Enoch
#11
The extent of government direction in infrastructure development was absolutely short termist under Blair. Let us not forget that despite consistently harking on about being pro-nuclear he never bothered to plan for the incoming AGR decommissioning because his government was only obsessed with how cheap gas was at the time. There's various other things to look at with respect to that, telecoms (FTTC bullshit instead of FTTP) was another case taking the easy option instead of the proper option and it's cost us more in the long term as we've needed to go to FTTP anyway.

And the basic economic model was the same, it was a carry on from the service-focused reorientation of Thatcher and Major and a more monetarist outlook instead of Keynesian (hence why the BoE was given independence from the Treasury). It doesn't have to be identical for it to be the same underlying economic model. The Heath and Attlee governments were very different on specific economic matters but they were still following the basic economic model, hence the postwar consensus. I don't think Blair was a Thatcherite disciple - I believe he was a bog standard social democrat - but the economic model we followed when he was PM was the same.
Reply
#12
In terms of the stuff that actually supports people's day to day lives, he delivered. Short term and long term.

If you look at the volume of money creation (cash circulating in the real economy) it is beyond credible to say that was comparable to what had come before.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#13
(09-16-2023, 09:39 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Sounds justified to use police violence against all participants now you outline the case so well. Imagine if that was the norm every time people wanted to rightly protect their living and community and a small number were outside of acceptable levels of protest. For a bloke that likes liberty and detests big state, you can't half flip when it suits

Not really. Given the choice between the elected mob and the unelected mob I'd generally choose the former - #leastworst and all that...

(09-16-2023, 11:20 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: If you look at the volume of money creation (cash circulating in the real economy) it is beyond credible to say that was comparable to what had come before.

That's very true. Wage growth was far faster under Thatcher.
Reply
#14
(09-16-2023, 11:20 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: In terms of the stuff that actually supports people's day to day lives, he delivered. Short term and long term.

If you look at the volume of money creation (cash circulating in the real economy) it is beyond credible to say that was comparable to what had come before.

But those social programmes weren't long term, they lasted as long as the next government led by a party who were rigidly following the direction of a paper that was found to be wrong ripping them up while being supported by another party that was beyond naïve and ballsless. And looming logistical frailties were ignored as it wasn't in Labour's short term interest to solve them, resulting in the compounding effects on productivity and how future tax would be to be targeted to support the population.

As it was, austerity happened and the infrastructure development opportunities that were passed over are spilling over into economic stagnation which is being compounded by demographic patterns.
Reply
#15
Those social programs changed lives. They were as long as they can be in a country that allows political ping pong at the epicentre of essential public services
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#16
(09-16-2023, 06:06 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Those social programs changed lives. They were as long as they can be in a country that allows political ping pong at the epicentre of essential public services

Yes, they changed lives and helped people, and the effects of them may be seen over the medium to long term. But ultimately they were still short term reforms because the governments over the last 13 years have gutted those provisions. They lasted as long as Labour did, if there's no will by an incoming government to continue them then they're going in the bin.

It's a lot harder to gut infrastructure though, if Blair had initiated a new nuclear programme in 1997 rather than ignore it because gas was cheap and we'd built those AGR reactors that Thatcher and Major put off building then we would have abundant, extremely low carbon and low OpEx electricity right now. Same as if Blair had revived the BT FTTP programme from the 1980s as the internet started to grow over his premiership instead of ignore it for 8 years and then panic and start the bodge that was FTTC which is now being displaced by FTTP, we could have been a digital world leader going into the 2010s.
Reply
#17
And they call Starmer Captain Hindsight…
Reply
#18
What am I supposed to do? Build a time machine? Not lament the impact of those mistakes on the here and now, and the compounding effects in the future?

People knew we needed to replace nuclear stock and replace copper telecoms infrastructure back in the 1970s. That's why there were plans in place to do that, and I can point to those plans not being enacted on. Much as people know that Old Oak Common isn't a suitable terminus for HS2 for configuration, timetabling and capacity reasons, that isn't stopping our non-technical PM overruling people for short term political gains right now though.
Reply
#19
(09-16-2023, 09:30 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-16-2023, 07:35 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: She utilised state power to violently control
striking protesters. I reckon that's extreme

Would that be the strikers who never actually called a national ballot to mandate the strike? Who committed violent acts against their own members who chose to work? Who actually murdered a taxi driver? Who wanted to hold the country to ransom (again) for their own selfish ends?

As someone who was born at home by candlelight during a power cut in the 70s miners strike I'm only disappointed I wasn't old enough to have joined South Yorkshire Police myself.

The defeat of that lot was one of her finest hours.

Feel free to come up to South Yorkshire and air your views in Fitzwilliam, Bentley or Shafton. Nip across to Liverpool whilst you're at it. They love SYP, too.
Reply
#20
(09-17-2023, 08:39 AM)DemonicBaggie Wrote:
(09-16-2023, 09:30 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-16-2023, 07:35 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: She utilised state power to violently control
striking protesters. I reckon that's extreme

Would that be the strikers who never actually called a national ballot to mandate the strike? Who committed violent acts against their own members who chose to work? Who actually murdered a taxi driver? Who wanted to hold the country to ransom (again) for their own selfish ends?

As someone who was born at home by candlelight during a power cut in the 70s miners strike I'm only disappointed I wasn't old enough to have joined South Yorkshire Police myself.

The defeat of that lot was one of her finest hours.

Feel free to come up to South Yorkshire and air your views in Fitzwilliam, Bentley or Shafton. Nip across to Liverpool whilst you're at it. They love SYP, too.

If nothing else, the post has conjured up a great image of pre-school Proth declining 'cowboys and indians' for 'crack some miner skulls'. I see him standing triumphantly over a splayed sibling's body ready to receive a personal commendation from Dear Margaret.

He would later be bullied at school but that just strengthened his resolve - and his love for the Conservative Party.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: