
(09-28-2023, 11:31 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-28-2023, 10:41 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I was actually discussing this with a German corporate law barrister at the weekend, whilst he was explaining how many British firms he knows who have lost millions and jobs galore due to Brexit.

Can we have a list of those firms?

Can we also have a list of German firms who've relocated to the US because of Mutti's ludicrous energy policy? And those now losing millions and shedding labour because of her?

Maybe we can also have a chat about mass youth unemployment across southern Europe #DespiteEU?

If not, then I suspect Brexit related nuance will still be in short supply on here...

I didn't get into that depth of chat with him Proth.

However, this kind of reply is why I respect you and you're such an asset to the forum.

We have disagreements on some things, agreements on others, but I've never found myself in an opposing echo chamber with you.

The beauty of this bored is the opposing views backed up with arguments like you've just stated, which gives food for thought.

The ability to argue with facts is far better than closing debate down by saying you're anti-woke or a hater or such. The propensity to label now is at epidemic proportions which can be seen on here if you show any form of conservatism.
Reply
#68
(09-28-2023, 11:54 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(09-28-2023, 11:45 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-28-2023, 11:23 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(09-28-2023, 11:11 AM)strawman Wrote: Confirmation bias - while it may make it easier to find other opinions - many people only seek out opinions that only confirm their view of the world

Which is what I do. I'm not the slightest bit interested in what Brexiteers, climate change deniers and far right-wing nutters in general think, although I am concerned by the extent to which their views can (and do) influence others.

Anyone I come across on Twitter (the only social media I use) writing stuff I strongly disagree with will get blocked if I see things like "Conservative", "anti-woke", "evangelical Christian", "Brexiteer" and so-on in their profile.

In which case are you not exactly the same as those you are talking about on your previous post? Ie by seeking only views you agree with, it just reinforces your beliefs anyway? That’s the other side of the same coin.

People may provide a view you disagree with on, say, brexit or the climate. If they disagree in some respects, does that automatically make anything they say nonsense to you? Can anyone be critical of a climate policy, or do you dismiss them as a “climate change denier”? (A phrase often used to shut down a genuine concern). These things are not binary. Likewise, an evangelical Christian is automatically dismissed? Do you think a Christian can’t debate or have a worthy view on anything in life? I’m atheist but I find that utterly bizarre. Surely just treat people as individuals and don’t label them, like, erm those “typical” brexiteers.

Someone has conservative in their profile so you don’t want to even hear what they may say on a particular issue? Again, bizarre. Very very closed minded. And an unhealthy view of the world IMO.

It’s so odd that so many people think this is a healthy way to debate. Opposing views, however offensive, are vital to any debate and society (within the law… I’m not talking about walking down the street screaming racial abuse at people btw).

You missed where I said "writing stuff I strongly disagree with", by which time I'll have read their opposing view and made a value judgement on it.

But does that mean that they may not add something of value on another subject?

I don’t use social media apart from here. But I do find this forum staggeringly dismissive of some people’s views, and particularly bad for pigeonholing, which adds to the divisiveness in the world these days.
Reply
#69
IMO this forum is one of the most balanced and rational of the glut of social media webplaces out there.

Abd if you disagree with me, just ask CaptainFantastico and NewWanker
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#70
The Chris Brunt test has always been a great barometer on which to judge people.

Think Brunt was shite? Yep, I'm never listening to another one of your opinions.

Keeps life stress free and easy.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)