Posts: 1,396
Threads: 87
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
7
What is our best X1? I think I’d go with:
Bairstow
Duckett
Root
Stokes
Brook
Buttler
Livingstone
Woakes
Wood
Rashid
Topley
Livingstone and Root to share 10 overs. Can’t understand why they haven’t had a look at Duckett, he scores all round the wicket and excels against spin. I’d have Malan, Curran, Ali and Atkinson to make up the squad. I feel Roy is past his best, Willey too easy to hit once the ball is old, Ahmed unlucky to miss out.
Thoughts?
Being brutally honest
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(09-11-2023, 04:00 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: What is our best X1? I think I’d go with:
Bairstow
Duckett
Root
Stokes
Brook
Buttler
Livingstone
Woakes
Wood
Rashid
Topley
Livingstone and Root to share 10 overs. Can’t understand why they haven’t had a look at Duckett, he scores all round the wicket and excels against spin. I’d have Malan, Curran, Ali and Atkinson to make up the squad. I feel Roy is past his best, Willey too easy to hit once the ball is old, Ahmed unlucky to miss out.
Thoughts?
Not sure on Duckett and Topley in the starting XI. I think I'd prefer Curran ahead of Topley and Roy for Duckett.
Stokes is the conundrum for me. No longer bowling, not mobile for quick runs and maybe wouldn't get a pick if he wasn't Ben Stokes. And yet, like the Ashes series he seems to find these magical moments that make him difficult to leave out though and has already made me eat my own words this summer.
Malan might have a good shout if the conditions suit.
20 overs of spin is also a bit of a risk, so again I think we'll go pitch dependent. We bat deep enough to sometimes add the extra seamer if needed.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 4,668
Threads: 183
Joined: Nov 2022
Reputation:
14
We're reaching the end of a period of brilliant dominance. We're still a very good side and have a great chance of winning the WC again. But it'll end sooner rather than later and the cycle will begin again.
What an incredible era it has been. Hopefully we can get one more tournament win and glory before it naturally comes to an end.
Posts: 98
Threads: 1
Joined: Sep 2023
Reputation:
1
Offering a bit of local perspective (as a YCCC member) I'm a bit baffled as to why Malan was initially preferred to Brook, even given that this was sold as Stokes in/Brook out.
I get the discrepancy in ODI stats, but Malan is 36 and getting steadily worse and Brook is 24 and getting better with each game.
I lack the analytical prowess of some on here (I just really like cricket), but I do know who I would have preferred to see batting at Headingley all summer.
Posts: 676
Threads: 15
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
Bairstow
Roy
Root
Brook
Stokes
Buttler
Livingstone
Curran
Woakes
Rashid
Wood
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
09-12-2023, 08:51 AM
(This post was last modified: 09-12-2023, 09:01 AM by AnelkasBeard.)
(09-11-2023, 05:24 PM)HWBaggie Wrote: Offering a bit of local perspective (as a YCCC member) I'm a bit baffled as to why Malan was initially preferred to Brook, even given that this was sold as Stokes in/Brook out.
I get the discrepancy in ODI stats, but Malan is 36 and getting steadily worse and Brook is 24 and getting better with each game.
I lack the analytical prowess of some on here (I just really like cricket), but I do know who I would have preferred to see batting at Headingley all summer.
Malan's ODI stats respectfully disagree that he's getting worse. There's no way you can leave someone out who's averaging 60 at a decent strike rate, especially as he fills a different role to Brook.
2021 - 5 innings, 134 runs, 44.6 avg, 89 SR. 2 50s. High score - 68*
2022 - 6 innings, 297 runs, 59.4 avg, 100 SR. 2 100s. High score - 134
2023 - 7 innings, 368 runs, 61.3 avg, 91 SR. 2 100s, 2 50s. High score - 118
Just for comparison, Brook's ODI stats below. As I said, very different role, but you can see why they'd pick Malan.
2023 - 5 innings, 113 runs, 22 avg, 80 SR, 1 50. High score - 80
Posts: 98
Threads: 1
Joined: Sep 2023
Reputation:
1
(09-12-2023, 08:51 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (09-11-2023, 05:24 PM)HWBaggie Wrote: Offering a bit of local perspective (as a YCCC member) I'm a bit baffled as to why Malan was initially preferred to Brook, even given that this was sold as Stokes in/Brook out.
I get the discrepancy in ODI stats, but Malan is 36 and getting steadily worse and Brook is 24 and getting better with each game.
I lack the analytical prowess of some on here (I just really like cricket), but I do know who I would have preferred to see batting at Headingley all summer. Malan's ODI stats respectfully disagree that he's getting worse. There's no way you can leave someone out who's averaging 60 at a decent strike rate, especially as he fills a different role to Brook.
2021 - 5 innings, 134 runs, 44.6 avg, 89 SR. 2 50s. High score - 68*
2022 - 6 innings, 297 runs, 59.4 avg, 100 SR. 2 100s. High score - 134
2023 - 7 innings, 368 runs, 61.3 avg, 91 SR. 2 100s, 2 50s. High score - 118
Just for comparison, Brook's ODI stats below. As I said, very different role, but you can see why they'd pick Malan.
2023 - 5 innings, 113 runs, 22 avg, 80 SR, 1 50. High score - 80
I did say I lack the analytical prowess of some on here
Plus I haven't seen Brook swing a bat at Headingley all summer except for the Ashes, and Malan has generally been a bit shit most times I've attended.
Hopefully both have a great WC and that will be another couple of players we don't see for the whole of next summer whilst languishing at the bottom of Div 2.
Posts: 656
Threads: 43
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
3
(09-11-2023, 04:00 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: What is our best X1? I think I’d go with:
Bairstow
Duckett
Root
Stokes
Brook
Buttler
Livingstone
Woakes
Wood
Rashid
Topley
Livingstone and Root to share 10 overs. Can’t understand why they haven’t had a look at Duckett, he scores all round the wicket and excels against spin. I’d have Malan, Curran, Ali and Atkinson to make up the squad. I feel Roy is past his best, Willey too easy to hit once the ball is old, Ahmed unlucky to miss out.
Thoughts? Brook’s been found out in the IPL big mistake picking him for WC!!!..
Things could go horrendously wrong next 6 months in India set him back years
Posts: 6,454
Threads: 192
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(09-12-2023, 03:48 PM)pindgill Wrote: (09-11-2023, 04:00 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote: What is our best X1? I think I’d go with:
Bairstow
Duckett
Root
Stokes
Brook
Buttler
Livingstone
Woakes
Wood
Rashid
Topley
Livingstone and Root to share 10 overs. Can’t understand why they haven’t had a look at Duckett, he scores all round the wicket and excels against spin. I’d have Malan, Curran, Ali and Atkinson to make up the squad. I feel Roy is past his best, Willey too easy to hit once the ball is old, Ahmed unlucky to miss out.
Thoughts? Brook’s been found out in the IPL big mistake picking him for WC!!!..
Things could go horrendously wrong next 6 months in India set him back years 
This may come back and bite you ... hard!
Posts: 1,396
Threads: 87
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
7
(09-11-2023, 07:09 PM)Wotty Wrote: Bairstow
Roy
Root
Brook
Stokes
Buttler
Livingstone
Curran
Woakes
Rashid
Wood
Curran as 3rd seamer? Too risky for me, if his variations are slightly off he’s very hittable. I’m warming to having him at 7 ahead of Livingstone though, as has been said above 20 overs of spin is too much, particularly on early season pitches in India where conditions are more suitable for seamers
Being brutally honest
|